Skip to main content
SUWANVARA LAWFIRM
Suwanvara Law Firm Co., Ltd.
SUWANVARA LAWFIRM
SUWANVARA LAWFIRM
Suwanvara Law Firm Co., Ltd.
Business Law

The Cheapest Quote Is Not the Cheapest: Comparing Suppliers by Total Cost of Ownership (TCO)

How to compare quotations by total cost of ownership (TCO) instead of purchase price: 11 cost components, a comparison table template, a hypothetical example where the lowest quote costs the most over 5 years, and the contract terms to write on warranty, spare parts, SLA, late delivery and acceptance.

Suwanvara Law Firm— Business Law TeamNovember 12, 202612 min read
The Cheapest Quote Is Not the Cheapest: Comparing Suppliers by Total Cost of Ownership (TCO)

Many owners pick a supplier by the last line of the quotation, then find out later that the machine uses more electricity, spare parts take three months, the technician is slow and the whole price had to be paid up front. The lowest price at purchase turns out to be the most expensive choice once the full life of the asset is counted.

This guide compares suppliers by total cost of ownership (TCO). It has a table template, a hypothetical example where the lowest quote costs the most over 5 years, and the contract terms needed to make the evaluated numbers actually happen. All figures in the example are hypothetical.

The core answer

Compare every quotation by its total cost over the planned life (for example 5 years), not by purchase price, using 11 items: price, freight and import, installation, training, energy and consumables, maintenance, spare parts, downtime, defects and returns, the cost of money under the payment terms, and residual value or disposal. Set the criteria and score weights before quotations arrive, then write what the supplier promised in its offer, such as warranty, spare parts, repair times and delivery date, into the contract, because the table only holds if the supplier is bound to it.

Legal principle The seller is liable for defects under sections 472 to 474 of the Civil and Commercial Code, but there are exceptions and a one-year time limit to sue. Spare parts, repair times and service credits are not required by law; they must be in the contract. Late-delivery penalties follow sections 379 to 383, and a court may reduce one that is disproportionate.

Our practical view A promise made at the sales stage that is not in the contract is usually worth little on the day the machine breaks. Move everything that won the comparison into contract terms.

1. What is TCO, and why is the lowest purchase price misleading?

TCO is the sum of all cash that leaves because of the purchase, from the day of the order to the day the item is retired, minus cash that comes back, such as resale value.

The purchase price misleads because the other costs are spread across departments. Purchasing sees the price, production sees the downtime, accounting sees the electricity bill, and nobody adds them up. The longer an item lasts, the more energy it uses, or the more revenue is lost when it stops, the smaller the purchase price is as a share of what is actually paid.

Use TCO for items with a multi-year life or that are bought repeatedly, such as machinery, software systems, vehicles and main raw materials bought continuously. Low-value one-off items do not need a detailed analysis.

2. What cost components does total cost include?

#ComponentWhat it coversWhere to ask or find the number
1Purchase pricePrice after discount; compare before or after VAT on the same basisQuotation
2Freight and importFreight, transport insurance, duty, tax, customs clearance, exchange-rate effectSupplier and customs agent; see importing machinery
3Installation and site preparationElectrical work, foundation, lifting, commissioningSupplier and contractor
4TrainingStaff training, Thai-language manuals, production time lost while learningSupplier
5Energy and consumablesPower, water, air, parts replaced on a cycleHourly specification and our production plan
6MaintenanceScheduled maintenance, maintenance contractManufacturer's maintenance plan
7Spare partsWear parts, their price and lead timeRecommended 1 to 3 year parts list
8DowntimeHours stopped times profit or revenue lost per hourModel failure data and the SLA
9Defects and returnsScrapped output, repeat claims, customer returnsTest results, samples, reference customers
10Cost of money under payment termsThe more paid up front the higher the cost of money; paying after acceptance helpsPayment stages in the quotation and our borrowing cost
11Residual value and disposalResale value, dismantling, waste disposalSecond-hand market and manufacturer

3. How do we set criteria before quotations arrive, and who should approve?

Criteria set after seeing prices tend to be bent toward the supplier already favoured. Work in this order.

  1. Write the requirement: required capacity, minimum quality, standards to be met, planned life (for example 5 years).
  2. Separate must-have criteria from scored criteria: must-haves, such as passing safety standards and having a service centre in the country, eliminate bidders who fail. Scored criteria get percentage weights before the RFQ is sent.
  3. Send every bidder the same form: ask them to fill in all 11 items, using the same assumptions (operating hours, production volume).
  4. Evaluate as a panel: at least two functions, for example production and accounting, scoring separately before prices are revealed.
  5. Record the reasons for the choice, especially when the lowest bidder is not chosen.

Who approves?

