Skip to main content
SUWANVARA LAWFIRM
Suwanvara Law Firm Co., Ltd.
SUWANVARA LAWFIRM
SUWANVARA LAWFIRM
Suwanvara Law Firm Co., Ltd.
Civil Litigation Guide

Someone Claims the Seized Property Is Theirs: What a Creditor Does (Section 323 Claims and Title Checks Before Seizure)

A guide for judgment creditors whose seized asset is claimed by a spouse, relative, lessor, finance company or another company. It explains the Section 323 third-party claim and its 60-day period, the effect on the sale, checking title before seizure, the evidence a creditor can offer, and when to drop an item and move to other assets.

Suwanvara Law Firm— Civil Litigation & Enforcement TeamNovember 20, 202615 min read
Someone Claims the Seized Property Is Theirs: What a Creditor Does (Section 323 Claims and Title Checks Before Seizure)

The core answer

Not everything in a debtor's house, factory or warehouse belongs to the debtor. A seizure by the enforcement officer does not mean the court has decided the asset is the debtor's. A person who says the asset is theirs can ask the court that issued the enforcement writ to release it (a third-party claim) under Section 323 of the Civil Procedure Code, generally within 60 days of the seizure.

Once the court accepts the claim, the sale of that asset is normally held back while the court decides, and the court hears it like an ordinary case. The creditor must answer with evidence and should expect extra time and cost. The cheapest route is to check title and origin before asking for seizure. Where a claim is already in and the facts are thin, dropping that item and moving to other assets can be worth more than fighting.

Where are you, and what should you read first?

Your stageWhat to know firstRead sections
Not yet suedThere is no judgment seizure yet, and the claim in this guide arises during enforcement. This is still the best time to collect proof of which assets really belong to the debtor, because checking after winning is harder.1, 3
Sued (case pending)If you will ask the court for an interim measure before judgment, you need grounds and evidence about the debtor's assets, including that they are the debtor's.1, 3, 9
Judgment wonThis is the stage this guide fits best: the 60-day period, the effect on the sale, the evidence to answer with, and how to decide whether to fight or drop the item.2 to 9

1. Why check that the asset really belongs to the debtor?

Creditors often see valuable items at the debtor's premises and assume they are the debtor's. In practice, many items there are not owned by the debtor.

  • Cars or machines still being paid off to a finance or leasing company
  • Machines or equipment the debtor rents for the factory
  • Goods left by customers or suppliers, such as consignment stock, materials sent by a client, or a client's moulds
  • Property owned by a spouse, relative or director but used in the same home or business
  • Property the debtor already sold or transferred but not yet re-registered or delivered

Section 322 sets the principle that enforcement does not affect a third party's rights, such as real rights, preferential rights, retention rights or other rights over the property. Put plainly, property that is not the debtor's cannot simply be sold off to pay the debtor's debt.

The result is that asking for seizure without checking can mean wasted enforcement costs, a delaying claim, and exposure to liability toward the true owner, depending on the facts.

2. Who tends to claim, and on what grounds?

ClaimantCommon claimWhat the creditor should look at
SpouseSeparate property, or co-ownership of marital propertyDate acquired, name on the papers, pre-marital agreement, source of funds (the spouse's share is covered in section 8)
Relative or close associateThe item is theirs and the debtor only borrowed it, or it was transferred before suitTransfer date, price paid, proof of payment, relationship to the debtor
LessorThey own it and leased it to the debtorLease contract, labels or plates on the item, tax invoice
Finance or leasing companyThey still own it under hire-purchase or a leaseContract, instalments paid, registration
Related company or director's companyAnother legal entity owns it and shares the premisesAsset register, tax invoices, each company's financial statements
Buyer not yet registeredBought before the seizure but not yet transferredSale contract, payment date, delivery, whether they could register first
Co-ownerCo-owns land or property the debtor holds jointlyTitle deed, each person's share, separation of possession

Section 323 allows a claim where the claimant says the debtor is not the owner of the seized property, or that they are a co-owner of immovable property held in separate portions, or a co-owner of divisible movable property, or are in a position to register their right in the property first. The claimant may ask for release of all, part, or only their share.

3. How do you check title and origin before asking for seizure?

This is a starting framework. Use lawful channels only; what you find is a snapshot on the date checked.

