Skip to main content
SUWANVARA LAWFIRM
Suwanvara Law Firm Co., Ltd.
SUWANVARA LAWFIRM
SUWANVARA LAWFIRM
Suwanvara Law Firm Co., Ltd.
Business Law

Giving Employees Share-Linked Rewards Without Transferring Real Shares: Phantom Shares and Cash-Settled SARs in Thailand

Phantom Shares and SARs are contracts to pay cash by reference to a share value; the employee does not become a shareholder. This guide covers the payout formula, valuing unlisted shares, vesting, what happens on resignation or dismissal, and the payout on a sale of the company.

Suwanvara Law Firm— Business Law TeamNovember 21, 202616 min read
Giving Employees Share-Linked Rewards Without Transferring Real Shares: Phantom Shares and Cash-Settled SARs in Thailand

The core answer

If you want key employees to share in the growth of the company without transferring real shares, the usual tool is a Phantom Shares or SAR (Stock Appreciation Right) plan. These are cash payment contracts that use a share value only as the measuring stick. The employee does not hold shares, so there is no entry in the shareholder register, no vote and no right to dividends as a shareholder.

A plan works only if the contract answers five questions: the payout formula, how share value is determined, the conditions for earning the right, when the company must pay, and what happens when the employee leaves or the company is sold. Whatever is not written down causes nearly every dispute, because employees often believe they are "part owners" while the company sees a form of bonus.

This page covers cash-settled plans only. For plans where the employee receives real shares, RSUs or options, see Employee share plans and RSUs in Thailand, which already covers tax, payroll and the limits of shares in a private company. It is not repeated here.

Who should read which part

Your situationSections to read
Planning: nobody has been granted anything yetSections 1 to 4 to choose the type and the formula, then the checklist at the end
Negotiating: an employee has asked for rights or a draft existsSections 3 to 8, especially the leaver table and the payout on a sale
Already done: rights have been granted but the contract is unclear, someone is leaving or a sale is comingSections 4, 6, 7 and 8, then the hypothetical example

1. How are Phantom Shares different from real shares?

Real shares make the holder a shareholder. Phantom Shares do not. The employee only has a contractual claim against the company for money.

PointReal sharesPhantom Shares / SAR
OwnershipShareholder, named in the registerNot a shareholder; holder of a contractual right
Vote at shareholder meetingsYesNo
DividendsAs resolved by the shareholdersNot as a shareholder; a dividend-equivalent exists only if the contract provides one
Shareholder rights under company lawYesNo; only what the contract and other laws give
Who has to payNo one "pays" a shareholder; they receive profit distributions or sale proceedsThe company is the debtor and must find the cash
Effect on company structureCompany-law formalities applyNo change to the shareholder register

On dividends, section 1201 of the Civil and Commercial Code provides that a dividend may be declared only by resolution of a general meeting, and dividends are paid to shareholders. A holder of Phantom Shares alone therefore has no dividend right under that section. If the company wants to give an equivalent amount, it must be a contractual right, and it should say it is paid only when the company actually pays a dividend.

If the aim is for an employee to become a real shareholder, for example to share control or shareholder rights, use real shares. See Minority shareholder rights for what those rights are.

2. Phantom Shares or SAR?

The two differ in what is multiplied.

  • Phantom Shares (full value): the employee receives a number of notional shares. At payout the company pays the value per share times the number of notional shares. The employee is paid even if the value has not risen since grant.
  • SAR (growth only): a base price is fixed at grant. At payout the company pays the difference between the value per share then and the base price, times the number of units. If value has not risen, nothing is paid.
PointPhantom SharesSAR
Paid if value is unchangedYesNo
Cost to the companyHigher, tied to full valueLower, only the increase
How it feels to the employeeLike a bonus tied to valueLike a share option that needs no purchase money
SuitsRetention, with a steadier rewardSharing only growth that happens after the plan starts

The label binds no one. A court or counterparty will look at the formula and conditions actually written. Choose the type first, then write a formula that matches it.

