Skip to main content
SUWANVARA LAWFIRM
Suwanvara Law Firm Co., Ltd.
SUWANVARA LAWFIRM
SUWANVARA LAWFIRM
Suwanvara Law Firm Co., Ltd.
Civil Litigation Guide

Company Debtor With No Land or Cars: What Else Can a Creditor Trace and Attach in Thailand

A creditor's guide when a company debtor shows no land or vehicles: money its customers owe it, rent, shares in other companies, equipment and stock, licences and rights, and what can be done before suing versus after judgment.

Suwanvara Law Firm— Civil Litigation & Enforcement TeamNovember 20, 202616 min read
Company Debtor With No Land or Cars: What Else Can a Creditor Trace and Attach in Thailand

The core answer

A company with no land and no cars may still have assets a creditor can pursue. A running business usually has money owed by customers, rent coming in, shares in other companies, machinery and stock, and sometimes rights that have value. Chasing a company therefore means checking both assets and claims, not just counting offices and vehicles.

Three cautions apply. First, a company's assets are not the assets of its directors or shareholders. Second, trade documents such as quotations, purchase orders and invoices are not the same as a right to be paid. Third, making the debtor's customers pay you instead can only be done through an order of the court or the enforcement officer. A creditor who writes to them directly gets no legal effect and may cause harm.

This guide separates what can be done before suing, while the case is pending and after winning, because the tools and the authority differ at each stage. Actual recovery depends on whether the asset exists, has value and is free of other creditors' rights. Nothing here promises that assets will be found.

Who this guide is for

Your positionMain sections
Not yet sued1, 2, 4, 8, 9 (checking information that can be obtained lawfully and deciding before suing)
Case pending5, 7, 8 (delivery disputes, interim measures, assets moved away)
Judgment won3, 6, 7, 8, 10 (attachment, seizure and court examination)

1. How do a company's assets differ from its directors' and shareholders' assets?

A limited company is a juristic person separate from its shareholders. A shareholder is liable to the company only for unpaid share value under section 1096 of the Civil and Commercial Code. If the contract was made with the company, the judgment is normally against the company, and enforcement is mainly against the company's assets.

  • A director's home, car and personal savings are not company assets.
  • A director becomes personally liable only on a legal basis, such as a written guarantee, being an unlimited partner in a partnership, or the company having transferred assets away in a way a court can revoke.
  • Money the company lent to a director or an affiliate may be a claim of the company that a creditor can pursue (see section 3).

Pursuing directors personally has its own conditions. See the guide on directors' personal assets and whether a resigned director is still liable under a personal guarantee.

2. No land or cars found: what should you check next?

Not finding land or cars does not mean the company has nothing. Many businesses rent their premises, finance their vehicles and hold value as receivables, stock and equipment. Work through the groups below.

GroupExamplesEnforcement route after judgment
Claims against othersMoney customers owe, rent the company receives, loans to directors or affiliatesAttachment under sections 316 to 321
Shares and investmentsShares in other limited companiesSeizure under section 307, with notice to the issuing company
MovablesMachinery, office equipment, stock, raw materialsSeizure under section 303
Registered movablesBoats and similar registered itemsSeizure under section 304 with notice to the registrar
Intellectual propertyTrademarks, patents, copyrightSeizure under sections 308 and 309
Leaseholds and licencesLeasehold rights, concessions, licences with valueSeizure under sections 310 and 311

The table shows which kinds of asset the law allows to be seized or attached. It does not show that your debtor has any of them, or that they are free of encumbrances. Anything you find must still be proved to belong to the company and to still exist.

Start with the financial statements

The financial statements a company files, including the statement of financial position and notes, are a good starting point. One route is DBD DataWarehouse+ of the Department of Business Development, which shows juristic person data, financial statements and financial ratios as published. What is published may not be current on the day you look, and statements are a historical picture, not cash on hand today.

Once you have the statements, look for these items and note where more information would have to come from.

  • Trade receivables (who owes the company), the clearest source of claims.
  • Investments in other companies, or loans to directors and affiliates.
  • Inventory, land, buildings and equipment shown in the accounts.
  • Notes on mortgaged or pledged assets, which affect what a creditor can recover.
  • Right-of-use assets or leased assets the company holds but does not own (see section 6).

For a deeper look at the line items, and why company debts are hard to collect, see company financial statements and assets.

Bank deposits are what creditors think of first, but there is no public channel through which a creditor can check a company's account balance. A bank named in documents the debtor itself issued is a clue, but it does not tell you how much is there.