Asset typeFirst checksCaution
Land, house, condominiumTitle document such as the title deed, and the registry entries available through lawful channels at the land office: holder, mortgages, co-holdersSeveral names may appear and a mortgage may exist (see the multiple-creditors guide on payment order)
Cars and trucksRegistration book and transport-office records available through lawful channels: owner, possessor, hire-purchase statusThe name on the book and the real user may differ
MachineryPurchase invoice or receipt, asset register in the accounts, lease or leasing contract, owner plates, where installedA machine installed in the factory may belong to the lessor or to another company sharing the site
StockGoods-received notes, delivery notes, consignment or OEM contracts showing who owns goods and materialsGoods held on deposit or for contract manufacture may belong to the customer
SharesShareholder register, share certificates, transfer restrictions in company documentsThe registered holder may be a nominee
Money and receivablesContracts and delivery documentsEnforcement against these runs on a different route, so check the specific rules first

Remember that a register shows who holds the name; it does not always show who truly owns the asset. There is no way to search a person's bank accounts or balances by name. The money trail behind a purchase can come only from documents the parties hold or from court procedures.

For checking assets before suing, see Is asset tracing before suing the debtor worth it?

4. A claim is filed after seizure: how does the procedure run?

Following Section 323, in outline:

  1. The enforcement officer seizes the asset the creditor points to.
  2. The claimant applies to the court that issued the enforcement writ, within the period in section 5.
  3. When the court accepts the claim, it sends copies to the creditor, the debtor and the enforcement officer.
  4. On receipt, the officer holds back sale or disposal of the asset pending the ruling, unless it is a Section 332 quick-sale asset.
  5. The court decides it like an ordinary case. Creditor, debtor and claimant may each present evidence.
  6. If the court releases the asset, it leaves this enforcement. If the claim is dismissed, the sale continues.

The holding back of the sale in the middle is why a claim adds time for the creditor, and why a debtor or a close associate sometimes uses a claim to buy time.

For perishable assets, or assets whose keeping costs would exceed their value, Section 332 allows a quick sale. Section 323 gives the claimant a different timetable for these, and the claim must be filed before the officer pays out the sale proceeds. The net proceeds are treated as the property claimed.

5. Time limits to know

EventPeriod under Section 323
Ordinary claim by an outsiderWithin 60 days of the seizure
Missed the period, with special circumstancesMay file later, but no later than 7 days before the first sale or disposal date set by the officer
Force majeureMay file later, but before the property is sold or disposed of
Quick-sale assets under Section 33260 days from seizure; later with special circumstances, but before the officer pays out the sale proceeds
Creditor seeking compensation after dismissalApply within 30 days of the order dismissing the claim

For a creditor the useful point is that the seizure date starts the 60 days. After that the sale tends to run more smoothly, but late filing is still open in the cases the law allows, so do not assume day 61 carries no risk.

Always count the days and check the period against the text of the section and the court papers in your own case.

6. Evidence each side puts forward

The claimant usually files

  • A sale contract or receipt, a tax invoice
  • A lease, hire-purchase or leasing contract
  • Registration, title deed or papers showing their own name
  • Proof of payment of the purchase price
  • Photographs or witness statements that the debtor merely used or held the asset for them

The creditor can answer with

  • Documents showing the debtor as buyer, payer, or user in the capacity of owner, such as financial statements and the asset register the debtor itself prepared
  • The date and nature of any transfer, such as a transfer after the debt arose, an unusually low price, or a transfer to a close associate
  • The debtor's own earlier statements that the asset is theirs, such as security offered, credit applications or quotations
  • Photographs taken at seizure and the officer's note of where the asset was found and who had possession
  • Papers from the creditor's own contract with the debtor that refer to the asset

Where the claimant took the asset from the debtor after the debt arose and the transfer looks designed to prejudice creditors, other civil-law remedies such as revocation of the transfer may exist. See the overview Debtor transferring assets. That is a separate matter, decided on its own facts.

After seizure, Section 315 also provides that a later creation, transfer or change of rights in the seized asset by the debtor cannot be set up against the creditor or the enforcement officer. So a debtor cannot take an asset out of enforcement by moving ownership after the seizure.

