Skip to main content
SUWANVARA LAWFIRM
Suwanvara Law Firm Co., Ltd.
SUWANVARA LAWFIRM
SUWANVARA LAWFIRM
Suwanvara Law Firm Co., Ltd.
Business Law

Profitable company, but which branch or department really makes money? Branch and department profit reporting

How to split direct revenue and costs by branch, allocate head-office costs without being misled, separate controllable from uncontrollable costs, read return on investment, and what to check before closing a branch: lease, employees and customer contracts.

Suwanvara Law Firm— Business Law TeamNovember 12, 202614 min read
Profitable company, but which branch or department really makes money? Branch and department profit reporting

Owners with several branches or departments often face the same situation. The consolidated accounts show a profit at year end, but nobody can say for sure which branch really makes money and which one is being carried by the others. Some look only at sales. Others split head-office expenses equally, conclude that the small branch loses money, and then close a branch that was in fact helping to pay the company's costs.

This guide shows how to build a branch (or department) profit report you can decide with: separating direct revenue and direct costs, allocating central costs carefully, separating controllable from uncontrollable costs, looking at profit, cash and capital invested, and the lease, employee and customer points to check before closing a branch. Every figure in the examples is a hypothetical example (ตัวอย่างสมมติ).

This guide differs from the checklist before opening a second branch, which covers readiness before opening. This guide starts once several branches are already running, and answers how to measure each one fairly and how to decide when one does not pay.

The core answer

  • Look at contribution before profit after allocation. Contribution is a branch's revenue less all direct costs that branch causes. If it is still positive, the branch is helping to pay the company's central costs.
  • Central costs can be allocated in several ways, and every formula changes the result. Use allocation for the overall picture, but do not use it alone to decide on closing, because most of those costs do not disappear when a branch closes.
  • Judge managers on what they control, not on rent the owner agreed or central costs spread to the branch.
  • Profit, cash and capital invested are different things. A profitable branch can still consume cash through stock and receivables, and a branch with low profit relative to its capital may not be worth it even when the books are positive.
  • Before closing a branch, work out the contribution that will be lost, the central costs that remain, the rent still payable, employee compensation (Labour Protection Act sections 17, 118, 120) and obligations to customers, then compare with other fixes.

1. Why does overall profit not tell me which branch makes money?

The consolidated profit and loss only says how much the whole company keeps, not where it came from. Three problems are common.

  1. Sales used instead of profit. A branch with high sales may have heavy discounts, high labour or a lot of dead stock.
  2. No branch code in the accounts. Expenses are booked together and cannot be traced to a branch.
  3. Central costs split for convenience, for example equally, which makes a small branch look worse than it is.

The result is decisions by feeling: more budget for the loudest branch, or closing the one that looks bad on paper. Before building the report, agree on one thing first: what question is the report for, for instance which branch to expand, where to add or cut staff, or which branch to close?

2. What are direct revenue and direct costs per branch, and how do I separate them?

Direct revenue is revenue generated by the branch's own sales or services. If a customer orders online and collects at the branch, set the rule in advance on which branch gets the credit.

Direct costs are costs that would not exist without the branch. There are two groups.

GroupExamplesHow to record
Direct variable costsCost of goods sold, raw materials, sales commission, packaging, outbound deliveryTag with the branch code when goods are received or the purchase order is issued
Direct fixed costsBranch rent, branch staff salaries, utilities, insurance on branch assets, depreciation of equipment in the branchTag with the branch code in the accounting system or journal

Branch contribution = direct revenue − direct variable costs − direct fixed costs

Common mistakes:

  • Staff who work at several branches: record hours and split by actual time. Do not let one branch carry everything.
  • Stock transfers between branches: set a clear transfer price and use the same one every month, otherwise one branch looks good because another is squeezed.
  • Damaged or lost goods belong to the branch where it happened, not to head office.
  • Supporting documents such as tax invoices, leases and receipts of each branch should be filed by branch. See also controlling contracts and employee documents across branches.