3. Customer claims, rent and other counterparties: how are they attached?

Where the company has a right to be paid by a third party, its creditor may ask the court or the enforcement officer, at the enforcement stage, for an order attaching that claim.

The key rules of sections 316 to 321 of the Civil Procedure Code are these.

  • The attachment order (section 316) is served on both the debtor and the third party. The debtor may not dispose of the claim, the third party may not pay the debtor, and payment is to be made to the court or officer when due.
  • A dispute is not a bar (section 317). A claim may be attached even if disputed, limited, conditional or uncertain in amount.
  • Periodic income such as rent (section 318). The attachment covers amounts that fall due later.
  • Security for the claim (section 319). The effect extends to a mortgage or pledge securing the attached claim.
  • After attachment (section 320). The debtor's later transfer or change of the claim cannot be set up against the creditor, and a third party who pays as the order directs is discharged.
  • If the third party does not pay (section 321). The creditor may ask the court to inquire and order the third party to pay or compensate, if the claim is found to exist and be enforceable.
  • Objections (section 325). The third party may object within 15 days of the order, and the part objected to is held up until the court rules.

The mechanics for money owed to the debtor under periodic contracts (such as contract fees) are in attaching money owed to a debtor by a contract counterparty. This guide concentrates on working out what claims the company has and how to check the evidence.

A creditor must not write to the debtor's customers on its own

Attachment goes through legal process. A creditor should not send letters or phone the debtor company's customers telling them to stop paying or to pay the creditor, because:

  • A creditor's own letter binds no one. If the third party pays the debtor anyway, it is discharged as normal.
  • If the claim or the pressure turns out to be wrong, the creditor may be liable for the damage (section 285 covers wrongful or excessive seizure or attachment) and may harm business relationships.
  • Shaming or pressuring a debtor's customers is not a lawful way to collect. See debt collection rules for creditors.

4. Quotation, purchase order, invoice and a real right to payment: what is the difference?

The documents a debtor company holds do not prove its customer must pay. Test the claim step by step.

DocumentWhat it can showWhat it does not yet show
QuotationThe company offered a priceThe customer agreed to buy
Purchase order or contractThe customer agreed to buy or hireThe company has delivered in full
Delivery note or work acceptanceDelivery or acceptance took placePayment is due and undisputed
InvoiceThe company demanded paymentThe customer accepts the amount
Tax invoice or ledger entryAn accounting record existsThe sum is still owed
Customer's written confirmation of the balanceThe customer admits the debtWhether it is due, and any set-off

You can check these from documents the debtor gave you in the past, contracts you have seen, financial statement data and, once in court, from evidence or from the court's examination of the debtor after judgment. Do not decide on the strength of a single invoice.

5. What if the customer says the work was incomplete or the goods were faulty?

A dispute between the company and its customer affects both how real the claim is and when attachment will produce money.

  • Under section 317 a dispute does not stop an attachment order from issuing.
  • But the customer may object to the court within 15 days of receiving the order (section 325) and may argue that payment is not yet due, work was incomplete or damages should be set off. The objected part is held up until the court rules.
  • What the customer finally has to pay may be less than the invoice, reduced by damages the debtor company owes the customer.

So an invoice of 1 million baht (an illustrative figure) in the debtor's accounts does not mean you will receive 1 million baht from an attachment. Where you can, check first whether the debtor and that customer are in a dispute.

6. Shares, machinery, stock, leaseholds and assets held but not owned

After winning, the enforcement officer seizes company assets according to type (sections 303 to 314).

  • Shares in other companies (section 307): the officer notifies the debtor and the issuing company and has the registrar record the seizure. What it is worth depends on the issuing company's condition.
  • Machinery, equipment and stock (section 303): seized and kept, with notice of the list to the debtor and the person holding them. You need evidence that the asset belongs to the company and where it is.
  • Registered assets (section 304): seized by notice to the registrar.
  • Intellectual property, leaseholds and licences (sections 308 to 311): these can be seized by law, but a creditor must judge whether they can really be sold. Some licences carry special conditions.

In practice, what a company uses is not always what it owns. Before seizing, check:

  • Hire purchase or leasing. If the equipment still belongs to the leasing company, the debtor only possesses it.
  • Goods held for others or processed under contract. Stock a customer has deposited is not the company's.
  • Rented premises and equipment. A creditor cannot seize and sell them.
  • Mortgaged or pledged assets. The mortgagee or registered holder ranks ahead of ordinary creditors. See what happens when the land is mortgaged.