7. If the claim looks groundless and meant only to delay

Section 323 gives the creditor two tools.

  • Ask for a deposit or security. The creditor applies saying the claim is groundless and filed to delay enforcement. If there is prima facie evidence the claim is arguable, the court may order the claimant to deposit money or give security in an amount and time it thinks fit, to cover the creditor's possible damages. If the claimant does not comply, the claim is struck off. The order on this point is final under that section.
  • Ask for compensation. If the court dismisses the claim and the creditor considers it groundless and filed to delay, the creditor may apply within 30 days of the dismissal for the claimant to compensate the damage. The court may separate it into its own case file.

These are not automatic buttons. The court looks at the prima facie evidence and the reasons in each case. Disliking the other side's story is not enough; the facts must support that the claim has no basis and is aimed at delay.

8. Spouses and jointly held property

Separate versus marital property, setting aside the spouse's share, and guarantors are covered in Seizing a spouse's or guarantor's assets. Here it is enough to say that a spouse who is not the debtor often claims all or part of the asset, and the creditor should prepare evidence of where the asset came from before seizing.

For assets the debtor holds jointly with others, such as one parcel of land, a co-holder may apply under Section 323 or ask under Section 324 for their registered share to be set aside. The creditor can then sell only the debtor's share, which often means fewer buyers and a lower price.

9. Fight on, or drop the item and move to other assets

There is no fixed formula. Ask these questions.

QuestionIf yesIf no
Is the creditor's evidence stronger than the claimant's?Worth contestingWeigh dropping the item
Is the asset valuable enough against the time and cost of the claim?Worth contestingWeigh dropping the item
Are there other clearly-owned assets that can be seized faster?Consider seizing those in parallelThis asset may be the only route
Does the claimant hold credible documents, such as a tax invoice in their name from before the debt?Weigh dropping the itemWorth contesting
Is the claim being used to buy time to move other assets?Move quickly on other assets and use Section 323 to seek security

Dropping one item does not end the right to enforce, but the creditor should keep other assets ready and not leave the whole plan waiting on one asset. For the enforcement time limit see Enforcing a judgment within 10 years.

Before turning to another asset, check whether other creditors have already seized it or others hold rights in it. See Several creditors, one asset: who is paid first?

10. Frequent disputes: hire-purchase cars and leased machinery

Cars the debtor is still paying off to a finance company, and machines the debtor rents, justify their own guides.

Here, the point is only that the contract is the first document to ask for, and the owner named in it may not be the debtor.

Documents to gather before seeking seizure of an important asset

  • The judgment and the enforcement writ you will use
  • Proof the asset is the debtor's: title deed, registration book, tax invoice in the debtor's name, asset register in the financial statements
  • Contracts with the debtor that touch the asset, such as security, quotations, goods-received notes
  • Results of registry and encumbrance checks as of the check date, with the date noted
  • A list of people who may hold rights: registered holder, lessor, finance company, co-owners, spouse
  • Photographs and notes of where the asset is, owner plates, serial numbers
  • An estimate of value and cost against what is likely to remain after others' rights
  • The seizure date and the 60-day date, entered in the case calendar
  • A fallback plan: other assets already checked

Hypothetical example: three machines in a debtor's factory

This is a made-up case to explain the principles. It is not a real client or firm case, and it contains no money amounts.

Company A wins a judgment for the price of goods against Company B and leads the enforcement officer to seize three machines in B's factory.

  • Machine 1 has a tax invoice in B's name and is in the asset register in B's financial statements. Nobody claims it.
  • Machine 2 carries a lessor's plate and a lease contract exists. The lessor files a claim within 60 days with the contract and proof of the lease.
  • Machine 3 was bought after B became indebted. Company C, a company of B's director, says it owns it. The tax invoice is in C's name, but the purchase money came from B's account according to documents A could obtain from the earlier contract parties.

Company A decides

  1. Not to contest Machine 2, since the lessor's papers are clear and contesting would cost time. It drops that item.
  2. To contest Machine 3, because the facts on money and timing support it, and to apply for an order that Company C give security.
  3. Meanwhile to check and seize other unclaimed assets, rather than leaving everything waiting on Machine 3.

The result of contesting depends on the evidence and the court's discretion. This example does not say the creditor will win or lose.

