Skip to main content
SUWANVARA LAWFIRM
Suwanvara Law Firm Co., Ltd.
SUWANVARA LAWFIRM
SUWANVARA LAWFIRM
Suwanvara Law Firm Co., Ltd.
Civil Litigation Guide

The Debtor Lives in One Province but Has Assets in Another: How a Creditor Enforces in Thailand

A creditor's guide: the court that heard the case is the enforcing court, and under Section 271 of the Civil Procedure Code another court can enforce on its behalf when the asset lies outside its territory. It explains who does what, what documents to prepare, how to prioritise assets in several areas, and whether the creditor must travel, which depends on the task and the authority delegated.

Suwanvara Law Firm— Civil Litigation & Enforcement TeamNovember 20, 202617 min read
The Debtor Lives in One Province but Has Assets in Another: How a Creditor Enforces in Thailand

The core answer

An asset located in another province does not mean you must start a new case there. Under Section 271 of the Civil Procedure Code, the enforcing court is, as a rule, the court of first instance that heard and decided the case. If enforcement has to take place outside that court's territory, the court may appoint another court to enforce on its behalf, or the creditor may file a motion, or the enforcement officer may report to the court that will act, attaching a copy of the writ or of the order fixing the method of enforcement. The substitute court then appoints an officer or issues further orders. Property seized or attached, or the sale proceeds, is sent back to the enforcing court to be dealt with according to law.

So keep three things apart: the court that decided the case, the court or officer acting at the asset, and where the asset actually is. Most creditors' problems are not about authority. They are about coordination: missing documents, an asset described too vaguely, nobody following up on the ground, or seizing without comparing priorities.

On whether the creditor must travel every time, the answer is by task, not yes or no. Paperwork and follow-up can be delegated to a lawyer or attorney if the power of attorney says so clearly. Tasks that depend on the creditor's own knowledge or on a major decision still come from the creditor. See section 6.

Your situationSections to read
Not yet sued1 and 5, to see that the location of an asset is no reason to skip steps, and to record where assets are now
Sued (case pending)1, 4 and 5, especially if you think the debtor will move assets; see the interim protection guide
Judgment obtained2 to 8, from enforcement outside the territory to progress reporting

1. How does the court that decided the case differ from where the asset is?

Three terms are often confused.

TermMeaningExample (hypothetical)
Court that decided the caseThe court of first instance that heard the case and gave judgment; as a rule the enforcing court under Section 271Province A court
Substitute courtThe court for the area where the asset lies, which takes over the enforcement on the enforcing court's behalfProvince B court
Where the asset isThe real location of the asset, such as land, a warehouse, machinery, or the address of someone who owes the debtor moneyA district in Province B

The debtor's registered address or head office is not always where the assets are. A debtor may live in Province A, own land in Province B, park a vehicle in Province C, and have a customer who owes money in Province D. Each item may need a different officer and method.

Before suing, the location of assets is not yet tied to enforcement because there is no judgment. Which court to sue in is a separate question of jurisdiction and contract, so consult a lawyer before filing. What you can do now is record the asset locations you know. If the debtor is about to move or sell assets, the court can be asked for interim protection under Sections 254 and 255, which needs evidence and is within the court's discretion. See Stopping a debtor moving assets during a case.

2. When the asset is outside the court's territory, what does the court do?

In outline, Section 271 works like this.

  1. The court that decided the case (the enforcing court) issues the order to comply and the writ of execution as usual.
  2. For enforcement outside its territory, that court may appoint another court to enforce on its behalf, or the creditor files a motion with the court that will act, or the enforcement officer reports to that court with a copy of the writ or of the order fixing the method of enforcement.
  3. The substitute court notifies the enforcing court without delay and appoints an enforcement officer or issues other orders.
  4. For seizure of property or attachment of claims, the substitute court sends the property seized or attached, or the sale proceeds, to the enforcing court to be dealt with according to law.
  5. If enforcement outside the territory is defective, mistaken or unlawful, the substitute court may revoke or correct it and direct the officer to correct it. Once enforcement is finished and reported to the enforcing court, only the enforcing court has that power.

Points to understand:

  • The original judgment is used. No new suit, and the enforcing court does not change. Work outside the territory is enforcement "on behalf".
  • Money and property flow back to the original court. Payment to the creditor goes through the enforcing court, not instantly from the destination court.
  • The route depends on the asset and the court's orders. A lawyer decides whether the original court should appoint another court or whether to notify the court where the asset lies directly.
  • Errors can be fixed along the way. Check reports and orders at each step instead of waiting until the end.

This guide gives no address or telephone number for any enforcement office branch. Those details change, so ask the court or office directly when you need them.