A person who says the seized asset is theirs can file an objection within 60 days of seizure under section 323. Seizing the wrong asset can expose the creditor to a damages claim under section 285, so have proof of ownership before pointing out an asset. If several creditors want the same asset, see multiple creditors, same asset: who is paid first.

7. Claims the company neglects to enforce, and assets moved away

The company does not collect from its own customer

Where the debtor fails or refuses to exercise a claim, to the creditor's prejudice, section 233 of the Civil and Commercial Code lets the creditor exercise that claim in its own name to protect its rights, other than rights purely personal to the debtor. Under section 234 the creditor must have the debtor summoned into that case.

This is a further lawsuit, with conditions, and it needs evidence that the company's claim really exists. It suits cases with clear evidence and enough value to justify the cost. It is not a shortcut around attaching claims after judgment.

Assets transferred to someone else

If the company transfers assets to a director, a relative or another company so that creditors cannot reach them, the creditor may ask the court to revoke the act under section 237 of the Civil and Commercial Code. The main conditions are:

  • The act concerns property rights, and the debtor did it knowing it would prejudice creditors.
  • If the transferee gave value, the transferee must also have known at the time. If the transfer was a gift, the debtor's knowledge alone is enough.
  • Third parties who acquired rights in good faith before the revocation suit are protected (section 238).
  • The suit must be brought within 1 year of the creditor learning the ground, and in any event within 10 years of the act (section 240).

While the case is pending, if there is reason to think the debtor will transfer or hide assets, the creditor may ask the court for an interim measure under section 254, such as seizing or attaching the debtor's property, including money owed to the debtor by third parties, before judgment. The court orders this only if the claim appears to have reasonable merit and the grounds in section 255 exist. Evidence is required and it is not always granted. See debtors transferring assets.

8. Before suing, while pending and after winning: what can you do?

StageCan doCannot do, or take care
Not yet suedCheck information that can be obtained lawfully, such as the company's filed financial statements, documents the debtor issued itself, contracts, and bankruptcy or rehabilitation status; assess whether suing is worth itNo seizure or attachment, no writ of execution; a creditor cannot instruct the debtor's customers
Case pendingAsk for an interim measure (section 254) if section 255 grounds existThe court may refuse; evidence of the risk is needed and the creditor is liable for loss if the request was wrong
Judgment wonRequest a writ of execution, seize assets, attach claims, ask the court to examine the debtor or others about assets (section 277)The result depends on the assets, other creditors' rights and objections

The 10-year rule after judgment (section 274) has several parts: the 10-year period, special rules for future or instalment debts, and continuation only for assets or claims already acted on within the period. It should not be shortened to "one writ lets you seize new assets forever". See 10-year enforcement of judgments.

9. In what order should you check, given the information and budget you have?

This order is a general guide. Adjust it to the size of the debt and the documents you hold.

  • Step 1: what you already have. Review contracts, purchase orders, invoices, emails, the names of customers and plant locations the debtor mentioned, banks named in documents the debtor issued, and who signed the contract.
  • Step 2: public data. Check juristic status and the latest financial statements through the DBD system, check land and vehicles through lawful channels, and check whether bankruptcy or rehabilitation is pending (section 10).
  • Step 3: is it worth it? Compare the debt with the assets you can see, the disputes you expect and other creditors' rights. See whether tracing assets before suing is worth it.
  • Step 4: sue, and seek an interim measure if grounds exist. Do this when there is evidence the debtor is moving or hiding assets.
  • Step 5: after winning. Request the writ, point out the assets and claims you found, and ask the court to examine the debtor under section 277 if you do not know the assets or doubt ownership.

10. What if the company is in bankruptcy or rehabilitation?

Check this before suing. If the debtor is in a bankruptcy or business rehabilitation process, the way to pursue the debt may change to filing a claim in that process rather than suing and enforcing in the ordinary way, and it can affect any seizure or attachment already made. It must be checked case by case. The process-specific detail is in the creditor's guide to bankruptcy and rehabilitation and bankruptcy and rehabilitation.

11. What documents should you prepare?

  • Contract, quotation, purchase order, delivery note, invoices and records of chasing payment
  • The debtor's full registered name and registration number, who signed, and their authority
  • The latest financial statements you could obtain, with the date you checked
  • Names of customers, trading partners, landlords or tenants known from actual documents
  • Assets you have seen yourself, such as machinery, stock, factory or warehouse locations, with photos and dates
  • The result of your bankruptcy or rehabilitation check
  • Evidence of any suspicious transfer (date, transferee, price)
  • The judgment and the order to comply, if you have won

12. Hypothetical example: a contractor owed by a construction company

This is a hypothetical example to illustrate the points. It is not a real client and the figures are illustrative.

