Skip to main content
SUWANVARA LAWFIRM
Suwanvara Law Firm Co., Ltd.
SUWANVARA LAWFIRM
SUWANVARA LAWFIRM
Suwanvara Law Firm Co., Ltd.
Inheritance Law Guide

A parent gave a child money for a house before dying and heirs now dispute it: gift or loan?

A parent transferred money to a child to buy a house, and other heirs now say it was a loan or should count against the child's share. How to examine transfer evidence, written notes, repayments, the name on the title deed and the sequence of events, with Civil and Commercial Code sections 521, 523, 650, 653, 1599, 1600 and 1754.

Suwanvara Law Firm— Family and Inheritance Litigation TeamNovember 21, 202611 min read
A parent gave a child money for a house before dying and heirs now dispute it: gift or loan?

The core answer

The same sum that a parent transfers to a child for a house can be a gift, a loan or something else. The number on the slip does not say which. The law asks whether the giver meant to hand it over for nothing and the receiver accepted (a gift, section 521), or whether they agreed the child would return the same amount (a loan, section 650). If heirs say it was a loan, the side making that claim needs evidence, and section 653 sets a written-evidence condition for loans of money above two thousand baht.

Whether the amount should be deducted from this child's share is a different question from whether it was a loan. The Civil and Commercial Code has no general rule that lifetime gifts are automatically added back or deducted from the share. A gift that turns out unequal is therefore not void, and not deducted on its own. The result depends on the evidence, any will, and any agreement among the heirs.

Who this guide is for

StageSections to read
Still alive and planningSections 2, 6 and 9, to make clear what a transfer is from the day it is made
Recently deceasedSections 1, 3, 5 and 8 and the checklist in section 9, to gather evidence before it is lost and watch the time limit
Administrator appointed or dispute under waySections 3, 4, 5, 7 and 8, for the burden of proof, what the estate holds and timing

1. What does "it was a loan" mean when heirs say it?

Heirs usually argue one of two different things, and it helps to separate them before talking.

  • It was a loan: the child must repay the estate. If true, the unpaid amount is a claim the deceased held.
  • It was a gift but should count as the child's share already received: this does not say the child must repay. It asks that the amount be taken into account in the division, which needs a basis in a will or an agreement. See section 7.

The two arguments use different facts and different tests. Mixing them wastes time.

2. What evidence separates a gift from a loan?

No single document answers it. Courts and lawyers usually put several pieces together.

EvidenceWhat to check
Slips, passbooks, statementsWhen, how much, from whose account to whose, one transfer or instalments
Who paid the house seller or developerDid the parent pay the seller directly, or send money to the child who then paid
Written notes or agreementsWords such as "loan", "gift" or "must repay", and who signed
RepaymentsDid the child ever return or pay by instalments, how much, how regularly
Name on the title deed or sale contractWho is the registered owner, one name or several
Messages, emails, witnessed statementsDid the parent say it was a gift, a loan, or tied to the child caring for them
WitnessesPeople present at the transfer or the conversation, such as siblings, relatives, bank staff, agents
Tax and bank recordsTax filings, the child's mortgage papers, documents showing the source of the down payment

Keep originals and request copies from the bank or the land office through proper channels. Do not delete or edit any message on the deceased's phone.

3. Who has to prove it, and why does a loan usually need writing?

A person who asserts a fact to gain a right usually has to bring the evidence. If the heirs say the child borrowed, they should have evidence of the loan. If the child says it was received as a gift, the delivery and acceptance should be shown.

Section 653 is why loans need special care. Its text says:

  • A loan of money of more than two thousand baht cannot be enforced by suit unless there is some written evidence of the loan signed by the borrower.
  • Where there is written evidence of the loan, repayment can be proved only by written evidence signed by the lender, or if the loan document has been returned or cancelled by striking it through.

In practice, if the parent never had the child sign anything, suing the child to repay as a loan faces a serious obstacle. Whether a given paper counts as "written evidence signed by the borrower" depends on the actual document and wording, not on feelings. Section 653 also speaks to loans of money. It does not itself decide whether a transfer was a gift or a loan in the first place.

If the child says it was a gift, then check that the elements of a gift are present. See section 4.

