Skip to main content
SUWANVARA LAWFIRM
Suwanvara Law Firm Co., Ltd.
SUWANVARA LAWFIRM
SUWANVARA LAWFIRM
Suwanvara Law Firm Co., Ltd.
Business Law

Too Many SKUs and Rising Costs: Which Products to Drop Without Losing Key Customers

How to weigh the complexity cost of long-tail SKUs (changeovers, raw-material stock, warehouse space, quality checks) against a product's halo role and key customers, with options short of dropping and the supply, warranty and spare-parts obligations to check before announcing end-of-life.

Suwanvara Law Firm— Business Law TeamNovember 21, 202614 min read
Too Many SKUs and Rising Costs: Which Products to Drop Without Losing Key Customers

The core answer

Do not drop a SKU only because it sells little or earns a low margin per unit. Weigh three things together. First, the complexity cost it creates (changeovers, dedicated raw materials and safety stock, planning time, warehouse space, quality checks, small batches). Second, its role: is it a reason customers buy other items from you? Third, which key customers buy it and what they would do if you stopped selling it.

If the numbers say drop, try lighter options first: a minimum order, a price increase, make-to-order, a longer lead time, or consolidating variants. An actual discontinuation needs a check of the contracts still in force, open purchase orders, warranty periods and spare parts still owed. Then notify customers in advance and offer a last-time-buy.

Legal frame. This is mainly a management question. The law comes in through what you have bound yourself to in contracts, quotations and warranty documents. This guide does not claim a specific provision obliges every seller to stock spare parts in all cases. What matters is what your own contracts and documents say.

Per-SKU margin, ABC/XYZ grouping and the discontinue decision table are already covered in Cash tied up in stock and product profitability analysis. This guide does not repeat them. It picks up where that table says "drop" and asks what dropping would cost.

Who should read which part

Your stageSections to read
Before decidingSections 1 to 5: complexity cost, product role, who buys it, options short of dropping
In progressSections 7 to 9: contracts, open orders, warranty, spare parts, and the customer notice
Numbers not going to planSections 3 and 4: check whether lost customers came from the dropped item; section 5: consider bringing it back with conditions

1. What is the complexity cost of a SKU?

Standard unit cost rarely includes the work caused by "having this item at all". Use this table to find those hidden costs.

Complexity costHow it arisesRough way to estimate
ChangeoversMachine stops, mould or cleaning changes, set-up, start-up scrapChangeovers per year x hours stopped x machine and labour cost per hour
Dedicated raw materials and packagingSmall lots at a higher price, or minimum buys above actual usePrice difference plus the value of excess material sitting in stock
Safety stockEvery item needs a buffer, so more items means more total bufferThis SKU's safety stock x annual cost of capital and obsolescence
Planning and purchasingForecasting, ordering, chasing, handling one more line on every orderHours per month x staff cost
Warehouse space and handlingDedicated shelving, labels, counts, scattered pickingStorage positions x cost per position
Quality checksCriteria to set, incoming inspection, retained samples per lotInspections per year x time x equipment and staff cost
Small batchesSet-up cost per unit is high because it cannot be spreadSet-up cost per run divided by units in that run
Service and paperworkQuotes, product data, manuals, customer questions, returnsSales and service hours per SKU

In practice, estimate baht per year per SKU and write it next to gross profit. It need not be precise on every line. It only has to show which SKUs cost more in complexity than the profit they make. Shared costs that do not fall when the item goes (such as the rent on the whole plant) are not savings. Always ask whether a line really shrinks if you drop the item, and when. Cost allocation under accounting rules is a job for your accountant.

2. Should a low-profit long-tail SKU be cut immediately?

No. A slow seller whose profit after complexity is negative can still have a reason to stay, in three ways.

  • It helps sell other items. Customers buy it together with your main products (see section 3).
  • A key customer is tied to it. A large customer has specified it in their own systems, or a framework agreement includes it (see sections 4 and 7).
  • There is an obligation to keep serving it. Units already sold are in warranty or need spare parts (see section 8).