3. What are central costs, and which methods can allocate them to branches?

Central costs are costs the whole company uses together: salaries of owners and management, accounting and HR, computer systems, shared brand marketing, consultants, head-office rent and audit.

MethodSuitsWhere it misleads
By share of revenueCosts that grow with sales, such as shared marketingA high-selling branch is charged a lot even though some central costs do not grow with sales
By headcountHR, payroll systemsA branch that uses many staff but sells a lot per head is penalised
By floor areaShared utilitiesDoes not reflect who uses central services
By number of transactionsBookkeeping, document issueNeeds a counting system, otherwise it is an estimate
Equal splitWhen no clear cost driver existsA small branch bears far too much

Good practice:

  • Choose a cost driver that really relates to that cost and write the formula down.
  • Keep the same formula for at least a year. Do not change it to get a wanted result.
  • Show the report in two layers: contribution before allocation, and profit after allocation.
  • Always ask: if this branch closed, would this central cost really fall? If not, it should not be a reason to close the branch.

4. How can allocation mislead?

  • Costs do not disappear when a branch closes. Central costs allocated to the closed branch fall back on the remaining branches, which then look worse and may be closed in turn.
  • Change the formula, change the result. The same branch can show profit or loss depending on the formula. If the result flips only because the formula changed, it is not yet fit for decisions.
  • The figures look more exact than they are. Allocation is an estimate, not an accounting fact.
  • Managers argue over the formula instead of fixing performance, once they know it affects their score.
  • New branches are penalised because revenue is still low while fixed costs are full. Compare with the start-up plan, not with mature branches.

5. How do controllable and uncontrollable costs differ, and why separate them?

Controllable costs are those a branch manager decides or directly influences within the accounting period. Uncontrollable costs result from decisions by the owner or head office.

Manager can controlManager cannot control
Sales and discounts within policyRent and lease terms the owner agreed
Cost of sales from shrinkage, waste, stock countsCentral costs allocated to the branch
Overtime and shift rosterDepreciation on buildings and equipment the owner paid for
Consumables used in the branchPurchase prices from a central contract negotiated by head office
Follow-up of the branch's receivablesInterest on loans used to fund the branch

Separate them to:

  1. Evaluate and reward managers fairly, on what they can actually fix.
  2. Show who owns the problem. If a branch earns little because rent is high, the issue is location or lease, not the manager's skill.
  3. Decide whether to close, using the costs relevant to that decision.

If bonuses are linked to branch measures, write the formula and measures in a document the employees acknowledge. See the thinking on bonuses in annual bonus vs performance bonus.

6. How do profit, cash and capital invested differ for a branch?

ViewQuestion it answersExample measures
ProfitDo sales exceed costs?Contribution, profit after allocation
CashHow much money really comes in and goes out?Branch operating cash, stock and receivables outstanding
Capital investedWas the money put in worth it?Return on investment, payback period

Branch return on investment = annual contribution ÷ capital invested in that branch. Capital includes fit-out, equipment, rent deposits, average stock and average receivables. Some companies use profit after allocation instead, which is stricter. Pick one formula and compare it with your own cost of capital, such as loan interest or what the money could earn elsewhere.

A high-profit branch whose stock and receivables grow fast can still run short of cash. See profitable but short of cash and cash tied up in stock and product profitability.

7. Hypothetical example (ตัวอย่างสมมติ): why does Branch C look loss-making after allocation but contribute positively before it?

A hypothetical company has three branches and central costs of THB 350,000 a month, allocated by share of revenue (figures in baht per month).

ItemBranch ABranch BBranch CTotal
Direct revenue1,200,000800,000500,0002,500,000
Cost of goods sold600,000400,000250,0001,250,000
Direct fixed costs (rent, staff, utilities)380,000270,000190,000840,000
Contribution220,000130,00060,000410,000
Central costs allocated (48% / 32% / 20%)168,000112,00070,000350,000
Profit after allocation52,00018,000(10,000)60,000

The old report concludes that Branch C loses THB 10,000 a month and should be closed. If it is really closed:

ItemEffect per month (baht)
Contribution of Branch C lost(60,000)
Central costs that actually fall (assume none)0
Company profit after closing0 (from 60,000)

In this example closing Branch C reduces total profit, and that is before the one-off closing costs. If some central cost really can be cut, such as one support post, put in that real figure, not the allocated figure.

