The core answer
Multi-tier discounts should be set by working backwards from the price the end customer will pay, not by adding a profit to cost at each step. Each tier needs a margin that matches the functions it actually performs: holding stock, giving credit, delivery, after-sales and marketing. If the margin is too thin, the tier stops selling or switches brands. If it is too fat, the end price is too high to sell, or your own profit disappears.
The number to watch is the pocket price: your price to the first tier, minus volume rebates, campaign support, returns, the cost of credit and freight, compared with product cost. Many businesses look only at the list price and never see how stacked discounts eat the profit.
The structure belongs in the trade contract: territory or customer allocation, rebate conditions, returns, credit, and price changes on notice. One more caution: requiring resellers to keep a fixed or minimum resale price, or having them agree prices among themselves, can raise trade-competition issues. Have counsel check before you use it. Information as of 21 November 2026.
Who should read which part
| Your stage | Read |
|---|---|
| Before deciding (designing channels and prices) | Sections 1 to 4 for structure and arithmetic, section 7 on recommended prices, and the hypothetical example in section 10 |
| In progress (several tiers already operating) | Section 5 on channel conflict, section 6 on the contract, and the checklist in section 8 |
| When the numbers are off plan (profit gone, tiers undercutting, resellers not selling) | Section 4 to see which discount is eating profit, then sections 5 and 9 for options |
1. How do you build the price from cost to end customer?
Use this order each time you set up or review a structure.
- End-customer price: what the final buyer will pay and what is reasonable against competitors.
- Retailer margin: enough for rent, stock, staff and the cash tied up in goods.
- Middle-tier margin (dealer or sub-distributor) for the functions it performs.
- Master distributor margin: buys in bulk, holds stock and extends credit to lower tiers.
- Your price to the first tier: the end price less every tier's margin.
- Deduct stacked discounts you bear (section 4) to reach the real pocket price.
- Compare with cost to see whether the gross profit covers your overheads and target profit.
If profit is short at step 7, there are four levers: raise the end price if the market accepts it, remove a tier, cut product cost, or trim a stacked discount. Do not squeeze the lower tiers until they cannot survive. They are the ones who actually sell to customers.
If the goal is to lift sales with discounts, the break-even volume maths is in Does discounting to boost sales pay off?. This page does not repeat that formula.
2. What does each tier do, and what should it be paid for?
Margin should follow functions, not job titles. This table is an example split; adapt it to your business.
| Function | Master distributor | Dealer | Retailer |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stocking | Large stock, high cash tied up | Mid-level stock | Only fast-moving lines |
| Credit | Extends credit to dealers, carries bad-debt risk | Extends credit to some shops | Mostly cash sales |
| Delivery | Delivers to dealers on a cycle | Delivers to shops in its area | Delivers to customers or customer collects |
| After-sales | Takes claims from lower tiers, liaises with you | Handles claims and usage advice | Front-of-shop enquiries |
| Marketing | Events and materials overall | Local promotion | Display and advice |
Ask which function a tier no longer performs. If a master distributor no longer stocks or extends credit but keeps the same margin, you are paying for a middleman who adds no value. Conversely, if a tier takes on an extra function, such as after-sales warranty on your behalf, pay for it separately and say so.
Whether to use a broker, an agent or a buy-and-resell distributor affects rights, duties and who owns the goods in transit. See Broker, agent or reseller: which sales model is lawful?. A contract of sale is one under which the seller transfers ownership of property to the buyer for a price (Civil and Commercial Code section 453), so a distributor that buys outright generally sets its own resale price, unlike an agent selling on your behalf.
3. How do you set the discount for each tier?
There are two main methods, often combined.
Method 1: tier discount. Publish separate price lists per tier, for example for the master distributor, dealers and retailers. Tiers that buy larger lots and carry more functions pay less. This is clear, but if prices between tiers are too close, lower tiers will skip a level and buy from the upper tier, and if they are too far apart the upper tier will be tempted to sell direct to end customers.
Method 2: performance discount. Pay extra when conditions are met: a volume rebate on annual purchases, a discount for on-time payment, or support funds for displays that meet your standard. The list price need not keep falling, and you pay only when you get what you wanted.
Principles that apply to both:
- Make performance measurable using figures you can verify from your own records, such as delivered purchase orders, not sales the reseller says it made.
- Set achievable thresholds. A level nobody reaches discourages the channel; a level everyone reaches becomes a permanent discount that motivates nothing.
- Never let a lower tier pay less than the tier above it. Otherwise the structure inverts and goods circulate between tiers.
- Write the criteria before the period starts, not after you see the sales.
Minimum sales targets and what to do when a distributor misses them are covered in Exclusive distributor missed its sales target: options.