If none of these applies and the complexity numbers clearly show a loss, it is a clear candidate to drop. Look at the options in section 5 first to decide how.

3. Does this product help sell other products (halo and basket role)?

Some products earn little themselves but are the reason a customer buys your whole set, such as a special size a contractor needs on the same project as your standard sizes, or a spare part that makes a customer comfortable buying the main machine. A simple check:

  1. Pull the last 12 months of purchase orders and list those containing this SKU.
  2. See what else is on those orders and how much profit it earns.
  3. Ask sales and the customer directly: without this item, would the customer keep buying the rest, or move the whole set to someone else?
  4. Assume a range, for example the customer might cut purchases by 10 to 30 percent, and compare the profit that could go with the complexity cost you would save.

Step 4 is an estimate, not a fact. Use it to see whether the decision is "clear loss" or "close call". If it is a close call, choose an option you can reverse before dropping outright.

A caution: an apparent halo can be coincidence, such as one large customer ordering several items together. Check whether there was ever a period when the item was out of stock and how that customer's other purchases changed then.

4. Which key customers buy tail SKUs, and what would they do if you drop them?

Build a customer-by-SKU table for the customers that make up most of your sales, and add the questions sales must answer.

QuestionWhy it matters
How much of this SKU does the customer buy per year, and what share of their total purchases from you is it?Shows whether it is truly important to them or an occasional buy
Is there a substitute in your range, and how easy is the switch?If switching is easy, advance notice with a recommended replacement is often enough
What would they do: switch model, move the whole basket, or not care?Used to assess the risk to total sales
Do they have a framework agreement, pre-agreed price or a specification embedded in their process?If so, change takes time and usually comes with contract conditions

Large customers that buy several tail items should be spoken to in person before any general announcement. If one customer is so large that it affects the whole business, read Depending on one big customer as well.

5. What options are there short of dropping?

OptionSuitsWatch out for
Minimum order quantityCost comes mainly from small lots and changeoversSmall customers may leave; the contract may allow orders below the minimum
Price increase to reflect true costCustomers who need the item and have no easy substituteContract or quotation prices may be fixed; give notice as the contract requires
Make-to-orderIrregular demand, safety stock high relative to salesLonger lead time; tell customers and put it in writing
Longer lead timeSmall lots can be combined into one production runIf the contract fixes delivery dates, an extension needs agreement
Consolidate near-identical variantsSeveral colours or sizes customers treat as interchangeableKey customers may need to test or accept the new specification first
Hand the item to another supplier or makerAnother reliable producer existsQuality and warranty responsibility must be agreed clearly

These can be combined and tried for a short period before you decide. If cost falls and customers stay, you may not need to drop anything. Before changing price or terms, always read the contract in use. If you have given price commitments, see also Most-favoured-customer (best price) clauses.

6. Hypothetical example: a plastic pipe-fitting distributor

Hypothetical example. This is not a real case and all figures are illustrative. A fictional company makes and sells plastic pipe fittings. Six items are under review. Figures are baht per year.

SKUSalesGross profitEstimated complexity costProfit after complexityCustomers and role
A 1-inch fitting, white4,000,000800,000120,000680,000Core item, general customers
B 1-inch fitting, grey600,000108,00090,00018,000Mainly contractor X
C 2-inch fitting1,500,000330,000100,000230,000Core item
D 3-inch special type250,00037,500110,000-72,500Distributor Y buys it with A and C
E 4-inch made to order180,00045,00095,000-50,000Customer Z under a framework agreement, 2 years left
F old-model seal spare90,00027,00060,000-33,000Customers who bought the old model, still in warranty
Total6,620,0001,347,500575,000772,500

On the numbers alone, D, E and F lose 155,500 baht per year together and all three look like candidates to drop. A closer look shows each needs different handling.

