Skip to main content
SUWANVARA LAWFIRM
Suwanvara Law Firm Co., Ltd.
SUWANVARA LAWFIRM
SUWANVARA LAWFIRM
Suwanvara Law Firm Co., Ltd.
Civil Litigation Guide

The Debtor's Factory Machinery Is Leased: Can a Creditor Seize It? (Checking Title, Encumbrances and Costs Before Seizure)

A guide for business creditors whose corporate debtor has a factory and machinery, some of it belonging to a lessor or financier. It explains how to separate machines the debtor owns, leases, holds on hire-purchase or under other contracts, how to check machinery registration and business collateral, other people's property in the factory, dismantling, transport, storage and sale costs, book value versus actual sale price, and liability for wrongful seizure.

Suwanvara Law Firm— Civil Litigation & Enforcement TeamNovember 20, 202612 min read
The Debtor's Factory Machinery Is Leased: Can a Creditor Seize It? (Checking Title, Encumbrances and Costs Before Seizure)

The core answer

A factory full of machines does not mean every machine can be seized and sold by the creditor. Some may be leased, still being paid for, mortgaged or pledged as security to another creditor, or belong to a customer who sent them in for production. Seizing a machine that is not the debtor's usually draws a third-party claim, which can halt the sale and waste time. If the seizure is wrongful or goes beyond what is needed, the creditor may also be liable for the resulting damage under Section 285.

Before asking for seizure, sort the machines into groups, check the title documents and the relevant registers, and estimate what will be left for you after other people's rights and after the costs of dismantling, transport, storage and sale. The book value in financial statements is often higher than the price actually obtained.

This page is written for business-to-business debts. For third-party claims, see the dedicated guide; for who is paid first when several creditors compete, see the multiple-creditors guide.

Where are you, and what should you read first?

Your stageWhat to know firstRead sections
Not yet suedNothing can be seized yet, but it is a good time to gather evidence of what machinery the debtor has, whose it is and who ranks ahead, to decide whether suing is worthwhile. A court order for interim protection before judgment is a separate matter and needs grounds and evidence1, 2, 3, 7
Case pendingThere is no writ of execution yet. Use the time to check the assets, and if you fear the debtor will move machines out, discuss interim measures, which the court does not grant in every case1, 2, 3, 4, 7
Judgment wonThe stage this page fits best. Check machines group by group, decide which to seize, and prepare for third-party claims and sale costs1 to 8

1. What kinds of machine are in the factory, and what can a creditor do with each?

The debtor calling a machine "ours" says nothing about title. Separate them like this.

GroupNatureUsual effect for the creditor
Owned by the debtor, unencumberedBought and paid for, not mortgaged or pledgedCan be seized. Still weigh the costs and the likely sale price
Owned but encumberedMachinery mortgage or business collateralCan be seized, but the mortgagee or collateral holder may be paid first, leaving less or nothing for ordinary creditors
LeasedLease contract; the lessor remains ownerThe machine is not the debtor's and a third-party claim is likely. The debtor's lease rights depend on the contract
Hire-purchase or financedThe finance company stays owner until the contract is fully paidSimilar to leased machines. Check the contract machine by machine
Held for othersCustomers' moulds or machines, machines sent for repairOther people's property and should not be seized
Fixed to the buildingInstalled and attached to the factory or landMay be a component or accessory of the building. Check case by case; it may also touch a land mortgage

The best way to sort them is from documents, not by looking around the factory.

2. What evidence shows title and encumbrances?

No single source answers everything. Combine several.

  • Tax invoices and purchase documents: buyer's name, date and serial number (if obtainable from earlier dealings or documents the debtor gave you when contracting).
  • Lease, hire-purchase or other contracts the debtor entered into, which a creditor may see through court processes such as an examination of the debtor that the court may order under Section 277 after judgment.
  • The debtor's financial statements published by the DBD, which show whether machinery appears as an asset but not which machine is leased or mortgaged, and which are backward-looking.
  • Registers relating to machinery and security (section 3).
  • The physical site, such as lessor plates, serial numbers and installation, which are only clues to be followed up against documents.
  • Information from the debtor itself in negotiations, pleadings or case documents.

Registry and statement information is a snapshot on the date checked, and searches are by name or number. Nobody can search a debtor's bank accounts or balances, and we do not recommend obtaining information by unlawful means.

3. Machinery registration, machinery mortgage and business collateral

Machinery is not like land with a single title deed. Two regimes matter.

  • The Machinery Registration Act B.E. 2514 sets up registration for certain machinery and allows registered machinery to be mortgaged. If a machine is mortgaged, the mortgagee may have a right to be paid from it ahead of ordinary creditors under the Civil and Commercial Code rules on mortgage.
  • The Business Collateral Act B.E. 2558 lets business operators give various assets that need not be handed over, including machinery, as security by contract and registration as the law requires. A properly registered secured party may rank ahead of ordinary creditors.

We do not give section numbers for these two Acts on this page. Details such as which machines must be registered, who may search and what the result means should be checked against the current text and the registry authority before you rely on them.