4. Which stacked discounts exist and how do they eat profit?
The list price is only a starting point. This table covers the items that are often left out.
| Item | Nature | Watch for |
|---|---|---|
| Volume rebate | Paid after the period when total purchases reach a threshold | Accrue for it in the accounts rather than finding out at payment; define how volume is counted |
| Campaigns and promotions | Temporary price cut or part-funded support | Decide who bears the cut, and whether stock the reseller bought at full price is compensated |
| Returns | Defective, overstocked or expired goods | Set an accepted level, the conditions for taking returns, and who pays return freight |
| Credit | Payment within a set number of days | A cost of money to you and extra bad-debt risk; set a limit and consequences for overdue amounts |
| Freight | You deliver, or it is deducted from price | Agree whether the list price includes freight, and any threshold at which you cover delivery, written as a contract condition |
| Early-payment discount | Discount for paying before the due date | Compare cost with your borrowing rate |
| Marketing support | Cash or goods for displays | Require evidence of use and a time limit |
A common problem is that each discount is approved by a different team: sales approves campaigns, accounting pays rebates, the warehouse takes returns, and nobody sees the total. Keep one table showing every item per tier per period and recalculate the pocket price each quarter.
Tax treatment of discounts and credit notes, including VAT, should be checked by your accountant or auditor before you decide how to issue documents and record them. This page gives no tax rates or figures.
5. What causes channel conflict and how do you prevent it?
Channel conflict arises when one tier feels another is taking its customers or profit. There are three common forms.
| Situation | Consequence | Way to reduce the risk |
|---|---|---|
| A distributor or dealer sells direct to shops or users who are the lower tier's customers | The lower tier loses customers, sells less or quits | Allocate territories or customer groups, state who may sell to whom, and set a price for out-of-group sales |
| One reseller undercuts online below the rest | Shops with premises cannot sell, market price falls, other tiers demand more discount | Set conditions for online selling, such as accurate images and product information, rather than a minimum price (see section 7) |
| You open a direct channel or marketplace store and sell cheaper than resellers | Resellers feel bypassed | State the scope of your direct channel in the contract, and use different products or models for different channels |
Choosing between marketplaces and your own website, and the legal issues of each, are in Selling on a marketplace or your own website. This page covers only the effect on reseller discounts.
Practical safeguards:
- Give each tier its own customers or area and put it in writing.
- Keep lower-tier margins viable from the design stage, not after complaints.
- Be as transparent as you can, for example tell resellers whether you sell direct and which models.
- Provide a complaints route and a verification process. When out-of-area or below-condition selling is found, ask for the facts and correct it as agreed.
6. How do you put this structure into the trade and distribution contracts?
A good price structure that is not in the contract carries little weight in a dispute. These terms should sit in the contract or an annex it refers to.
- Territory or customer groups the reseller may sell to, whether exclusive, and when others may sell into the area.
- Prices and a price-list annex by tier and product, with an effective date and a version number.
- Volume rebates: period, which sales count, tiers and rates, how it is paid or credited by credit note, how returns are netted off, and what makes the entitlement lapse.
- Returns: which goods are accepted, notice period, condition of goods, refund or credit method, and who pays freight.
- Credit: number of days, credit limit, interest or penalty on overdue sums, and the right to hold deliveries above the limit.
- Freight and delivery terms: who bears risk in transit and whether the price includes delivery.
- Campaigns: who funds them, duration, and how remaining stock bought earlier is handled.
- Changes to prices and discounts: your right to change, the written notice period in days, and confirmed orders keeping the old price.
- Restrictions and selling standards: no selling outside the agreed area, no passing off as another brand, display standards.
- Verification and consequences: the right to check purchase records relevant to rebates, the consequence of selling outside the terms, and termination.
Before signing, set up a review route so the right approver and signatory are involved; see Contract review and approval with no legal department.
7. How do recommended prices differ from fixing resale prices, and what should you watch?
Brands often want resellers to sell at similar prices to protect the brand image, but the method used has legal consequences.
- Recommended price. You state a suggested resale price and the reseller decides what to charge. This is generally the framing used.
- Requiring or fixing the resale price. For example forbidding sales below a set price, fixing a price, or threatening to cut supply or discounts if the price is not followed, can raise trade-competition issues.
- Resellers agreeing prices among themselves, within a tier or across tiers, can raise the same issues.
Competition law has its own scope, conditions, exceptions and agency guidance that turn on the facts, such as market share and the nature of the business. This page does not conclude what is or is not permitted in your case. Have counsel review the price structure and the terms before use, and see the agency information at the Trade Competition Commission of Thailand.
A safer practical route is to use tools that do not force prices: performance discounts for resellers who display to your standard, market information shared without compulsion, and margins designed so resellers have no reason to undercut destructively.
