Skip to main content
SUWANVARA LAWFIRM
Suwanvara Law Firm Co., Ltd.
SUWANVARA LAWFIRM
SUWANVARA LAWFIRM
Suwanvara Law Firm Co., Ltd.
Business Law

The Other Side Wants Unlimited Liability: How to Negotiate Liability Caps, Indirect Damages and Indemnities

How to negotiate a liability cap, an indirect-damages exclusion, a third-party indemnity and the link to your insurance limit before signing a business contract, and what Thai law does not let parties agree.

Suwanvara Law Firm— Business Law TeamNovember 21, 202614 min read
The Other Side Wants Unlimited Liability: How to Negotiate Liability Caps, Indirect Damages and Indemnities

The core answer

When a large customer hands you a contract that says the supplier is liable without limit, do not answer only yes or no. Ask three things first: which types of loss the unlimited liability covers, whether the third-party indemnity sits under the cap or outside it, and how much insurance the company really holds for this risk. With those answers you can propose a cap, a list of excluded losses and a scoped indemnity in writing.

If the contract is silent, the law does not set a cap for you. The party in breach compensates the loss that actually arises, within the limits of section 222, and that can be many times the contract price. A cap is therefore something you negotiate and write down, and even a written cap has limits: liability for fraud or gross negligence cannot be excluded in advance (section 373).

Our practical view Do not start by deleting the word unlimited. Start by offering a whole structure: an aggregate cap tied to the fees, a higher special cap for the risk the customer truly worries about, a short and clear list of carve-outs, and an indemnity limited to your own fault. Counterparties tend to accept a reasoned package more readily than word-by-word edits.

This guide covers only caps, indirect damages, indemnities and insurance. For the wider picture of a customer's standard-form contract, see checking a large customer's contract before signing. For caps and service credits in monthly service contracts, see MSA and SLA.

Who should read which part

Your situationSections to read
Not signed yetSections 2 to 7 for negotiation, and section 8 to prepare before you send the draft back
Signed and runningSections 1 and 6 to check that the risk you carry matches your policy, and section 8 to keep proof of claim notices
Dispute already startedSections 1 to 5 to see how far the clause being relied on can work, section 6 to notify the insurer in time, then send the contract and documents to a lawyer per section 8

1. If the contract sets no cap, how far does the party in breach pay?

Legal basis When a debtor fails to perform an obligation as it was truly meant, the creditor may claim compensation (section 215). A claim for damages means compensation for the loss that normally results from the non-performance, and the creditor may also claim for loss from special circumstances if the parties concerned foresaw or should have foreseen those circumstances in advance (section 222). If the injured party contributed to the loss through its own fault, the amount payable depends on the circumstances and on which side contributed more to the loss (section 223).

Three points follow.

  1. There is no numeric cap. Liability is measured by actual loss.
  2. Lost profit and consequential loss can fall within section 222 if they are the normal result or something the parties should have foreseen. If the customer states its special circumstances in the contract or purchase order, that may make the loss something you should have foreseen.
  3. If the customer failed to mitigate or helped cause the problem, the amount may be reduced under section 223, but you need evidence.

The second point matters most in practice. Loss above the contract price usually comes from the customer's own business being stopped, not from the defective goods or work itself. A cap is the tool that closes that gap.

2. How should a liability cap be set?

A cap is the maximum each party must pay the other for breach. There is no universal number, but there are common structures that can be negotiated.

Cap structureHow it is writtenNotes
Tied to feesNot more than the fees paid or payable under the contract in the 12 months before the eventEasiest to justify. Suits continuing services
Tied to job valueNot more than the price of the job or order concerned in the defectSuits one-off work or sales. Watch overlapping jobs
Fixed capA stated sum in baht or a multiple of feesUse when fees are low but risk is high. Needs a reason
Special cap (super-cap)A higher cap for one topic, such as a data leak or breach of confidentialityHelps the customer accept the main cap
No capSilent or "unlimited"Accept only for what the law does not let you limit anyway

Points to settle every time:

  • Per event or aggregate. A per-event cap lets liability accumulate many times over. An aggregate cap per contract or contract year is easier to control.
  • Two-way or one-way. Ask that the cap applies to both sides. If the customer limits its own liability but not yours, treat that as a first-priority point.
  • Whether penalties and service credits count inside the cap. If the contract has penalties, liquidated damages or service credits, state that they count under the same cap and do not stack.
  • What sits outside the cap. Keep the list short: fraud, gross negligence, intentional acts, and fees already due. The longer the list, the less the cap means.
  • Claim notice period. Say how many days from awareness a claim must be notified, failing which it lapses. A period that is too short risks being seen as unfair.

For the company-wide table of what a manager may approve, what is negotiable and what goes to a lawyer, see contract review without a legal department. In this guide, treat one rule as the anchor: a cap you propose yourself, with reasons, is considered more readily than a request to delete the customer's clause with no figure in its place.

3. What are indirect damages, and how should the exclusion be written?

Thai law has no defined category of indirect damages. Section 222 uses normal result and foreseeability as the test. A contract that says only "no liability for indirect damages" leaves one side to argue that lost profit is direct and the other that it is indirect. The way to cut disputes is to write a list.