3. Who does what when enforcement crosses areas?

PartyRole
Enforcing court (the court that decided the case)Fixes the method of enforcement, receives money and property sent back, rules on matters about the enforcement
Substitute courtAppoints the officer or issues orders, notifies the original court, sends property or money back, corrects defects in enforcement within its area
Enforcement officerThe court's officer; acts under the writ and the Code, may call on the creditor to assist, gives reasoned orders, receives payment or property on behalf of the creditor, and reports to the court periodically (Section 278)
CreditorSupplies information and documents, identifies the asset, assists as the officer calls, makes major decisions such as whether to sell or withdraw
Lawyer or attorneyFiles motions, follows up, coordinates with courts and officers, receives notices, reports to the creditor, within the authority given

Further points from Sections 278 to 284 that matter for work outside your home area:

  • The officer acts on working days and in daylight hours unless necessary or the court permits otherwise, and must show the writ, or post a copy where nobody is present (Section 281).
  • Where there is reason to believe the debtor holds assets or related documents at premises the debtor possesses, the officer may search (Section 282). For premises held by a third party the creditor must apply ex parte for a court search warrant, and the court examines the matter before issuing it (Section 283).
  • If obstructed, the officer may ask administrative officials or police for help (Section 284).

4. What documents and information are needed for coordination?

Missing documents and vague descriptions of assets are the main causes of delay in out-of-area work. Prepare them before sending the matter.

Case documents

  • The judgment and the order to comply, with proof the debtor was notified and the time for compliance has expired
  • The writ of execution or the order fixing the method of enforcement (the copy to be attached for the substitute court)
  • The enforcing court's case number, and the enforcement case number if one exists
  • A statement of the debt still outstanding, separating principal, interest and fees under the judgment, with payments already received; see Partial payments after judgment: how the balance and interest are worked out
  • The power of attorney and identity documents of the principal (a company needs proof of directors' authority)

Information about assets in the other area

  • Type of asset, location and owner according to the evidence held, for example title deed number, vehicle registration, warehouse address
  • A map or landmarks on site for land or a storage place, and the date the location was last checked
  • Evidence linking the asset to the debtor, such as contracts, purchase orders, photographs, or lawful registry checks with their dates
  • Known rights of others, such as a mortgage, other creditors, tenants, or someone claiming ownership
  • Name and address of anyone who owes money to the debtor, if a claim is to be attached, with evidence of the relationship such as a contract, purchase order or invoice

Contact arrangements

  • Who can decide for the creditor, and a contact channel that answers in time
  • Who can point out the asset or give information on site, if needed
  • Agree beforehand which matters the lawyer may decide alone and which must be put to the creditor first

Information about assets must be obtained lawfully; see What data is lawful in asset tracing, and its limits. If you are unsure what the debtor owns, a judgment creditor may ask the court under Section 277 to examine the debtor or other persons about the debtor's assets when the creditor does not know of property or doubts its ownership.

5. With assets in several areas, how should priorities be set?

The law does not fix an order in which you must seize. It is a joint assessment by the lawyer and the creditor. Useful factors:

FactorQuestion to ask
Risk of loss or removalCan the asset be moved or used up quickly, for example money owed to the debtor or goods in a warehouse?
Ease of conversion to cashHow fast can it be sold or collected? Land goes through announcement and public auction, so it is not immediate.
Prior rights of othersIs there a mortgage or another creditor who may be paid first? See Mortgaged land and Several creditors
Proof of ownershipIs the owner on the documents really the debtor? If it is another name there may be a third-party claim; see Third-party ownership claims
Cost against valueIs follow-up outside the area worth the likely recovery?
SufficiencySeizure or attachment must not exceed what is enough to satisfy the judgment and costs (Section 300), and the creditor is liable for damage from wrongful or excessive seizure (Section 285)

Practical approach:

  • Start with the asset most at risk and best proven, one you can show belongs to the debtor and where others' rights do not overlap much.
  • Do not seize in several areas at once just because you can. If the first item may suffice, assess before widening.
  • Keep a fallback. The first asset may be objected to or sell low, so prepare the next one.
  • Record the order and the reasons, so the creditor can see why one item was handled first.
  • Watch the time limit. Section 274 contains a ten-year rule, detail for debts payable in instalments or in the future, and continued enforcement only for assets or claims already acted on within the period. Do not summarise it as "one writ lets you seize new assets forever". See Judgment enforcement and the 10-year period.

If another creditor has already seized the same asset, a creditor who wants to take part may ask to share in the distribution. If the seizing creditor withdraws and another continues under Section 327, that continuing creditor may petition under Section 328 to transfer enforcement to the court that gave judgment in that creditor's own case, if this is convenient for all parties and the receiving court consents; the order is final. This is a specific provision. It is not a general way for a creditor to move enforcement to another province for convenience.