8. Checklist for designing and reviewing a discount structure
- Write the price chain from end-customer price to your price to the first tier
- Name each tier's real functions (stock, credit, delivery, after-sales, marketing) and tie its margin to them
- Put every stacked discount in one table and compute the pocket price per tier
- Compare the pocket price with product cost and your overheads
- Check that no lower tier buys more cheaply than the tier above
- Allocate territory or customer groups to each tier in writing
- Write rebate, returns, credit, freight and campaign terms into the contract
- Set written advance notice for price and discount changes
- Have counsel review recommended-price and competition-related terms before use
- Have your accountant review the bookkeeping and tax treatment of discounts and credit notes
- Set a quarterly pocket-price review and an owner
9. When the numbers are off plan, what should you check first?
- Find which discount is growing faster than sales, for example rebates rising because cumulative volume hit a higher tier, or returns rising after a campaign.
- See which tiers are selling across each other. Compare actual selling prices with the agreed framework.
- Look at receivables ageing and reseller stock. Overstock means resellers will cut prices to clear it, pulling the market price down.
- Compare the contract with what happened: does each discount paid have a basis in the contract, and does the contract allow changes?
- Adjust the structure by giving notice as the contract requires, not suddenly. If the contract gives no right to change unilaterally, negotiate and sign an amendment.
If a reseller is missing targets or ignoring terms, see the options in Exclusive distributor missed its sales target.
10. Hypothetical example: a home-appliance brand selling through three tiers
This is a hypothetical example, not a real case or business. All figures are illustrative, and all prices exclude VAT.
A brand has a product cost of 60 baht per unit and sells through a master distributor, dealers and retailers. The market accepts an end price of 160 baht.
Step 1: work back from the end price (list prices)
| Tier | Buys at (baht) | Sells at (baht) | Gross margin (baht) | Margin on selling price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Brand | cost 60 | 100 | 40 | 40.0% |
| Master distributor | 100 | 115 | 15 | 13.0% |
| Dealer | 115 | 130 | 15 | 11.5% |
| Retailer | 130 | 160 | 30 | 18.8% |
Step 2: deduct stacked discounts the brand bears, per unit (illustrative)
| Item | Baht per unit |
|---|---|
| List price to master distributor | 100 |
| Volume rebate 3% | -3 |
| Campaign support | -2 |
| Returns provision 1% | -1 |
| Cost of credit (45 days) | -1 |
| Freight paid by the brand | -3 |
| Real pocket price | 90 |
| Product cost | -60 |
| Brand gross profit | 30 (about 33% of pocket price) |
On the list price the brand appears to make 40 baht but really keeps 30. Stacked discounts take a quarter. The master distributor receives the 3 baht rebate, so its real cost is 97 baht and its real margin rises to 18 baht per unit.
Step 3: check every tier remains viable (assumed running costs per unit)
| Tier | Real margin | Cost of its functions | Net left |
|---|---|---|---|
| Master distributor | 18 | 10 (stock, credit, delivery) | 8 |
| Dealer | 15 | 8 | 7 |
| Retailer | 30 | 22 | 8 |
Step 4: someone sells online at 140 baht. A shop with premises that bought at 130 baht is left with a 10 baht margin against 22 baht of running cost. It will stop selling or demand more discount. Options to consider: a separate model or bundle for online channels, a performance discount for shops that display to standard, online-selling conditions that are not a minimum-price requirement, and a review by counsel before use. Then write the result into the contract and give the agreed notice.
Common misunderstandings
- "Set a fixed margin for every tier and you're done." Margin must follow real functions. A tier that neither stocks nor extends credit should not earn what one that does earns.
- "List price is profit." Real profit is the pocket price after every stacked discount.
- "A bigger discount makes resellers sell more." If the discount is not tied to performance and everyone gets it, it motivates nothing and just hands over margin.
- "We can always make resellers sell at one price." Requiring a fixed or minimum resale price can raise trade-competition issues. Have counsel review before use.
- "Resellers agreeing prices among themselves is their business." Price agreements between resellers can raise the same issues, and the brand should not coordinate or encourage them.
- "It's our price, so we can change discounts any time." If the contract gives no right or no notice is given, a unilateral change risks a dispute.
- Limits of this guide. It does not cover competition law in detail, the tax treatment of discounts, or industry-specific rules. All figures and ratios are examples; use your own. Information as of 21 November 2026.
Further reading
- Broker, agent or reseller: which sales model is lawful?
- Selling on a marketplace or your own website
- Does discounting to boost sales pay off? Break-even volume
- Exclusive distributor missed its sales target: options
- Contract review and approval with no legal department
A sound discount structure starts from the end price, works back by each tier's real functions, is measured at the pocket price, and is written into the contract, with counsel checking any resale-price terms before use.
We help design the channel model and discount structure, and draft and review distributor and trade contracts, including checking the competition and pricing terms involved. We are not accountants or tax advisers and cannot promise commercial results or the outcome of negotiations with resellers. Fees depend on the stage of the matter and the work required. Send us the documents first, and we will give you the scope of work and fees in writing before starting. Call +66 92 254 2045 or send us the details. See also Business plan and Contracts and documents.
This guide is published by Suwanvara Law Firm — a Khon Kaen law firm established in 1986. General information only, not legal advice on a specific matter.