Type of lossHow to write it
Lost profit, lost revenueName it in the exclusion list. Do not leave it under the word indirect
Consequential loss (for example the customer's business stops)State that it is excluded even if the possibility was notified in advance
Loss of reputation or business opportunityName it too, as it is hard to prove and value
Cost of finding a replacement supplierAgree clearly whether it counts as direct. Customers often ask for it, and you may accept it under the cap
Cost of fixing or redoing defective workNormally treat it as direct loss you bear. If you want to fix it first, write a right to cure within a set time
Penalties the customer must pay its own customerAgree whether you accept them. If yes, keep them under the cap

Watch for An exclusion must really be two-way. If the customer asks to recover only direct loss, ask how it defines direct. Agreeing the definition before signing costs less than proving it in court afterwards.

4. What can a cap not protect against?

Two layers apply together.

Fraud and gross negligence (section 373). An advance agreement that excludes a debtor's liability for its fraud or gross negligence is void. The section does not speak of intentional acts directly, so in practice the carve-out list is usually written to cover all three, to remove argument. A customer clause that makes you liable without limit for these matters is therefore not one you need to fight: a cap cannot protect you there anyway.

Unfair contract terms (Unfair Contract Terms Act B.E. 2540). Section 4 covers several contract types including standard-form contracts. A term that gives the drafter an unreasonable advantage takes effect only to the extent that it is fair and reasonable, and the examples in that section include terms excluding or limiting liability for breach. Section 8 bars reliance on an advance agreement that excludes or limits liability for harm to the life, body or health of another caused intentionally or negligently.

Our practical view Treat this as a safety net, not the plan. Whether your contract is a standard form, and whether a clause goes too far, depends on the facts case by case, and litigation is slow and uncertain. The best time to protect yourself is before signing.

5. How should a third-party indemnity be limited?

An indemnity is one side's promise to bear the cost when a third party claims against the other. It differs from a cap because it concerns people outside the contract, such as a rights holder who says your work infringes, an injured user, or someone whose data was misused. The usual problem is a broad draft: indemnify every claim relating to the goods or services, which moves the customer's own faults onto you.

What to fix:

  • Trigger. Indemnify only claims arising from your breach or fault, not every claim that reaches the customer.
  • Subject matter. Limit it to a list, for example IP infringement by work you delivered, or death or injury caused by your fault. Not everything.
  • Carve-outs on the customer side. If the claim arises from what the customer ordered, modified or misused, you do not indemnify. The customer may have to indemnify you in return.
  • Procedure. The customer gives prompt notice, lets you control the defence or settlement, and does not settle without your approval.
  • Under or outside the cap. This is the most important point. If the indemnity sits outside the cap, unlimited liability returns through the back door. Ask for it to sit under the cap or have its own special cap.
  • What money is covered. Agree whether it includes lawyers' fees, court fees and sums actually paid, and whether it includes fines imposed by authorities. The last item needs case-by-case advice from a lawyer.

An indemnity does not stop you defending the third party's claim. After notice, keep the documents and respond within the contract's deadlines.

6. How do the cap and the insurance limit relate?

Liability insurance is a contract in which the insurer agrees to pay compensation in the name of the insured for loss caused to another person for which the insured is liable. The injured person is entitled to receive compensation directly from the insurer, but not more than the insurer must pay under the policy, and the injured person must join the insured in the case (section 887).

In contract terms, check these before agreeing a figure.

  1. The real policy limit, compared with the cap the customer asks for. If the customer asks for a cap above the limit, the excess is risk the company carries itself.
  2. Whether the policy covers liability assumed by contract. Some policies cover only liability imposed by law, not extra liability taken on by contract, and may exclude data, intellectual property or fines.
  3. Notice conditions and policy period. Some policies require notice within a set time or cover only claims made and notified during the policy period.
  4. What the insured bears. Deductibles and exclusions for matters already known.
  5. A contract term requiring you to buy insurance. Do not promise a type or limit you do not hold. Write that you will maintain the insurance you have and notify the other side of material changes. If the customer wants more cover, price the premium before agreeing.

We are not an insurer or insurance broker and we do not assess whether your policy responds. Have your agent or broker review the policy, then bring the result to the lawyer so the contract wording matches it.

7. The customer insists on unlimited liability: what is the negotiating order?

A sequence that works for most contracts, from the smallest change to the largest:

  1. Ask why. What does the customer really fear: a data leak, an infringement, a delay? The answer shows where a special cap belongs.
  2. Offer an aggregate cap plus special caps as in section 2, with a short carve-out list.
  3. Offer the excluded-loss list from section 3, applied to both sides.
  4. Scope the indemnity as in section 5, under the cap or with its own special cap.
  5. Offer insurance as a bridge. If the customer wants comfort, offer to maintain the insurance you hold and consider more cover if the contract value justifies it.
  6. If still stuck, escalate. Management decides whether the risk is worth the revenue, not the sales person.

If the customer will not move at all, the answer may be not to sign, or to reprice for the risk. Both are business decisions that the law cannot make for you.