Now capital. Assume capital invested of 6,000,000, 4,000,000 and 3,500,000 baht in A, B and C.

Branch ABranch BBranch C
Annual contribution2,640,0001,560,000720,000
Capital invested6,000,0004,000,0003,500,000
Return on investment (approx.)44%39%21%

Branch C is still positive but lowest relative to the money put in. Options to consider before closing: renegotiate rent, adjust opening hours and staffing, change the product mix, or move recoverable capital to branches with a higher return. A lower return does not always mean closing. All figures are hypothetical, to show the reasoning only.

8. What should I check before closing a branch?

A. Contribution and the central costs that stay. Calculate as in section 7, using the central costs that can really be cut.

B. The lease. Check the remaining term, early termination terms, forfeiture of deposit or advance rent, rent payable to the end of the term, removal and handback, and any right to sublet or assign the lease. The landlord may refuse early exit, so the contract terms set the real cost of closing.

C. Employees. This is the cost people most often underestimate.

  • If it is a dismissal, the employer must pay severance under Labour Protection Act section 118 by continuous service: thirty days of final wages for one hundred and twenty days but under one year, ninety days for one year but under three, one hundred and eighty days for three but under six, two hundred and forty days for six but under ten, three hundred days for ten but under twenty, and four hundred days for twenty years or more. A fixed-term employee whose term ends on schedule is outside this rule as the section provides.
  • Notice under section 17 paragraph 2: for a contract with no fixed term, written notice must be given on or before a wage payment date, to take effect on the next wage payment date, and notice need not exceed three months. The employer may pay wages in lieu and let the employee leave at once (paragraph 3).
  • Moving staff to another branch instead of dismissal. Section 120 provides that an employer who wishes to move an establishment to a new place, or to another place of the employer, must post a notice for employees to see for not less than thirty days before the move, stating which employees are moved where and when. If no notice is posted, special compensation in lieu of notice equal to thirty days of final wages (or the last thirty days' wages for piece-rate employees) is payable to employees who do not wish to work at the new place. Separately, an employee who considers that the move seriously affects their or their family's normal life and does not wish to go must notify the employer in writing within thirty days of the notice being posted (or of the move, if no notice was posted); the contract then ends on the moving date and the employee is entitled to special severance pay of not less than the section 118 rate. The employer must pay within seven days of the contract ending, and if it disagrees with the employee's reasons it must petition the Labour Welfare Committee within thirty days of receiving the notice. This section deals with moving the establishment and advance notice. Moving an individual employee in a way that seriously affects the employee's rights needs a separate check of the employment contract and consent.
  • Unpaid wages, accrued leave, agreed bonuses and other sums under the contract or work rules must be included in the calculation.

D. Customer and partner contracts. Ongoing service contracts, product warranties, vouchers or customer prepayments, dealer or territory rights granted, and supplier contracts with per-branch minimum orders. Plan who takes over and who must be notified.

E. Other matters. Branch registration, tax, branch licences, keeping the branch's accounting records, and stock to move or sell off. Consult your accountant and lawyer before announcing the closure.

Closing cost itemWho provides the information
Contribution lostAccounting
Central costs that can really be cutOwner, accountant
Rent and deposit lostLease, lawyer
Employee compensation and unpaid sumsHR, lawyer
Obligations to customers and suppliersEach contract

9. If I must decide, what are the options besides closing or not closing?

SituationOptions to consider
Contribution negative and not fixable within the set timeClose or merge the branch after the full closing cost is calculated
Contribution positive but return on investment lowCut fixed costs, renegotiate rent, change the branch format
New branch not yet at break-even per planSet a clear time and number threshold before deciding
Problem is location or rentRelocate (see section 120 on informing employees) or renegotiate the lease
Problem is the managerReplace or train, checked separately from uncontrollable costs
Need cash fastSell stock, collect receivables, instead of closing the whole branch

Set triggers in advance, for example how many months of contribution below target will trigger a review, and write them into the business plan to reduce emotional decisions. See deciding between machinery, hiring or a new branch with limited capital and own branches, franchise or dealers.