Cautions

  • A machine absent from a register is not necessarily unencumbered: it may be leased, on hire-purchase or someone else's without any registration.
  • Where a machine is mortgaged, the mortgagee may claim first from the sale proceeds; compare the principle for mortgaged land.
  • An owner-lessor or financier does not wait to share in proceeds but files a third-party claim under Section 323 (Section 322 also provides that certain third-party rights are not affected by enforcement).
  • This check can and should be done before applying for seizure.

4. Other people's property in the debtor's factory: what to do

A contract-manufacturing plant often holds items that are not the debtor's.

  • Moulds, spare parts, raw materials and goods sent in by customers for production.
  • Machines a supplier or manufacturer has placed for trial.
  • Machines owned by a shareholder or affiliate but used by the debtor.
  • Consignment stock, or goods bought but unpaid with a retention-of-title clause in the contract.

The enforcement officer may enter premises the debtor occupies under Section 282, but entry does not decide who owns each item. When you point to a machine for seizure, have reasons and documents. For what happens when someone claims the item after seizure, see the third-party claims guide; it is not repeated here.

A creditor should never enter the factory and remove items personally. Seizure is done only through the enforcement officer under a writ.

5. If you seize wrongly or too much, what is the creditor's liability?

Section 285 provides tort liability for damage arising from seizure, attachment or sale that is wrongful or goes beyond what enforcement needs, and Section 300 bars seizing or attaching more than enough to pay the debt and costs. Think about this when choosing which machines to seize.

  • Seizing a machine plainly owned by someone else, causing loss to the factory or lessor.
  • Seizing the core of a production line so that the factory stops, when the debt is far smaller than the machine's value.
  • Seizing several machines which together exceed what is needed.

Actual liability depends on the facts and the court's discretion and does not follow every third-party claim, but the more you check before seizure the lower the risk.

6. Costs of dismantling, transport, storage and sale

Turning machinery into money costs more than turning cash or land into money. We give no figures here because each job differs.

  • Dismantling and disconnecting. Machines fixed to floors or wiring need technicians and equipment, and care not to damage the machine or other property.
  • Transport. Large machines need trucks and cranes, and some work may need permits.
  • Storage. The enforcement officer must keep seized property safely (Section 279). Leaving it in the factory needs a custodian; moving it needs premises. Idle machines can deteriorate.
  • Sale. Auction cannot take place earlier than 60 days after seizure (Section 331), and the creditor must deposit the enforcement expenses as required. Buyers may bear removal costs themselves and so bid lower.
  • Time. It depends on the assets, the number of creditors and any objections. No standard duration can be given.

Sometimes machines stay in the factory and are sold with the premises, or instalments are negotiated after seizure; the creditor must weigh that against the risk of the debtor moving or damaging the machines. See the guide on instalments after seizure.

7. Book value versus what the machinery actually sells for

Financial statements published through the DBD show machinery at cost less depreciation, which differs from market price in several ways.

Why the sale price may be below book valueShort explanation
A forced auctionBuyers know the owner must sell and bid low
Actual conditionMay be old, often repaired or long idle
Special purposeA machine built for that factory's work is hard to sell
The buyer's costsRemoval, transport, reinstallation, testing
EncumbrancesProceeds must be shared with the mortgagee or prior holders in order
Machines worth more working as a lineSold separately the total may be lower

For the financial statements and why money is hard to trace, see the corporate-debtor financial statements guide. The point here is only that you should get a price view from someone who knows that kind of machine before seizing, and not use the statement figure directly.

For claims against customers and other company assets that may be easier to check and attach than machines, see the guide on corporate debtors with no land and no car.

8. Before suing, while the case is pending, and after judgment

  • Before suing. Check what lawful channels allow, and judge whether, after others' rights and costs, what is left is worth it. See is asset tracing before suing worth it. Before judgment and a writ, a creditor cannot seize machines personally.
  • While pending. There is no writ yet. A request for interim protection, such as an order restraining transfer or seizure before judgment under Sections 254 and 255, needs grounds and evidence that the debtor will move or dispose of assets. The court does not grant it in every case, and it is the court's order, not seizure by the creditor.
  • After judgment. The creditor applies for a writ and takes the officer to seize the machines checked. Section 274 has a ten-year rule, details for debts payable in the future or by instalments, and continuation against property or claims already acted on within the period, so it should not be shortened to "one writ and I can chase new assets forever".

Documents to prepare

  • Contracts, purchase orders, invoices and other documents proving the debt
  • The judgment, the order to comply and the writ of execution (if you have them)
  • The debtor's latest DBD financial statements, with the date checked
  • The machinery list in the statements (if any), and photographs or notes from a properly made site visit
  • Tax invoices, purchase documents, or lease and hire-purchase contracts the creditor already holds
  • Results of machinery-registration and business-collateral checks, with the date checked
  • Information on other known creditors (mortgagees, finance companies, financial institutions)
  • An informal view or rough valuation from someone who knows that type of machine
  • An estimate of dismantling, transport, storage and sale costs

Hypothetical example: a plastics factory with five injection machines

This example is invented to illustrate the principles. It is not a real client or firm case and contains no sums of money.