8. Checklist of documents and checks before you send the draft back

  • The full contract and annexes, including purchase order, general terms and any policies it refers to
  • Every clause on liability, damages, penalties and indemnity, all marked
  • Total annual or contract fees, to set a fee-linked cap
  • The insurance policies you hold, with limits, exclusions and expiry dates
  • A list of the losses the customer really worries about, to set special caps
  • A comparison table of original and proposed clauses, kept in the contract file
  • An internal approver who signs off the remaining risk
  • Dates for claim notices and insurer notices, entered in the contract register

9. Hypothetical example: the customer's draft says unlimited liability and indemnity for every claim

This is not a real case. All figures are illustrative only.

A software company agrees to maintain a system for a large manufacturer, fees 1,200,000 baht a year. The customer's draft says the contractor is liable for all loss without limit, indemnifies every claim relating to the services, and must hold insurance of 10,000,000 baht. The contractor holds a policy of 5,000,000 baht.

PointCustomer's draftContractor's counter-proposal
General capUnlimitedNot more than fees paid in the 12 months before the event (1,200,000 baht)
Data leakInside unlimitedSpecial cap of 3,000,000 baht
Outside the capNot stated, as there is no capFraud, gross negligence, intentional acts
Indirect damagesNot excludedLost profit, lost revenue and consequential loss excluded for both sides
IndemnityEvery claim relating to the servicesOnly third-party claims of IP infringement by delivered work and injury caused by the contractor's fault, under the special cap
InsuranceMust hold 10,000,000 bahtMaintain the policy held (5,000,000 baht) and notify material changes

Before replying, the contractor asked its broker whether the policy covers contractual data liability and learned that it does not, so it set the special cap at a level the company can carry itself rather than at the policy limit. Results would differ with the real contract and facts.

Common misunderstandings

  • "If we write no cap, the law limits it for us." Not so. When the contract is silent, the party in breach is liable for the loss that arises within section 222, and there is no numeric cap.
  • "Writing no liability for indirect damages makes us safe." Not always. Thai law has no central definition of the term. List lost profit and consequential loss expressly.
  • "A cap protects us in every case." It does not. An advance exclusion of liability for fraud or gross negligence is void under section 373.
  • "An indemnity is the same as a cap." They are different. An indemnity concerns third-party claims, and outside the cap it can bring unlimited liability back.
  • "We have insurance, so we can sign any cap." No. Insurance pays under the policy, which has limits and exclusions and may not cover liability assumed by contract.
  • "If a term is unfair, the court will fix it later." The Unfair Contract Terms Act helps only for certain types of contract, requires proof of facts and is uncertain. Negotiate before signing.
  • "A lawyer can guarantee the customer will accept the cap." No one can. The result depends on the bargaining power of both sides.

Further reading

Unlimited liability is the opening position of a negotiation, not the final answer: offer a whole structure with reasons, and check your policy before you agree any figure.

We review and draft liability caps, excluded-loss lists and indemnity clauses in your contracts, prepare a comparison table of the customer's draft against your counter-proposal, and work with your insurance agent or broker so that the contract wording matches the policy. We are not an insurer or insurance broker, we do not assess what your policy covers, and we cannot promise the outcome of a negotiation with the other side. Fees depend on the stage of the matter and the work required. Send us the documents first, and we will give you the scope of work and fees in writing before we start. Call +66 92 254 2045 or send us the details. See also contracts and documents.


This guide is published by Suwanvara Law Firm — a Khon Kaen law firm established in 1986. General information only, not legal advice on a specific matter.

Frequently asked questions

If a contract has no liability cap, how much must the party in breach pay?+

When the contract is silent, the party in breach compensates the loss that actually arises under Civil and Commercial Code sections 215 and 222: the loss that normally follows from non-performance, plus loss from special circumstances if the parties foresaw or should have foreseen them. There is no fixed figure, and it can be many times the contract price.

Does Thai law separate indirect damages from direct damages?+

The Civil and Commercial Code does not define indirect damages as a legal category. Section 222 turns on what is normal or foreseeable. If you want to exclude lost profit or consequential loss, list those items in the contract instead of relying on how a court would read the word indirect.

Can liability always be limited in advance?+

No. Section 373 makes an advance agreement excluding a debtor's liability for fraud or gross negligence void, and for standard-form contracts the Unfair Contract Terms Act B.E. 2540 (1997) may limit an unreasonably one-sided clause to what is fair.

How is an indemnity different from a limitation of liability?+

A limitation of liability caps what you owe the other party if you breach. An indemnity is a promise to bear the cost when a third party, such as a rights holder or an injured person, claims against the other party. You must check whether the indemnity sits under the cap or outside it, because outside the cap it can undo a negotiated cap.

If we have liability insurance, can we ignore the cap?+

No. Insurance pays according to the policy, which has its own limit, exclusions and notice conditions. The cap in the contract should match the cover you actually hold, and your insurance agent or broker should confirm whether the policy covers liability assumed by contract.

Lawyer-client handshake symbolizing trust at Suwanvara Law Firm

Ready to hear your story

Get an initial consultation with one of our experienced attorneys.