The core answer
An appeal by the debtor does not mean the creditor has to wait. Section 231 of the Civil Procedure Code provides that filing an appeal does not stay enforcement of the first-instance judgment or order. A creditor who won at first instance therefore does not always have to wait for the case to become final. But the appealing debtor can ask the court to stay enforcement, and if the court makes a stay order, enforcement must follow it.
Two questions have to be kept apart. The first is "has the debtor filed an appeal?" The second is "has the debtor applied for a stay, and has the court ruled on it?" Before any significant step, such as asking for a writ of execution, pointing out assets to the officer or asking to receive money, check the file for a stay application or order, and read what conditions the order carries.
This guide is general information. The outcome in any case depends on the wording of the judgment, the court's orders and the facts in the actual file.
Which situation is this guide for?
| Your situation | How to read this guide |
|---|---|
| Pre-suit. No case and no judgment yet | This topic has not arisen. Read the guides on interim protection before judgment and on tracing assets before suing (links at the end), then come back to sections 1 to 3 to see what happens if you win and the debtor appeals. |
| Case pending. The first-instance court has not yet given judgment | There is no judgment to enforce. Protection before judgment is a separate matter: it needs evidence and the court decides. See section 9 to prepare in advance. |
| Judgment won. First-instance judgment given, debtor has appealed or may appeal | This is the closest match. Read sections 1 to 8 and use the file checklist in section 5. |
1. What is the difference between filing an appeal and applying for a stay?
People often treat these as one thing. Legally they are two separate requests.
| Filing an appeal | Applying for a stay of enforcement | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | Asks a higher court to review the first-instance judgment | Asks that enforcement of the judgment be paused while the appeal is decided |
| Does it stop enforcement by itself? | No (Section 231) | Not until the court makes an order |
| Who decides | The appeal court decides the appeal | The court rules on the application on the grounds the appellant gives |
| Where the creditor sees it | The appeal and the court file | The application and the court's orders in the file |
A debtor who only files an appeal, without applying for a stay, does not stop enforcement, which can continue. A debtor who has applied for a stay has still achieved nothing until the court rules. So "the debtor says that because he has appealed you cannot enforce" is a statement to verify against the file every time.
2. Who can apply for a stay, in which court, and when?
Under Section 231 the applicant is the party who has filed the appeal, in this guide the losing debtor. The application is made by a petition giving reasons why enforcement should be stayed, and it can be filed at any time before the appeal court gives judgment.
The court that receives it depends on timing.
- Until the first-instance court has given an order allowing the appeal. The appellant may file the application with the first-instance court, which must promptly forward it to the appeal court.
- After the order allowing the appeal. The application is filed directly with the appeal court.
So the application may appear in the first-instance file or in the appeal court's file, depending on when it was filed. Looking at the first-instance court once may not be enough.
If the case reaches the Supreme Court, check the file and ask counsel separately. This guide covers the appeal stage under Section 231 only.
3. What is the difference between a pending application and a stay order already made?
This is where creditors are most often confused.
A pending application means the debtor has applied but the court has not ruled. The application alone does not stop enforcement. But an order can come at any time, and there are special cases where an order is made quickly before the creditor has been heard.
- In a case of extreme urgency, the first-instance court that has received the application has power to stay enforcement pending the appeal court's decision on the application.
- The appeal court may grant a stay in an urgent case without first hearing the other party, but such an order is provisional until the other party has been heard.
A stay order already made means the court has allowed the stay. Enforcement must then follow the order. Its scope and conditions are in the order itself, not in what the debtor or the debtor's lawyer says about it.
| Status | Effect on enforcement | What the creditor should do |
|---|---|---|
| Appeal filed, no stay application | Enforcement does not stop by itself | Check the file periodically and proceed through the usual steps |
| Stay application filed, no ruling | Not stopped by itself, but a provisional order is possible in urgent cases | Check the file before every significant step and ask counsel about a response or objection |
| Court has allowed a stay | Must follow the scope and conditions in the order | Read the full original order, check for conditions and who must do what |
| Court has refused the stay | Enforcement may continue | Check whether the refusal is final or the debtor has filed a new application |
4. What scope and conditions can a stay order carry?
Section 231 lets the court set conditions. It does not say that a stay always halts everything. The order may be subject to any conditions or none. The conditions the section names are:
- that the appellant gives an undertaking not to dispose of the appellant's assets during the appeal;
- that the appellant provides security for the court sufficient for the sum due under the judgment;
- that the appellant deposits that sum with the court.
If the appellant does not comply, the court may order the appellant's assets seized or attached. Where the assets are movable property, the court may order them sold at auction if satisfied that the sale is necessary and proper because the property is perishable or because keeping it during the appeal would be difficult or very costly.
A different case applies where the appellant deposits with the first-instance court a sum sufficient to pay the judgment debt together with the costs of suit and of enforcement, or provides security satisfactory to the court. The court must then stay enforcement as provided in Section 292(1), which is the case where the enforcement officer withdraws enforcement on the court's order.