4. What does a gift need, and when is it complete?

Section 521 says a gift is a contract by which a person, the giver, transfers property of their own to another, the receiver, out of generosity, and the receiver accepts it. "Out of generosity" means without return consideration under a contract.

Section 523 says a gift is complete only when the property given is delivered. For money, delivery is usually visible in a transfer to an account or a handover, so the trail is often clear. A gift of property that must be registered, such as land, involves steps at the land office. See the post transferring land to children during life.

Reading the sequence:

  • If the parent sent money, the child bought the house in the child's own name, and nobody mentioned repayment, the facts lean toward a gift.
  • If the parent sent money while saying or writing "lend now, to be repaid" and the child repaid by instalments, the facts lean toward a loan.
  • If the child repaid some money and then stopped, look at the reasons and the messages from that time.

5. What do the name on the deed and the sequence of events show?

The registered owner is important, but it does not decide whether the purchase money was a gift or a loan. Build a timeline.

OrderWhat to date clearly
1The date of agreeing to buy, the deposit, and who paid
2The dates and amounts of each transfer from the parent
3The date ownership transferred, and the buyer's name
4Messages or documents made before or at the time of transfer
5Repayments, or talk of repayment, afterwards
6The date the giver died and the date heirs began to dispute

If the claim that it was a loan first appears after the giver's death with no earlier document, a court or lawyer will look at it carefully. Equally, if the child says "it was a gift" only after the dispute arose, yet had earlier made repayments, that needs a consistent explanation.

6. If you are alive, how do you avoid a dispute later?

  • Write down the intention on the day of transfer, for example "a gift, no repayment" or "a loan with repayment terms", dated and signed.
  • If it is a loan, have the borrower sign the record, in line with section 653.
  • If it is a gift, say whether you want it counted against other shares, for example in a will, because there is no general rule that does so automatically.
  • Tell the other children or keep the papers where the administrator can find them.
  • Plan the will and lifetime gifts together.

7. Is an unequal lifetime gift deducted from the child's inheritance?

This needs a plain answer. The Civil and Commercial Code has no general rule that gifts made during life are brought back into the estate or deducted from a child's share automatically. So:

  • Giving one child more than the others does not make the gift void merely because it is unequal.
  • A gift already made is not deducted from the inheritance automatically.
  • The real result depends on the evidence, any will, and any agreement the heirs reach themselves or at court.

If an heir argues the gift is invalid for another reason, such as lack of capacity or pressure, that reason must be proved separately and is specific to the facts.

8. After the giver dies, what is in the estate, and what are the time limits?

Section 1599 says that when a person dies, the estate passes to the heirs, and an heir loses rights in the estate only as the Code or another law provides.

Section 1600 says that, subject to the Code, the estate consists of all kinds of the deceased's property together with rights, duties and liabilities, except those that by law or by nature are strictly personal to the deceased.

So if the amount the child owes is a real, enforceable loan, the claim to repayment may form part of the estate and sit with the heirs or the administrator acting. A completed gift is no longer the deceased's property. For the overall division of an estate see when a parent dies, how is the estate divided.

On time, section 1754 bars estate suits after one year from the death, or from when an heir by operation of law knew or should have known of the death, and bars them after ten years from the death. Whether your dispute counts as an estate suit under that section, and any exceptions, depend on the facts, so get advice quickly rather than waiting for siblings to talk it out.

If an administrator is already appointed but not acting, see estate administrator not distributing or not responding.

9. Checklist: documents and steps

  • Transfer slips, passbooks and statements of the deceased and the child, from before the house purchase
  • Sale agreement, title deed, and receipts from the seller or developer
  • Notes, agreements, chats, emails and voice messages mentioning this money
  • Evidence of every repayment, if any
  • Names of witnesses and what each saw or heard
  • Any will, or earlier agreement among the siblings
  • The timeline from section 5 on a single page
  • The date of death and the date you learned of it, to check timing under section 1754
  • Do not delete or edit messages, move money or sell the house before getting advice

Hypothetical example

This is a hypothetical scenario, not a real case. Figures are illustrative only.