The law does not say who must approve; this is internal control. We recommend separating the roles.

Purchase value (example thresholds the company sets itself)RequesterEvaluatorsApprover
LowDepartment headPurchasingManager
MediumManagerPurchasing, production, accountingManaging director
High or multi-year commitmentManaging directorEvaluation panel, and legal adviser reviewing the contractBoard meeting or owner

Evaluators must disclose in writing any relationship with the bidders. On gifts and kickbacks from suppliers, see employees receiving gifts or kickbacks from suppliers.

4. What does the comparison table template look like?

Fill in total amounts over the planned life (for example 5 years) in every cell, in one unit.

ComponentSupplier ASupplier BSupplier CNotes / assumptions
1 Purchase price
2 Freight and import
3 Installation and site preparation
4 Training
5 Energy and consumables
6 Maintenance
7 Spare parts
8 Downtime
9 Defects and returns
10 Cost of money under payment terms
11 Less residual value
Total TCO
TCO per year or per unit produced
Non-financial score (risk, reliability, service)

5. Hypothetical example: how can the lowest quote become the most expensive over 5 years?

A small factory will buy one packing machine for 5 years and receives three quotations. Units are thousand baht over the 5 years. Everything is a hypothetical example (no present-value discounting, to keep it readable).

Common assumptions: one hour of downtime costs about 5 thousand baht of profit; the cost of money is about 8 percent a year.

ComponentA (cheapest)BC (most expensive)
Purchase price1,0001,2501,450
Freight and import604030
Installation403020
Training201510
Energy and consumables750600500
Maintenance300200150
Spare parts250150100
Downtime600 (120 hrs)150 (30 hrs)50 (10 hrs)
Defects and returns1506020
Cost of money under payment terms20 (paid in full up front)5 (three instalments)-10 (paid 30 days after acceptance)
Less residual value-50-150-250
Total TCO over 5 years3,1402,3502,070

Reading the result: A is 450 cheaper than C on the face of the quotation but 1,070 more expensive over 5 years. The cause is not price but energy, downtime and spare parts, which the cheap supplier never put in its quotation.

Cautions in using the example

  • The downtime hours and energy figures are estimates. Ask reference customers for data and trial the machine.
  • Run a sensitivity table: vary downtime hours and electricity price. If the ranking flips easily, the numbers are not solid.
  • Anything the supplier is not bound to in the contract should be costed on the worse case.

6. What warranty and defect liability should we have?

What the law already gives. Under section 472 of the Civil and Commercial Code the seller is liable for a defect that reduces the value of the property or its fitness for ordinary use or the use agreed, whether or not the seller knew of the defect. The limits are:

  • Section 473: the seller is not liable in some cases, for example where the buyer knew or should have known, or the defect was visible and the buyer accepted delivery without objection, and in the case of a public auction.
  • Section 474: no suit may be brought after one year from the time the defect was discovered.

These rules apply to a sale. For a contract for work, or a contract with several installation components, the time limits and conditions may differ. See machinery not meeting specification: repair, refund or withholding payment.

What to add to the contract, because the general law does not answer it:

ItemWhat to write
Warranty periodCounted from the acceptance date, not the delivery date, and say whether parts and labour are both covered
ScopeWhat is not covered (consumables, misuse) must be stated clearly
RemedyRepair, replace or refund within how many days
Cost during downtimeWhether the supplier is liable, and the liability cap
Warranty extensionAfter a major repair or replacement of key parts

Check that these match the terms in the quotation and the purchase order. If the documents conflict, see quotation and purchase order with conflicting terms.

7. How should spare parts, SLA and service credits be written?

The general law does not require a seller to keep spare parts or to repair within any set time. These only count if written into the contract.

Spare parts commitment

  • How long the seller guarantees spare parts (for example how many years after the model is discontinued)
  • Delivery time for key parts, and a recommended parts list with prices
  • If parts production stops, advance notice and an opportunity to buy a final batch or receive the drawings to make them ourselves

SLA (service level agreement)

MeasureExample term to set
Response timeReply within how many working hours
Time to siteTechnician on site within how many hours, by severity level
Time to restoreRepair completed within how many hours or days
ReplacementWhether a loan machine or part is provided during repair
Service creditIf times are missed, a price reduction or refund under an agreed formula
How measuredWho logs the time, when the clock starts, and through which channel the report is made

Tie the service credit to a formula that can be calculated, and if it is set as a penalty also read section 8.

8. How should late-delivery penalties be written so they work?

Late delivery costs production opportunity and delays delivery to your own customers. Set a clear delivery date and a penalty per day of delay.