6. Must the creditor travel every time?

There is no single answer. Look at the task and the authority delegated. The table is a guide; the real position depends on the power of attorney, the orders of the court or officer, and the facts.

TaskCan a lawyer or attorney do it?Note
Filing motions and documents, tracking statusYes, if the power of attorney covers itMost work falls here
Receiving orders and appointments from the court or officerYesThe creditor should be told of anything affecting rights
Pointing out an asset, identifying a plot, confirming which asset is the debtor'sDepends on who knows the factsThe creditor, or someone from the creditor's side who knows the area, may need to help, or a local person who is instructed
Giving facts only the creditor knows, such as dealing history or deliveryPartly, if documents are preparedIf there is an objection and evidence is needed, the creditor or a witness may have to attend
Receiving money recovered through enforcementDepends on the power of attorney and the applicationState clearly whether money may be received and into which account
Settlement, concession, or withdrawing a seizureShould be the creditor's decision, or someone with clearly stated authoritySee Who may approve a settlement
Assisting the officer when called on (Section 278)Depends on what is askedDo not ignore a call; it can hold up progress

A workable power of attorney should state

  • The case name and number to be handled, including enforcement
  • Authority to file motions, receive documents, deal with officers and act outside the court's territory; if sub-delegation is needed, the right to delegate must be stated
  • Whether money may be received, how much or by what method, and how the creditor must be told
  • Matters that are not delegated, such as settlement, debt reduction and withdrawing a seizure, which need prior written approval
  • A signatory who really has authority (for a company, a director with signing power as shown in the certificate)

7. What are the travel, follow-up and other cost items?

This guide gives no amounts, because they depend on the asset, the distance, the number of steps and the rates under the law or rules at the time. Ask the firm to set out its scope and fees in writing before work starts. Items to ask about:

ItemWhat to ask
Travel and accommodationWho goes, how many times, actual cost or agreed in advance, whether approval is needed first
Local helperWhether needed, for what (inspecting the asset, photographs, pointing out location), and how it is charged
Enforcement fees and costsWhat must be deposited with the court or officer, including announcement costs and other costs of the process, which the creditor may need to advance
Copies, certification, postageDocuments to be sent to the court or officer outside the area
Checking asset informationLawful registry checks and inspection of the asset
Legal fees by stageWhether charged by work done or by stage, and what is covered

Agree in advance the amount above which the creditor must be asked first, and include costs incurred so far in every report so they can be compared with the likely recovery. See Instructing Thai counsel on debt recovery: evidence, budget and reporting for budgeting in phases.

8. How should progress be followed and reported?

Out-of-area work involves many hands and several offices. If nobody owns the follow-up, things go quiet. Agree at the start:

  • A lead contact, one person the creditor can reach, and a deputy
  • Reporting rhythm, for example on every significant event, plus a summary at agreed intervals
  • What each report contains: what was filed or done, with which court or officer, the date, the status, what is pending, the next date, what is needed from the creditor, costs so far, risks and limits
  • Attachments: copies of orders, the officer's report, site photographs where available
  • Limits stated plainly, such as assets not yet verified, others' prior rights, possible objections, and no guaranteed timeline, since duration depends on the asset, the number of creditors and objections
  • Closing: when the work finishes or stops, a full summary and the documents to keep

The officer reports to the court periodically under Section 278. The lawyer should obtain those reports and orders and explain them to the creditor, not forward raw documents without explanation.

Hypothetical example

Note This example is invented. It is not a real client and gives no outcome figures.

A building-materials seller wins a judgment in the Province A court. The debtor is a company registered in Province A. The seller knows the company owns land with a warehouse in Province B, and that a large customer in Province C owes it money for work done.

  1. Separate the court from the asset locations. The Province A court remains the enforcing court. Provinces B and C are where assets lie. No new suit is needed.
  2. Check both assets. The Province B land is mortgaged, so it must be assessed whether anything remains for an ordinary creditor. The money the Province C customer owes is a claim that can be attached if the relationship is evidenced. The seller should not ask the customer to pay it directly; payment can be redirected only through an attachment order. See Attaching money the debtor is owed under contracts.
  3. Set priorities. The money owed looks the quickest to disappear and has no mortgage, so enforcement against that claim goes first. The land waits until the mortgagee's rights are assessed.
  4. Send the matter outside the territory. The lawyer prepares a copy of the writ and the documents in section 4, and proceeds under Section 271 so that the court or officer in the relevant area takes the matter.
  5. Delegate by task. The seller gives the lawyer authority to file motions, follow up and receive notices, but not to receive money or settle without asking. A sales employee who knows the warehouse points it out once when the officer asks, so the seller does not travel for every step.
  6. Report. The lawyer reports on each significant event: what was filed, where, who is awaited and costs so far. If someone objects, the seller is told at once.