  • D. Distributor Y buys about 1,000,000 baht a year of A and C, with gross profit of roughly 210,000 baht. If Y cut its purchases by 25 percent for lack of D, about 52,500 baht of profit would go. Against the 72,500 baht of complexity cost saved on D, the gain is only 20,000 baht, close enough that D should not be dropped immediately. Try a minimum order and a price increase first.
  • E. The framework agreement with Z requires supply for two more years, so dropping it mid-term without a right to do so would be a breach. The practical routes are make-to-order, or talking to Z about price or consolidating variants, and not renewing when the term ends.
  • F. Customers are still in warranty and the warranty document says parts will be replaced, so the company must plan to keep parts or an equivalent until the warranty period ends, and only then end the item.

Taken together, the real first-year saving is well below 155,500 baht, and part of it must wait until the contracts and warranty periods end. The example only shows the way of thinking. A real company's figures must come from its own accounts and contracts.

7. When can a product be ended under the contract, and how is notice given?

Before announcing, go through the contracts and documents binding you, group by group.

  • Supply contracts and framework agreements. Are you bound to supply the item for the whole term? Did you agree a minimum volume? What do the termination and non-renewal terms say?
  • Notice terms. Some contracts require advance notice before changing or ending a product and set out how notice is sent (to whom, by what channel). Follow what the contract says. For managing all notice dates, see A contract register and renewal notice dates.
  • Open purchase orders. Orders you have accepted generally have to be delivered in full, or cancelled by written agreement with the customer.
  • Prices and terms agreed in advance. Quotations still valid and contract prices remain binding until they expire or are changed as agreed.
  • Agent or distributor agreements. If the item is sold through an agent or distributor, check what was agreed on the product list, the stock they hold, and their rights when you withdraw a product. See Ending a distributor agreement: stock, brand, customers.

If a contract requires you to keep supplying the item and you stop without a right to do so, the customer may claim damages as the contract and the general law allow, depending on the wording and the facts. The safer course is to agree a change or an end with the customer and put it in writing.

8. Warranty, spare parts and service still owed after you stop selling

Ending sales does not end your obligations for units already sold. Check three things.

  • Warranty period. Are units already sold still in warranty, until when, and what does the warranty document say you must repair or replace? If a warranted unit needs a part you are about to stop making, you need a plan until the period ends. See Product plus after-sales service and warranty.
  • Spare parts and service. What you have promised customers in contracts, quotations, catalogues or statements (for example "spare parts available for at least five years") binds you as written. Where nothing at all was agreed on spare parts, this guide does not say a specific statutory duty exists, but a customer may rely on the wording of a quotation, catalogue or earlier arrangement, so have a lawyer read the documents before you announce.
  • Liability for units already sold. Units on the market may later show a quality problem and need a recall. See Product recalls and the responsibilities of brand, maker and distributor. Ending sales does not close this.

If consumer products are on the list, see the Office of the Consumer Protection Board (ocpb.go.th) on advertising and warranties. Information as at 21 November 2026.

9. How to tell customers, and the last-time-buy offer

The notice should be simple and complete.

  • What to include. The models being ended, the last order date, the last delivery date, the recommended replacement, and the price.
  • Offer a last-time-buy. Let customers place one last order by the deadline so they have stock to carry on. State the maximum quantity you will accept, payment terms, and what is excluded (for example no returns).
  • Warranty and spare parts afterwards. Say clearly how long you will support the item and whom to contact.
  • Order of notice. Key customers first (by phone or in person), then a written letter, then the general announcement.
  • Keep evidence. Date sent, channel and recipient.

Prepare answers in advance to "can I order less than that?", "what replaces it?" and "what is the new price?", and have the sales team use one consistent message so customers do not hear different things.