3. How should the payout formula be written?

Someone who did not take part in the negotiation should be able to read the contract and reach the same number without asking anyone. Elements to include:

ElementWhat to fix
Number of unitsNotional shares or SAR units granted, and the grant date
Base price (SAR only)Value per share at grant and how it was obtained
Value per share at payoutWhich valuation method, see section 4
Share count usedIssued shares only, or including shares reserved for issue, because this changes value per share
CapA cap per person or per plan, so the liability does not exceed what the company can bear
AdjustmentsHow the units change on a capital increase, share split, share consolidation or new shares
Payment scheduleOne payment or instalments, see section 6

A common mistake is writing "entitled to 2% of the company" without saying 2% of what, as of which date, before or after debt, and whether shares later issued to a new investor change the percentage. Use a fixed number of units and write the adjustment formula for changes in the capital structure.

4. For an unlisted company, who sets the share value, and how?

A company that is not listed has no daily market price, so the valuation method must be agreed in advance. Options in use:

MethodAdvantageWatch out for
Fixed formula, e.g. past profit or revenue times an agreed multipleCan be calculated in-house, no valuer neededThe multiple must be reasonable for the business, and the contract must say which financial year and whether one-off items are included
Price from the latest real funding round or share saleReflects a real marketThere may be no new round for years, so a fallback is needed
Independent valuerReduces disputes about neutralityCosts money; say who chooses, who pays and whether the figure binds
Board or shareholder resolutionQuickThe employee may feel management is setting the figure in its own favour, so provide a way to challenge it

Whichever method is chosen, state three things: who values, when (for example each year-end, or only when a payout event occurs), and what happens if the employee disagrees, such as review by a second independent valuer. The employee who asks for a review should be able to see the data needed, as far as this does not expose business secrets beyond what is reasonable, and a confidentiality undertaking should accompany it.

The valuation should also be consistent with the method used between shareholders, such as a buy-back arrangement, so that an employee does not receive a different figure from shareholders without a reason.

5. How should vesting conditions be set?

A right that has been granted does not mean cash is due immediately. The contract usually ties payment to conditions. Under section 182 of the Civil and Commercial Code, a condition is a term that makes a juristic act take effect or cease to have effect upon a future event that may or may not happen. Typical types:

  • By length of service: the right vests in stages, for example in equal parts each year, possibly with an initial period during which nothing vests (a cliff), as agreed.
  • By performance or company targets: for example revenue, profit or closing a key deal. The measure and the source of the figures must be defined so they can be checked.
  • By event: the right vests on a sale of the company or a listing. This means that if the event never happens the employee may receive nothing, and the employee should be told this clearly at the start.
  • Combined: the person must serve the full period and the event must also occur.

Three more points to write down: whether time continues to count if the employee is transferred or moves to another employer in the group; whether long leave such as maternity or sick leave counts as service; and whether the company may postpone or change conditions unilaterally (if so, limit it by a framework, do not make it absolute).

6. When must the company pay, and where does the money come from?

Unlike real shares, the burden to pay rests on the company, so cash flow must be considered before any right is granted.

Payment triggerAdvantageWatch out for
A fixed date, such as year 3 or 5The employee can planThe company needs cash on that date; a sharp rise in value may make the payout heavy
On a sale or listing of the companyFunds come from the deal itselfIt is uncertain when, or whether, it will happen
When the employee leavesEnds the relationshipNeeds the formula in section 7
Paid in instalmentsEases cash flow pressureSay what happens to remaining instalments if the employee resigns mid-way

Set an overall cap for the plan, set aside reserves or provisions as the accountant advises, and state how payment can be deferred or staged if the company lacks funds, and whether interest applies. Otherwise the employee has a contractual right but no clear way to collect.

7. What happens to the rights if the employee resigns or is dismissed?

This must be set out in a table, or it will be argued every time. The usual terms are good leaver and bad leaver. An example grouping, adjustable as agreed:

Reason for leavingVested portionUnvested portion
Retirement, illness preventing further work, or dismissal without fault of the employeeKept, or bought back under the formulaLapses, or vests pro rata to time served, as agreed
Voluntary resignationKept, bought back, or reduced under an agreed formulaLapses
Dismissal for serious misconduct or a material breach, such as fraud or leaking secretsForfeited or heavily reduced, if the contract says so clearly and the facts fit the definitionLapses
Moving to a competitorDepends on the non-compete terms agreedLapses

Points to state clearly:

  • The definition of each leaver category and who decides. If the company alleges misconduct, there must be verifiable grounds, not bare discretion.
  • The time for payment or exercise after the employee leaves, for example payment within a set number of days, or waiting until the original payout date.
  • Forfeiture should be proportionate to the fault. A clause that forfeits everything whatever the reason may be challenged as excessive or unfair, and a court may weigh the facts, so have a lawyer review this clause before use.
  • Relationship with labour law. If the plan payment resembles wages or consideration for work, it may affect how severance or other entitlements are calculated. This depends on the facts and the drafting, so take advice before settling the wording and see Annual bonus vs performance bonus.
  • Non-compete, non-solicitation of customers or staff. If tied to the plan, draft them separately and reasonably. See Non-compete clauses after resignation.