Four points to read in the actual order:
| What to look at | The question |
|---|---|
| Scope | Does it stop all enforcement or only part, and which assets? |
| Conditions | Must the debtor deposit money, provide security or give an undertaking, and by when? |
| Provisional or not | Was it made without hearing the creditor, and can the creditor still respond? |
| Effect on seizures already made | Do existing seizures or attachments remain or are they lifted? |
If the order is unclear, do not interpret it yourself. Have counsel review it, or ask the enforcement officer in writing.
5. What to check in the court file and with counsel before acting
Check before every significant step, not once. An application for a stay can be filed at any time before the appeal court gives judgment.
- Has the debtor actually appealed, when, and has the first-instance court ordered that the appeal be allowed?
- Is there a stay application in the first-instance file or the appeal court's file, and when was it filed?
- Has the court ruled? If so, is it an order allowing, refusing or provisional?
- What conditions does the order carry, and has the debtor deposited money or provided security?
- What is the scope of the order: which assets or enforcement methods are stopped?
- Has the notice of enforcement issued, and has the period given to the debtor to comply passed?
- Has the enforcement request been filed, and has the court issued the writ of execution?
- Which court has power to enforce (normally the first-instance court that tried the case, Section 271), and has enforcement been sent to another court?
- The judgment sum, interest, costs and amounts the debtor has already paid
- Assets or claims already seized or attached, and whether anyone has objected or applied for a share
- Does the debtor's appeal challenge the whole judgment or only part, such as interest or particular items?
6. What can the creditor do while the debtor's appeal is pending?
If there is no stay order, the creditor may proceed through the usual enforcement steps. The question clients ask most is "we have found assets, can we seize them now?" The answer is not immediately. In outline:
- The court issues a notice of enforcement when the judgment is read (Section 272), setting the time and conditions for the debtor to comply.
- The creditor files an enforcement request, ex parte, stating the unpaid debt and the method requested (Section 275).
- Once the debtor is treated as knowing of the notice and the time has passed, the court issues a writ of execution appointing an officer (Section 276).
- The enforcement officer seizes or attaches assets as pointed out and as the law permits.
Once the writ is issued the work continues.
- Point out the assets to the officer and give information that can be verified.
- Follow the file with the officer and check whether other creditors or objectors have appeared.
- Keep checking the file during the appeal for any stay application or order.
- Keep every document received from the court and the officer.
Seizing assets does not put money in your hands at once. The main risk during an appeal lies at the stage of receiving money or selling assets, which a changed or reversed judgment affects directly (section 8). Many creditors therefore seize or attach first, to hold the assets, and decide on the next step once the status of the appeal is clearer.
If the debtor asks to pay in instalments meanwhile, see the guide Debtor offers instalments after seizure or attachment on a stay as against a withdrawal of enforcement.
7. The debtor has applied for a stay: how should the creditor respond?
Section 231 does not require the creditor to file anything. But the appeal court may hear the other party, and where it grants a provisional order without hearing the creditor, the order stays provisional until the creditor has been heard. So the creditor should prepare information in advance rather than wait to be asked.
What the creditor and counsel should consider preparing in a statement or objection:
- the risk that the debtor will conceal or dispose of assets during the appeal (evidence, such as past transfers of assets);
- the assets the debtor actually holds, against the sum due under the judgment;
- if the court is minded to grant a stay, a request for the conditions Section 231 allows, such as a deposit, security sufficient for the judgment sum, or an undertaking not to dispose of assets;
- if the appeal challenges only part of the judgment, a request that the stay affect only that part.
How to respond depends on the stage and state of the file, so have counsel review before filing. No one can guarantee that the court will refuse a stay or impose the conditions requested.
8. If the judgment is changed or reversed, what is the creditor's risk?
Enforcing before the case is final carries the risk that the judgment may be varied, reversed or dismissed on appeal. Section 292(2) provides that:
- if the court orders enforcement withdrawn because the judgment under enforcement has been reversed or set aside, the enforcement officer must withdraw enforcement;
- if the judgment is reversed only in part, enforcement may continue until the money collected is enough to pay the creditor under the judgment.
In practice, assess before three steps that are hard to undo.
| Step | Ask counsel first |
|---|---|
| Seizing or attaching assets | Can be done to hold the assets, but if the judgment is reversed the seizure must be lifted |
| Selling assets at auction | If sold and the judgment is then reversed, what is the effect on the buyer and the creditor? Assess before the sale |
| Receiving money from enforcement | If the judgment is later varied, is there a repayment issue? Check the wording of the appeal judgment and have counsel assess it |
The statutes cited in this guide do not set out a mechanism for returning money or assets when a judgment is reversed. We therefore do not say that nothing must be returned, or that something certainly must. The result depends on the wording of the appeal judgment and the facts of the case.