The result in a real case depends on the assets that exist on the day of enforcement, the rights of the mortgagee and other creditors, and any objections.

Common misunderstandings

What people assumeWhat is correct
The asset is in another province, so I must sue again in that province's courtAs a rule the court that decided the case remains the enforcing court; enforcement outside the territory is done by another court or officer on its behalf under Section 271
The creditor must travel every time, or never needs toIt depends on the task and the authority delegated. Paperwork can go to a lawyer; tasks needing the creditor's knowledge or decision still come from the creditor
The substitute court pays the creditor directlyProperty or money from seizure, attachment or sale goes back to the enforcing court to be dealt with
If I can see assets in several places, seize them all as fast as possibleSeizure must not exceed what suffices, and the creditor is liable for damage from excessive seizure. Set priorities first
I can contact the debtor's customers and tell them to pay mePayments can be redirected only through an attachment order of the officer or court
One writ lets me seize new assets foreverSection 274 has time limits and conditions; see section 5
A local lawyer means I need no reportsThe creditor is still owed regular reports on status, costs and limits

Further reading

An asset outside the territory does not mean starting again: the court that decided the case remains the enforcing court, and a court or officer in the area enforces on its behalf under Section 271, so what decides the result is complete documents, a clearly identified asset, sensible priorities, and authority and reporting agreed from the start.

We can review documents and evidence about assets in several areas, assess whether suing and enforcing is worthwhile, set priorities, file the claim, apply for enforcement and send it outside the territory, follow up with courts, enforcement officers and local helpers, prepare a power of attorney that fits the task, handle objections and payments, and negotiate instalments after attachment. We trace assets only through lawful channels, do not search bank accounts, do not obtain data unlawfully, and do not guarantee that assets will be found or that the creditor will be paid; results depend on the assets, the rights of other creditors and the facts of the case. Fees depend on the stage of the case and the work required. Send us your documents first, and we will set out the scope of work and fees in writing before starting. For an initial consultation call +66 92 254 2045 or send us the details. See Asset tracing and Civil litigation.


This guide is published by Suwanvara Law Firm — a Khon Kaen law firm established in 1986. General information only, not legal advice on a specific matter.

Frequently asked questions

If the debtor's assets are in another province, must the creditor travel there personally?+

Not every time. It depends on whether the task really needs the creditor and what authority has been delegated. Paperwork, filing motions, dealing with the officer and receiving notices can be done by a lawyer or attorney if the power of attorney covers them. Some tasks, such as confirming facts only the creditor knows, pointing out where an asset is, or deciding on a settlement or on withdrawing a seizure, still need the creditor's instruction or approval. The enforcement officer can also call on the creditor to assist under Section 278.

The judgment was given in one province and the asset is in another. Must I file a new case or application in that province?+

As a rule, no new case is needed. The court of first instance that heard and decided the case remains the enforcing court under Section 271 of the Civil Procedure Code. For enforcement outside its territory that court may appoint another court to enforce on its behalf, or the creditor may file a motion, or the enforcement officer may report to the substitute court with a copy of the writ or of the order fixing the method of enforcement. A lawyer should check which route suits each asset.

With assets in several provinces, where should I seize first?+

There is no fixed formula. Consider which assets are at risk of being moved or spent, which convert to cash most easily, whether others may have prior rights such as a mortgage or other creditors, how clear the proof of ownership is, and cost against likely value. Under Section 300 seizure or attachment must not exceed what is enough to satisfy the judgment and costs, so do not seize everywhere at once without assessing.

How will the firm report progress and limits to the creditor?+

Agree the reporting format before work starts, for example a written report on each significant event or at agreed intervals. It should say what was filed, with which court or office, the date, the status, what is pending, what is needed from the creditor, costs incurred so far, and the limits, such as assets not yet verified, prior rights of others, or possible objections. No promise should be made that money will be recovered by a given date.

If enforcement outside the territory is done wrongly, who corrects it?+

Under Section 271 the substitute court may revoke or correct steps that are defective, mistaken or unlawful, or direct the officer to correct them. Once enforcement is finished and the result has been reported to the enforcing court, only the enforcing court has that power. Review reports and orders while the work is under way instead of waiting until the end.

Lawyer-client handshake symbolizing trust at Suwanvara Law Firm

Ready to hear your story

Get an initial consultation with one of our experienced attorneys.