10. What should I do in the first month to start branch reporting?

  • Define the purpose of the report (expand, close, adjust staff, evaluate managers)
  • Open branch/department codes in the accounting system and require a code on every entry
  • Agree rules for revenue that spans branches (online orders, collection at a branch)
  • Set transfer prices between branches and use them the same every month
  • List all central costs, choose a cost driver for each and write the formula down
  • Produce the two-layer report (contribution and profit after allocation) with controllable costs separated
  • Gather capital invested per branch (fit-out, equipment, deposits, stock, receivables)
  • Look at cash by branch, not only profit
  • Collect each branch's lease, employment and customer contracts, with expiry dates and exit terms
  • Set the branch review triggers in advance and hold a monthly review
  • Before deciding to close or move, have a lawyer and accountant check closing costs and the employee notice steps

Further reading

A report you can decide with looks at contribution before profit after allocation, separates controllable from uncontrollable costs, checks cash and return on investment, and totals the closing cost of the lease, employees and customers before any decision.

We help review leases, employment contracts and customer contracts, and advise on labour matters before a branch is moved or closed. For an initial consultation, call +66 92 254 2045 or send us the details. See also business plan, accounting and tax and labour compliance.


This guide is published by Suwanvara Law Firm — a Khon Kaen law firm established in 1986. General information only, not legal advice on a specific matter.

Frequently asked questions

Why does the company make a profit overall while some branches look loss-making?+

Most branch reports spread central costs such as management salaries, the accounting system and shared marketing across branches using a formula the owner picked. A small branch can be charged far more than it causes. Look at contribution (revenue less all direct costs of the branch) before profit after allocation. A branch with positive contribution is still helping to carry central costs.

Should a branch manager be judged on profit after allocation?+

No. Judge the manager on what he or she can control, such as sales, cost of goods, labour under the shift roster and waste. Rent the owner agreed, allocated central costs and depreciation on buildings the owner paid for are outside the manager's reach, so show them separately but do not use them to judge performance.

If I close a loss-making branch, does company profit rise immediately?+

Not always. If the branch has positive contribution, closing it removes that contribution, while the central costs once allocated to it usually stay and fall on the remaining branches. Deduct the closing costs, such as rent that must still be paid under the lease, severance under the Labour Protection Act section 118 and deposits or stock that cannot be recovered. Calculate before deciding.

How must employees be informed if the workplace of a branch is moved?+

Labour Protection Act section 120 requires an employer who wants to move an establishment to a new place to post a notice in an open place at the establishment, visible to employees, for not less than thirty days before the move, stating which employees will be moved where and when. If no notice is posted, special compensation in lieu of notice is payable to employees who do not wish to work at the new place. An employee for whom the move seriously affects their or their family's normal life, and who notifies the employer in writing within thirty days that they will not move, is entitled to special severance pay of not less than the section 118 rate. If the change is large or the move is far, check each employment contract and obtain consent person by person.

What must be paid to employees when a branch closes and they are dismissed?+

If it is a dismissal and the employee does not fall within the exceptions in section 118, severance is payable by continuous service, from thirty days' wages for those with one hundred and twenty days' service up to four hundred days' wages for twenty years or more. Written notice under section 17 paragraph 2 is also needed, or wages in lieu, and notice need not exceed three months. Have a specialist check each employee before announcing.

Lawyer-client handshake symbolizing trust at Suwanvara Law Firm

Ready to hear your story

Get an initial consultation with one of our experienced attorneys.