A mother transfers 1,500,000 baht to her eldest child for a house down payment. The child buys the house in their own name. The mother dies two years later. Two younger siblings say it was a loan owed to the estate. The eldest says the mother gave it.

Hypothetical factPossible weight
No paper signed by the child acknowledging a duty to repayAn obstacle to the loan claim because of section 653
The mother's chat says "it's yours, no need to repay"Supports a gift under section 521, and the transfer is delivery under section 523
The child sent 5,000 baht a month for a yearNeeds explaining as debt repayment or help for the mother; the messages from the time carry weight
The mother left no willNothing directs this sum to be deducted from the eldest's share

No conclusion is possible from the amount alone. The whole body of evidence must be read, and nobody should conclude the transfer is void merely because the younger siblings feel the result is unequal.

Common misunderstandings

MisunderstandingCorrection
"One child got more, so the transfer is void"An unequal gift is not void merely because it feels unequal. A legal ground and evidence are needed
"A parent's gift must always be deducted from the inheritance"There is no general rule of automatic deduction. The result depends on evidence, any will and any agreement
"Money went into the child's account, so it was a loan"A transfer alone does not say. Intent, messages and repayments matter
"There is no loan paper, but the siblings remember mum saying to repay, so we can sue"Section 653 requires written evidence signed by the borrower for loans above two thousand baht. Recollection alone faces an obstacle
"The deed is in the child's name, so that settles it"The deed shows the registered owner. It does not say whether the purchase money was a gift or a loan
"Wait until things calm down"Estate suits have time limits under section 1754. Get advice quickly

Limits of this guide: it does not cover land transferred on the register, conditional or burdened gifts, revocation of gifts, claims to recover for other reasons, assets abroad, or tax on gifts (ask an accountant or auditor to review tax). It is general information as at 21 November 2026. The answer changes when there is a will, an agreement among heirs, or documents not yet seen.

Further reading

Whether a parent's transfer to a child is a gift or a loan depends on the whole body of evidence and the sequence of events, not on a feeling that the shares are unequal, and time limits may apply.

We help examine the facts and evidence on gift-or-loan questions inside a family, and negotiate or handle the estate matter with the heirs. We cannot promise any outcome, and we do not review tax. Fees depend on the stage of the case and the work required. Send us the documents first, and we will give you the scope of work and the fees in writing before we start. Call +66 92 254 2045 or send us the details. See also our estate practice and family law practice.


This guide is published by Suwanvara Law Firm — a Khon Kaen law firm established in 1986. General information only, not legal advice on a specific matter.

Frequently asked questions

A parent transferred money to a child for a house. Is it a gift or a loan?+

The transfer alone does not say. It depends on what the giver and receiver intended, the transfer evidence, messages, repayments and the sequence of events. A transfer made out of generosity and accepted by the receiver fits a gift. An agreement to return the same amount of money fits a loan, which brings in the written-evidence rule in section 653.

With no written loan contract, can the heirs sue the child to repay?+

Section 653 says that a loan of money of more than two thousand baht cannot be enforced by suit unless there is some written evidence of the loan signed by the borrower. Evidence therefore matters a great deal for the side claiming a loan. Every actual document still has to be read, for example a note the child signed acknowledging a duty to repay.

Must money a parent gave a child during life be deducted from that child's inheritance?+

The Civil and Commercial Code has no general rule that lifetime gifts are automatically added back or deducted from a child's inheritance share. An unequal gift is not void merely because it feels unequal, and it is not deducted automatically. The result depends on the evidence, any will, and any agreement among the heirs.

If it was a loan, who holds the claim after the parent dies?+

Sections 1599 and 1600 provide that the estate passes to the heirs and that the estate includes all kinds of property together with rights, duties and liabilities, except those strictly personal to the deceased. A real, enforceable claim to repayment may therefore form part of the estate.

Is there a time limit for estate claims?+

Section 1754 bars estate suits after one year from the death, or from when an heir by operation of law knew or should have known of the death, with an outer limit of ten years from the death. Whether your dispute counts as an estate suit under that section depends on the facts, so get advice quickly.

Lawyer-client handshake symbolizing trust at Suwanvara Law Firm

Ready to hear your story

Get an initial consultation with one of our experienced attorneys.