Company A owes a contractor 1,200,000 baht. The contractor finds no land or vehicles in A's name, but A's latest financial statements show trade receivables and inventory, and a contract the contractor has seen shows A building for several other customers.

Before suing, the contractor checks the financial statements and A's bankruptcy or rehabilitation status. The contractor sues and wins, A does not comply with the order, so the contractor requests a writ and points out that customer B still owes A instalments for work done. The enforcement officer issues an attachment order. B objects that some instalments are not yet due because the work has not passed inspection. The objected part is held up, the undisputed part continues, and the contractor may recover only part of the sum.

What the example shows: the claim figure in the accounts is not the amount you will receive. Attachment is possible even with a dispute, but money arrives later, and other creditors may also claim a share of the proceeds.

Common misunderstandings

MisunderstandingCorrection
A company with no land or cars has nothing to seizeIt may still have claims, shares, equipment, stock and rights that can be seized or attached, though real recovery depends on what exists
You can always pursue the directors because the directors are the companyThe company is a separate juristic person. Personal liability needs a basis such as a written guarantee
An invoice to the customer is money that can surely be attachedIt is trade evidence. You must check delivery, due date and absence of disputes or set-off
A creditor can simply write to the debtor's customers telling them to pay the creditorAn attachment order of the court or officer is required. A creditor's own letter has no binding effect and risks liability
After judgment everything can be attached at onceA writ must be requested properly, third parties can object and other creditors may share
Tracing services can tell you a company's bank balanceThere is no public channel for a creditor to check balances. Data available is historical and may be out of date

Further reading

A company debtor with no land or cars may still have claims, shares, equipment and stock to check, but you must keep company assets apart from directors' assets, test each claim against real documents, and attach only through an order of the court or the enforcement officer.

We review documents and the information that can be checked through lawful channels, assess whether suing or enforcement is worth it, file suit, seek interim measures where grounds exist, request enforcement, follow up with the enforcement officer, handle objections and distribution, and negotiate instalments after seizure or attachment. We do not search bank accounts, we do not use unlawful data, and we cannot guarantee that assets will be found or that a creditor will be paid. The outcome depends on the assets, other people's rights and the facts of the case. Our fees depend on the stage of the case and the work required. Send us your documents first and we will confirm the scope of work and fees in writing before we start. For an initial consultation call +66 92 254 2045 or send us the details. See asset tracing and civil litigation.


This guide is published by Suwanvara Law Firm — a Khon Kaen law firm established in 1986. General information only, not legal advice on a specific matter.

Frequently asked questions

If the debtor is a company with no land or cars, does that mean enforcement is impossible?+

Not necessarily. A company may be owed money by its customers, receive rent, hold shares in other companies, or own equipment, stock or licences, and the Civil Procedure Code allows seizure or attachment by asset type (sections 303 to 314 and 316 to 321). Whether money is actually recovered depends on whether the asset exists, has value and is free of other people's rights.

Can a creditor write to the debtor company's customers telling them to pay the creditor instead?+

No. Making a third party stop paying or change payee is done only through an attachment order from the court or the enforcement officer (section 316), which is available at the enforcement stage after judgment. Before judgment the creditor must ask the court for an interim measure and the court must see grounds under sections 254 and 255. Writing to the debtor's customers on your own can cause loss and expose you to liability.

The company issued an invoice to its customer that is unpaid. Can that be attached straight away?+

An invoice shows a trading relationship but does not confirm a due claim. You need to check whether delivery or work was completed, whether the customer accepted it and whether payment is due. The law does allow attachment even if the claim is disputed, conditional or uncertain in amount (section 317), but the customer may object and that part is then held up (section 325).

If the company will not collect from its own customer, can the creditor do so instead?+

Sections 233 and 234 of the Civil and Commercial Code let a creditor exercise the debtor's claim in the creditor's own name where the debtor fails or refuses to do so to the creditor's prejudice, and the debtor must be summoned into that case. It is conditional and needs documents, so take advice before choosing it.

Are directors or shareholders liable for the company's debt?+

Not automatically. A shareholder of a limited company is liable only up to the unpaid value of the shares (section 1096). Personal liability needs a basis, such as a written guarantee, unlimited partner status, or assets moved out by an act that can be revoked. See the guide on directors.

Lawyer-client handshake symbolizing trust at Suwanvara Law Firm

Ready to hear your story

Get an initial consultation with one of our experienced attorneys.