10. Checklist before announcing a SKU's end

  • Estimate complexity cost per SKU and check which costs really fall when it goes (section 1)
  • Pull 12 months of purchase orders and see whose other purchases this SKU travels with (section 3)
  • Build the key-customer table for this SKU and what each would likely do (section 4)
  • Try the lighter options and compare results over a short period (section 5)
  • Go through supply contracts, framework agreements, agent and distributor agreements and live quotations (section 7)
  • Check notice terms, how notice must be sent, and the last date to give it
  • Summarise open purchase orders and agree in writing how each will be closed
  • Check warranty periods, spare parts and promises in sales documents (section 8)
  • Prepare the notice, the last-time-buy offer and the replacement product (section 9)
  • Ask your accountant about writing off remaining stock and the accounting entries
  • Set review dates 30 and 90 days after the announcement to see how key customers' purchases moved

Common misunderstandings

MisunderstandingCorrection
"Low sales and low profit, so just drop it."Look at complexity cost, any halo role, which customers are tied to it, and contract obligations before deciding.
"Dropping the item removes the cost I calculated."Many shared costs do not fall at once. Check which lines really fall and when.
"As the seller I can stop supplying whenever I like."If a framework agreement or order binds you, stopping may be a breach. Check before announcing.
"A website notice is enough."Customers bound by contract should get notice in the way the contract requires, and key customers should be spoken to first.
"Once I stop selling, warranty and spare parts are finished."Units already sold may still be in warranty, and spare-parts promises bind you as written.
"The law requires sellers to keep spare parts in every case."This guide does not say so. The spare-parts duty depends on the contract, the sales documents and the facts.

Limits of this guide. It does not cover margin calculation or ABC/XYZ analysis (see the inventory guide). It is not accounting or tax advice, and it cannot take your own contracts into account. The answer changes with binding contracts, consumer products, specially regulated goods or foreign counterparties. Information as at 21 November 2026.

Further reading

A good SKU cut removes the items whose complexity cost exceeds their real profit, after checking that it does not take key customers and contract obligations with it.

This guide sets out a management framework. The firm helps review supply contracts, framework agreements, warranty documents and customer notices connected with ending a product, and helps plan the business side where it meets the law. It is not an accountant, auditor or production consultant, and it cannot promise the outcome of negotiations with customers. Fees depend on the stage of the matter and the work involved. Send us your documents first, and we will set out the scope of work and fees in writing before work begins. Call +66 92 254 2045 or send us the details. See also Business plan and Contracts and documents.


This guide is published by Suwanvara Law Firm — a Khon Kaen law firm established in 1986. General information only, not legal advice on a specific matter.

Frequently asked questions

Can I drop a low-margin, slow-selling product straight away?+

Not on margin per unit alone. First deduct the complexity cost the product creates (changeovers, dedicated raw-material stock, warehouse space, quality checks), then ask whether it is the reason key customers buy your other products. Finally check the contracts and delivery obligations still running, because ending supply mid-contract can be a breach.

How do I measure a halo product that helps sell other items?+

Look back through purchase orders to see which customers bought it together with other items and how much profit those items made. Then judge whether, without it, the customer would keep buying the rest from you or move the whole basket elsewhere. The result is an estimate, so ask the sales team and try lighter options before dropping.

Are there options other than dropping a product?+

Yes: a minimum order quantity, a price increase that reflects true cost, make-to-order, a longer lead time, or consolidating near-identical variants. These usually affect customers less than stopping the item entirely, but check first whether the contract fixes price and delivery terms.

Which contracts should I check before announcing end-of-life?+

Check any supply contract or framework agreement still in force: whether you are bound to supply the item for the whole term, how much notice is required, what open orders exist, whether warranty periods are still running, and whether anything was agreed on spare parts or after-sales service. Then plan the customer notice and a last-time-buy offer.

What is a last-time-buy?+

An offer to let customers place one final order for a model being discontinued, within a deadline, so they have stock while they find a replacement. State the last order date, the quantity you can make, the price terms, and what applies to warranty and spare parts afterwards, in writing.

Lawyer-client handshake symbolizing trust at Suwanvara Law Firm

Ready to hear your story

Get an initial consultation with one of our experienced attorneys.