8. If the company is sold or control changes, how is the employee paid?

If this is not written, a buyer may acquire shares or assets without taking over the plan, and the employee may receive nothing. Terms to include:

PointWhat to fix
Events counted as a change of controlA sale of shares above a stated percentage, a merger, a sale of key assets, or a listing
Value usedThe actual sale price per share after deal costs and agreed deductions, or a valuation figure
TimingPaid together with shareholders, or in line with what the buyer actually pays, including escrow or holdback amounts
AccelerationWhether unvested units vest immediately, in full or in part, and what happens if the employee is dismissed shortly after the deal
Buyer takes over the planIf there is no acceleration, whether the buyer or company must carry the plan, or it is paid out with the deal first
Information to the employeeNotice of the figures used when a deal occurs, as far as confidentiality undertakings to the buyer allow

Buyers often review such plans in due diligence because they are liabilities that do not show up in the shareholder register. A vaguely drafted plan can lower the price or delay closing. For the wider picture see Share purchase vs asset purchase.

9. Who should check tax and accounting?

Payments under the plan affect both sides: the employee's income tax, withholding and remittance, social security contributions, and the company's accounting for the liability or expense under the applicable accounting standards. We do not give tax rates or confirm tax outcomes. Have the company's accountant or auditor check this before the plan starts, and have them review the draft contract, because some wording affects how the payment is classified. Basic information is on the Revenue Department site.

The lawyer's work alongside the accountant is to draft the contract to match what the accountant needs, for example stating that the company withholds tax from payments as required by law and that the recipient bears their own tax.

Checklist before issuing a plan

  • Choose the type (Phantom Shares or SAR) and record why real shares are not used
  • Name each participant, the number of units, grant date and base price (for a SAR)
  • Write the payout formula with a cap per person and per plan
  • Fix the valuation method, the valuer, the frequency and how to challenge the figure
  • Write the vesting conditions (time, performance, event) and the effect of leave or transfer
  • Define good leaver and bad leaver with the result for each
  • Write the change-of-control terms, acceleration and whether the buyer takes over the plan
  • State that the holder is not a shareholder, has no vote and no shareholder dividend unless an extra payment right is written in
  • Set adjustments for capital increases, share splits and consolidations
  • Have the accountant check tax, withholding, social security and booking of the liability
  • Have the directors or authorised signatories approve the plan and keep each signed contract with the attached formula
  • Let the employee read and ask questions before signing, and keep proof of delivery

Hypothetical example: a key employee asks for "3% of the shares"

This is not a real case. The names and figures are invented for illustration only.

A company has two shareholders and is not listed. The sales manager asks for "3% of the shares". The shareholders do not want another name in the register, so they offer 3,000 Phantom Shares out of 100,000 issued shares. The contract says value per share is the average net profit of the last two years times a multiple of 5, divided by the number of issued shares at the payment date. The rights vest by one third each year over three years, and are paid at the end of year five or on a sale of the company, whichever comes first.

Suppose at the end of year five the average net profit over two years is 10 million baht. Under the formula the company value is 50 million baht and value per share is 500 baht. The payout is 3,000 times 500, or 1.5 million baht (all figures are hypothetical, not data of any real company, and before tax).

Situations that send the parties back to the contract:

  • Resignation at the end of year two: two thirds of the units have vested. If the contract says a voluntary leaver keeps only the vested part, the person holds 2,000 units, valued at the payment date, not at the resignation date. If the contract does not say which date, the point can be argued, so state the date and method.
  • Sale of the company in year four: if the contract is silent on acceleration, the unvested part may lapse and the buyer may not assume it. If it says full acceleration on a sale, the employee is paid at the actual sale price less the agreed deductions.
  • The employee thinks the value is too low: if the contract allows review by an independent valuer, use it. If not, the dispute turns on whether management's calculation was correct, which the contract should have addressed in advance.