Company A wins a judgment for goods supplied against Company B, which makes plastic parts. B's DBD financial statements show machinery as a large asset. A checks documents and finds:

  • 2 injection machines bought by B itself, with no mortgage found in the register
  • 1 injection machine under a hire-purchase contract with a finance company, not yet fully paid
  • 1 injection machine mortgaged to a bank
  • 10 sets of moulds owned by B's customers

A concludes that the hire-purchase machine and the moulds should not be seized. The mortgaged machine can be seized, but the bank may be paid first. So A starts with the 2 unencumbered machines and asks someone who knows the second-hand injection-machine market what they would really sell for. Weighing that against dismantling, transport and sale costs, A decides to seize those 2 machines, and in parallel checks B's claims against its customers so as not to rely on machinery alone.

The real outcome depends on the sale price, other creditors and any objections. The example does not mean the creditor will be paid.

Common misunderstandings

MisunderstandingCorrection
A machine in the debtor's factory belongs to the debtorIt may be leased, on hire-purchase, mortgaged or someone else's. Check the documents
The price in the financial statements is what it will sell forIt is an accounting value. The real price differs and depends on the market and costs
Not on the machinery register means no encumbranceA machine may be leased or on hire-purchase without registration, and a register is a snapshot on the date checked
Seize first, and whoever has rights will objectA wrongful seizure can waste time and money and may bring liability under Section 285
A creditor can take machines out of the factory when the debtor does not paySeizure must go through the enforcement officer under a writ. Taking items yourself may be a wrong by the creditor
One writ lets me chase new assets foreverSection 274 has a ten-year rule, details for instalment debts, and continuation against property already acted on within the period, so it should not be understood that way

Further reading

Before asking for machinery to be seized, separate what the debtor truly owns from what is leased, financed or someone else's, and compare the realistic sale price after others' rights with the cost of dismantling, transport and sale, because the figure in the financial statements is not the money you will receive.

We help check the debtor's assets and documents through lawful channels, assess whether to sue or continue enforcement, file claims and enforcement applications, follow up with the enforcement officer, respond to third-party claims, deal with objections and payment of proceeds, and negotiate instalments after seizure. We do not guarantee that assets will be found or that a creditor will be paid, we do not search bank accounts, and we do not obtain information by unlawful means. Recovery depends on the assets, the rights of mortgagees and other creditors, and the facts of the case. Our charges depend on the stage of the case and the work required. Send us the documents first and we will confirm the scope of work and charges in writing before we start. For an initial consultation call +66 92 254 2045 or send us the details. See asset tracing and civil litigation.


This guide is published by Suwanvara Law Firm — a Khon Kaen law firm established in 1986. General information only, not legal advice on a specific matter.

Frequently asked questions

I found machinery in the debtor's factory. Can I have it seized straight away?+

Not safely. A writ of execution is needed first, and the creditor takes the enforcement officer to seize under the procedure. Before that, check whether the machine really belongs to the debtor, whether it is leased, on hire-purchase, mortgaged or held as security by another creditor, and whether what is left after other people's rights still justifies the cost of dismantling, transport, storage and sale.

Can a creditor seize machinery the debtor leases?+

The machine itself belongs to the lessor, not the debtor. If it is seized, a third-party claim under Section 323 usually follows, and it can be filed within 60 days of the seizure. The debtor's own rights under the lease may in some cases be reachable, but that depends on the contract terms, such as a ban on assignment, and on rent in arrears, so read the contract first.

Where can I check whether machinery is encumbered?+

Several sources are needed: purchase documents and tax invoices, any lease or hire-purchase contract, serial numbers and plates on the machine, machinery registration and machinery mortgage under the Machinery Registration Act B.E. 2514, and business-collateral registration under the Business Collateral Act B.E. 2558. A registry search is a snapshot on the date of the search, and not every machine is registered.

How far can the machinery value in the financial statements be trusted?+

It is an accounting figure after depreciation, not the price a buyer will pay at auction. The real price depends on condition, age, market demand, the buyer's removal costs, and whether the machine is a purpose-built part of that factory's line. Treat the figure in the statements only as a starting point.

If I seize someone else's machinery by mistake, am I liable?+

Section 285 provides tort liability for damage arising from seizure, attachment or sale that is wrongful or goes beyond what enforcement needs. The outcome depends on the facts, such as whether the creditor knew or should have known the machine belonged to someone else, how the damage arose, and any court order. Checking title before seizure reduces this risk.

Should I go after the machinery or look for other assets first?+

It depends on how much is genuinely the debtor's, whether others rank ahead, what the machines would sell for, and whether easier assets exist, such as claims against the debtor's customers. In many cases the options should be compared before deciding. See the guide on corporate debtors with no land and no car.

Lawyer-client handshake symbolizing trust at Suwanvara Law Firm

Ready to hear your story

Get an initial consultation with one of our experienced attorneys.