Common misunderstandings

MisunderstandingReality
Everything in the debtor's house or factory belongs to the debtorNot necessarily. It may be leased, financed, owned by a spouse or another company, or left by a customer. Check documents first.
Seizure means the court has confirmed the debtor owns itSeizure is an enforcement step. It does not decide ownership, and a claimant can file under Section 323.
Anyone who objects stops the sale at onceThe claimant must file with the court in time and the court must accept it. The sale is held back when the officer receives the claim, on the conditions in Section 323.
After 60 days no one can claimThe law allows later filing for special circumstances or force majeure, on the conditions of Section 323.
If a claim is filed you must always fightSome items are better dropped in favour of other assets. Weigh evidence, value and time first.
Putting an asset in another name always protects the debtorIf the facts show the asset really is the debtor's, the creditor has ways to challenge it, but with evidence, and as a separate matter from the time limits in this guide.

Further reading

Before asking for any asset to be seized, check that it truly belongs to the debtor, because a third-party claim holds up the sale and costs you time; if a claim is already in, weigh the evidence against the time and decide whether to fight or move to other assets.

We help check the debtor's assets and documents through lawful channels, assess whether to sue or continue enforcement, file claims and enforcement applications, follow up with the enforcement officer, respond to third-party claims, deal with objections and payment of proceeds, and negotiate instalments after seizure. We do not guarantee that assets will be found or that a creditor will be paid, we do not search bank accounts, and we do not obtain information by unlawful means. Recovery depends on the assets, the rights of mortgagees and other creditors, and the facts of the case. Our charges depend on the stage of the case and the work required. Send us the documents first and we will confirm the scope of work and charges in writing before we start. For an initial consultation call +66 92 254 2045 or send us the details. See asset tracing and civil litigation.


This guide is published by Suwanvara Law Firm — a Khon Kaen law firm established in 1986. General information only, not legal advice on a specific matter.

Frequently asked questions

What is a third-party claim over seized property, and who can file one?+

It is a request by an outsider who says the property seized by the enforcement officer does not belong to the judgment debtor, for example because they own it, co-own divisible movable property or immovable property held in separate portions, or are in a position to register their right first. Section 323 of the Civil Procedure Code lets them apply to the court that issued the enforcement writ to release all of the property, part of it, or only their share.

How long does the claimant have, and can a late claim still be filed?+

Under Section 323 the claim must be filed within 60 days of the seizure. A later filing is possible only with special circumstances and no later than 7 days before the first sale or disposal date; force majeure allows a later filing but before the sale. Perishable or costly-to-keep assets sold quickly under Section 332 follow a different timetable, so read the section for the case in hand.

Does a claim stop the auction?+

As a rule, once the enforcement officer receives the copy of the claim the court has accepted, an asset that is not a Section 332 quick-sale asset is held back from sale while the court decides. The court hears it like an ordinary case, so it affects both time and cost for the creditor.

What can the creditor do if the claim looks groundless and meant only to delay?+

Section 323 lets the creditor apply to the court saying so. If there is prima facie evidence the claim is arguable, the court may order the claimant to deposit money or give security. If the claim is dismissed, the creditor may apply within 30 days of the dismissal for compensation for the damage caused. The outcome depends on the evidence and the court's discretion.

The debtor drives an expensive car registered to someone else. What should I check?+

Check who the registered owner is, when and how the car was bought (cash or hire-purchase), whether a hire-purchase contract exists, whether the debtor is only the user or the real owner using another name, the transfer papers, the source of the purchase money, and the registered owner's relationship to the debtor. A car that truly belongs to someone else is likely to draw a claim, so seizing without checking can waste time and cost. For hire-purchase cars, see the dedicated guide.

I have found the debtor's asset. Can I have it seized immediately?+

Do not rush. An enforcement writ is needed and the creditor leads the officer to the asset under the officer's procedure. Before that, check whether the asset truly belongs to the debtor, whether it is mortgaged, pledged, leased, on hire-purchase or co-owned, and whether what remains after others' rights is worth the cost. Not everything in the debtor's house or factory belongs to the debtor.

Lawyer-client handshake symbolizing trust at Suwanvara Law Firm

Ready to hear your story

Get an initial consultation with one of our experienced attorneys.