  • Section 379: if a debtor promises to pay a sum as a penalty for not performing, the penalty becomes forfeitable once the debtor is in default.
  • Section 380: the creditor may claim the penalty instead of performance, and if it can claim damages for non-performance it may treat the penalty as minimum damages and prove a greater loss.
  • Section 383: if the penalty is disproportionately high the court may reduce it to a reasonable amount, considering all the creditor's lawful interests, and once the penalty has been paid the right to ask for reduction ends as that section provides.

In practice

  • Set the penalty in proportion to the real loss you can estimate, not disproportionately high.
  • Set an overall cap and a right to terminate if the delay passes an agreed limit.
  • Define force majeure and the number of days within which the supplier must give notice.
  • Check that the penalty and the SLA service credit do not overlap unintentionally.

When delivery is late, send written notice reserving the right to the penalty before or when you take the goods, rather than staying silent.

9. How do we accept the goods without losing rights?

Under section 473, accepting a visible defect without objection may relieve the seller of liability, so acceptance matters as much as negotiating the price.

  • State in the contract what the acceptance criteria are: which figures, tested where, with what material
  • Split acceptance into stages: factory acceptance test, test after installation, and a trial running period
  • Tie the final payment to passing acceptance, not to delivery
  • Sign for conditional acceptance with a list of outstanding items if defects remain; do not sign an ordinary acceptance
  • Keep test reports, photos and running data as evidence

10. How does this differ from the guide on depending on a single supplier?

This guide answers who to choose, and on which numbers, before buying. The backup plan when depending on one factory answers once you depend on one supplier, how to reduce the risk and prepare a backup. They work together: the lowest TCO may point to a single supplier, which then calls for a backup plan.

11. What should we check before choosing a supplier?

  • Write the requirement and the planned life before asking for quotations
  • Separate must-have and scored criteria, and set the weights before seeing prices
  • Send the same 11-item form to every bidder
  • Compare TCO per year or per unit, with a sensitivity table
  • At least two functions evaluate, and conflicts of interest are disclosed
  • Requester, evaluators and approver are different people according to value
  • The offers that won (warranty, spare parts, SLA, delivery date) are written into the contract
  • The late-delivery penalty has a cap and a right to terminate
  • Acceptance criteria are numeric and the final payment is tied to acceptance
  • A lawyer reviews the contract before signing when the value is high or the commitment spans several years

Further reading

The lowest purchase price is not the lowest cost: compare with the 11 TCO items, set the criteria before seeing prices, then write what won the comparison into the contract, including warranty, spare parts, SLA, delivery date and acceptance criteria.

We help Thai businesses review and draft sale contracts, maintenance contracts, SLAs, penalty clauses and acceptance documents. For an initial consultation, call +66 92 254 2045 or send us the details. See also our contracts and documents and business plan services.


This guide is published by Suwanvara Law Firm — a Khon Kaen law firm established in 1986. General information only, not legal advice on a specific matter.

Frequently asked questions

What is TCO and how does it differ from the purchase price?+

TCO (Total Cost of Ownership) is the total cash actually paid over the useful life, not only the price on the quotation. It includes freight and import costs, installation, training, energy and consumables, maintenance, spare parts, downtime, defects or returns, the cost of money under the payment terms, less residual value at the end of use. For long-lived or energy-hungry items the purchase price is often a smaller share than people expect (see sections 1, 2 and 5).

Is the seller liable for defects even without a written warranty?+

Under section 472 of the Civil and Commercial Code the seller is liable for a defect that reduces the value of the property or its fitness for use, whether or not the seller knew of it. But section 473 excludes liability in some cases, for example where the buyer knew or should have known, and section 474 bars suit one year after the defect is discovered. A written warranty should be clearer than this (see section 6).

Should spare parts and repair times be written into the contract?+

Yes. The law does not oblige a seller to stock spare parts or to repair within a set time, so without a clause there is no right to demand it. State how long the seller guarantees spare parts, the response and repair times in an SLA, and the service credit if times are missed (see section 7).

If a late-delivery penalty is written in, can a court reduce it?+

Yes. Section 383 of the Civil and Commercial Code lets the court reduce a penalty that is disproportionately high to a reasonable amount, considering all of the creditor's lawful interests. Under section 379 the penalty becomes forfeitable when the debtor is in default, and section 380 lets the creditor claim the penalty instead of performance, or treat it as minimum damages and prove greater loss. Set the rate in reasonable proportion to the real loss (see section 8).

Who should approve the choice of supplier?+

The law does not name anyone; this is internal governance. Separate the requester, the evaluators and the approver, set approval limits in tiers, and have everyone involved disclose conflicts of interest (see section 3).

Lawyer-client handshake symbolizing trust at Suwanvara Law Firm

Ready to hear your story

Get an initial consultation with one of our experienced attorneys.