This risk is why a creditor should weigh the strength of the appeal, the assets available and the chance that the debtor moves assets if the creditor waits, then decide step by step, rather than making one all-or-nothing choice between "enforce now" and "wait until final".
9. How does this relate to the pre-suit and case-pending stages?
Pre-suit. There is no judgment to appeal. The useful work is to trace assets through lawful channels and assess whether suing is worthwhile. See Tracing assets before suing: is it worth it?.
Case pending. The first-instance court has not given judgment. If you are worried that the debtor will move assets while you wait, there are protective measures before judgment that the court orders on evidence. See Interim protection before judgment. Do not confuse this with a stay of enforcement, which comes after judgment and an appeal.
Judgment won. Sections 1 to 8 above apply.
Hypothetical example: a building-materials supplier wins at first instance and the debtor appeals
This is a made-up example to show the order of thinking. It is not a real case or a result obtained by the firm, and the figures and timing are not real.
Company A, a building-materials supplier, wins a claim for the price of goods of 1,000,000 baht at first instance. The debtor, Company B, files an appeal last week. Company A's accounts staff ask whether they must wait for the appeal court.
Counsel advises this order of work.
- Check the file. The debtor has appealed, but there is no stay application and no court order.
- Check the enforcement stage. The notice of enforcement has issued and the time to comply has passed, so the creditor files the enforcement request and asks for a writ of execution.
- Check assets. A parcel of land in Company B's name is found, and Company A points it out to the officer for seizure, to hold the asset first.
- Prepare a statement. In case the debtor applies for a stay, Company A collects evidence of earlier transfers of assets by Company B.
- Check the file again before the next significant step, such as asking for a court auction, because a stay application can be filed at any time before the appeal court gives judgment.
If the debtor later applies for a stay and the court orders a deposit or security sufficient for the judgment sum, the creditor checks whether the debtor complied. If not, the court may order the debtor's assets seized or attached. If the debtor does comply, the enforcement the officer is carrying out may have to stop or be withdrawn as the order provides. The actual result depends on the wording of the court's order.
Documents to prepare when the debtor appeals
- The first-instance judgment and the notice of enforcement, with proof of service or proof that the debtor knew of it
- A copy of the debtor's appeal and proof of the filing date
- The stay application, if any, and every court order on it
- The enforcement request and the writ of execution, if already filed
- A statement of the judgment sum, interest, costs and payments the debtor has made
- A list of assets or claims found, with the date and source of each
- Documents or evidence showing that the debtor transferred or disposed of assets, if any
- Letters or notes of contact with the enforcement officer
Common misunderstandings
| What you often hear | What is correct |
|---|---|
| "The debtor has appealed, so the creditor must always wait until the case is final" | An appeal does not stay enforcement by itself (Section 231). The creditor need not always wait, but must check for a stay application or order |
| "Filing an appeal and applying for a stay are the same thing" | They are separate requests. A debtor may appeal without applying for a stay, or apply and not yet have a ruling |
| "The debtor has applied for a stay, so enforcement stops at once" | A pending application is not a stay order. In urgent cases a provisional order is possible, so check the file regularly |
| "Once a stay is granted everything stops" | An order may carry conditions and a scope, such as a deposit, security or an undertaking. Read the actual order |
| "After seizure we can sell immediately" | The legal steps must be followed, and during an appeal the judgment may be varied or reversed. Assess before selling or receiving money |
| "The fastest enforcement is always best" | Weigh the assets, the strength of the appeal, the risk the debtor moves assets and the effect of a reversal, then choose step by step |
Further reading
- Debt collection, suing a debtor and enforcement: the overview from demand to enforcement
- How many years after winning can you enforce?: the enforcement sequence after judgment
- Debtor facing enforcement: rights and defences: the debtor's side
- Debtor offers instalments after seizure or attachment: when the debtor asks to pay in instalments during enforcement
- Several creditors, one asset: who is paid first?: when objectors or other creditors appear
- Interim protection before judgment: before there is a judgment
A debtor's appeal does not stop enforcement by itself, but before every significant step check the file for a stay application or order, read the scope and conditions of the actual order, and assess the risk of a changed or reversed judgment before you sell assets or receive money.
We trace the debtor's assets through lawful channels, review documents and evidence, advise whether to sue or continue enforcement, file suit, request enforcement, follow up with the enforcement officer, handle objections and distribution, and negotiate instalments after seizure. We do not guarantee that assets will be found or that a creditor will be paid, we do not search the debtor's bank accounts, and we do not use unlawful means. Payment depends on the assets, the rights of prior creditors and the facts of the case. Fees depend on the stage of the case and the work required. Send us your documents first, and we will give you the scope of work and fees in writing before we start. Call +66 92 254 2045 or send us the details. See asset tracing and civil litigation.
This guide is published by Suwanvara Law Firm — a Khon Kaen law firm established in 1986. General information only, not legal advice on a specific matter.