The lesson is that "3%" tells you nothing on its own. What binds is the number of units, the formula, the conditions and the result on leaving or sale.

Common misunderstandings

  • "Phantom Shares are just another way of giving shares." No. The employee is not a shareholder but holds a contractual right to cash under a formula, so there is no vote and no dividend right as a shareholder.
  • "They are not real shares, so the contract can be short." The opposite. With no shareholder register and no company law to fill gaps, everything depends on the contract. If it is too short, the formula, leavers and company sale become disputes.
  • "Calling it a bonus lets the company change the terms at will." The label does not decide rights. Once rights are agreed in a contract, the company cannot always change them alone. Check whether the contract leaves room.
  • "On resignation the rights always lapse entirely." Not a fixed rule. The vested part may be kept, bought back or forfeited depending on the contract, and total forfeiture may be challenged. Match the consequence to the reason.
  • "If the company is sold the employee will get the share they were told about." A spoken understanding is not enough. A contract must say what it is calculated on, when it is paid and whether the buyer takes the plan on.
  • "Cash payment means tax works like a bonus." Tax and accounting depend on the facts and wording. Have the accountant check; do not assume.
  • "This plan replaces shareholder structuring." It does not. If someone is to share control or shareholder rights, real shares under company law are needed.

Scope of this guide: it covers only cash-settled plans linked to the share value of an unlisted Thai company. It does not cover real shares, RSUs of a foreign parent, listed public companies, or companies whose shareholder agreement or joint-venture contract restricts rewards to employees, which must be reviewed first. Information as of 21 November 2026.

Further reading

Phantom Shares and SARs deliver share-linked rewards without making the employee a shareholder, but everything rests on the contract: write the formula, valuation method, conditions and the result on leaving or sale before any right is granted.

We help companies draft share-linked compensation plans and agreements, and check them against employment contracts, shareholder agreements and the company's approval process, keeping them clearly separate from real share grants and shareholder rights. We are not accountants or tax advisers, so we do not give figures or confirm tax outcomes; the company's accountant should check that part. We cannot promise the outcome of a dispute with an employee or a buyer. Fees depend on the stage of the matter and the work required. Send us the documents first, and we will give you the scope of work and fees in writing before we start. Call +66 92 254 2045 or send us the details. See also HR documents and corporate secretarial.


This guide is published by Suwanvara Law Firm — a Khon Kaen law firm established in 1986. General information only, not legal advice on a specific matter.

Frequently asked questions

Do Phantom Shares make an employee a shareholder?+

No. The employee only holds a contractual right to cash calculated from a notional share value. The name is not in the shareholder register, and there is no vote, no dividend as a shareholder and no company-law shareholder right. If you want the employee to receive something like a dividend, the contract must say so expressly as an extra payment right.

What is the difference between Phantom Shares and a SAR?+

Phantom Shares usually pay the full value of a number of notional shares. A SAR (Stock Appreciation Right) pays only the increase in value above a base price fixed when the right is granted. Both are settled in cash. The label matters less than the formula written in the contract.

How is the share value set if the company is not listed?+

The method must be fixed in the contract from the start: for example a formula based on profit or revenue times an agreed multiple, the price from the latest real funding round or share sale, or an independent valuer named or chosen by an agreed method, with a stated frequency and a way to challenge the figure. A missing formula is the main cause of disputes.

If the employee resigns, are they still paid?+

It depends on the contract. Usually the unvested part lapses on resignation, while the vested part may be kept, bought back by the company under a formula, or forfeited. To separate a good leaver from someone who committed serious misconduct, define both cases clearly and state the result of each.

If the company is sold, when and how much is the holder paid?+

It depends on the change-of-control terms. The contract should define which events count as a sale, which price is used and what is deducted, whether payment is made together with shareholders or in line with amounts the buyer holds back, and whether the buyer must take over the plan. If none of this is written, the employee may receive nothing.

How are payouts under this plan taxed?+

Have the company's accountant or auditor check it, because it affects the employee's tax, withholding, social security contributions and the company's accounting for the liability. This guide gives no tax rates or figures.

Lawyer-client handshake symbolizing trust at Suwanvara Law Firm

Ready to hear your story

Get an initial consultation with one of our experienced attorneys.