Skip to main content
SUWANVARA LAWFIRM
Suwanvara Law Firm Co., Ltd.
SUWANVARA LAWFIRM
SUWANVARA LAWFIRM
Suwanvara Law Firm Co., Ltd.
Business Law

Paying Extra for a Business Based on Results: How to Draft an Earn-Out Clause in Thailand Without Disputes Later

How to draft an earn-out in a Thai business sale agreement: defining revenue, profit or customer retention, the accounting rules for measuring it, control of the business after closing, buyer conduct that could depress results, access to the books, who decides disputes, and payment timing with security.

Suwanvara Law Firm— Business Law TeamNovember 21, 202615 min read
Paying Extra for a Business Based on Results: How to Draft an Earn-Out Clause in Thailand Without Disputes Later

The core answer

An earn-out splits the purchase price in two. The first part is paid at closing and the second later, depending on how the business performs. Almost all disputes do not come from the idea itself but from a contract that says "based on profit" without saying what profit means, who calculates it, under which accounting rules, and who runs the business while it is being measured.

A good earn-out clause answers six questions: what the metric is and how it is calculated; which accounting basis applies and which adjustments are allowed; what the buyer may and may not do with the business; when and how the seller can inspect the books; who decides if the numbers are disputed; and when payment is due and what secures it.

Legal principle (Civil and Commercial Code) Section 368 provides that a contract is to be interpreted in accordance with the intention in good faith, having regard to customary practice. This helps when wording is unclear, but a court or arbitrator starts from what is written. If the contract is silent on an important point, the result is hard to predict.

Our practical view Do not agree on the target figure until the calculation formula and a worked numerical example can be attached to the contract. If both sides run the same example and reach different results, the contract is not ready.

Who should read which part

Your stageWhich sections
Planning (price not yet discussed)Sections 1 and 2, to decide whether an earn-out suits the deal and which metric to use
Negotiating (a draft exists)Sections 3 to 9, as a clause-by-clause review list
Already done (closed and in the measurement period)Sections 5 to 7 on buyer conduct, inspection rights and the dispute mechanism

1. What kind of deal suits an earn-out?

An earn-out suits a deal where the seller believes the business will grow or keep its revenue, but the buyer has not seen enough evidence. Typical cases are a business that depends on its owner or a few large customers, a business that has only just started to grow, or one whose latest year was unusual. Deferring part of the price lowers the buyer's risk, and the seller can earn more if the figures turn out as described.

The drawback is that the parties stay tied together after closing. Their interests conflict by nature: the buyer gains when the earn-out is small, yet the buyer controls the business and its books. If the parties do not trust each other at all, alternatives are a lower fixed price or instalments that are not tied to performance.

Whether to buy shares or assets, and how the buyer's risks differ, is a separate question; see share purchase vs asset purchase. This guide starts after the structure has been chosen and deals only with the part of the price that waits for results.

2. Should the target be revenue, profit or customer retention?

MetricStrengthWeakness to draft around
RevenueEasy to measure, harder to manipulate than profit, visible to the seller earlyBuyer cuts prices or takes low-margin work to push sales up, or moves sales to another group company
Profit (for example operating profit)Reflects the quality of revenueBuyer can book group overheads, consultant fees or amortisation, so it needs a detailed definition
Customer retention (key customers kept, contracts renewed)Suits relationship-driven businesses, easy to verifyMust name the customers or the test for who counts; does a customer the buyer drops count?
CombinationProtects against distortion of any single metricComplex formula, needs a worked calculation attached

Whichever metric is chosen, state clearly:

  • The measurement period (for example two financial years from closing) and the cut-off date
  • What "the business" means: only the acquired company, or also lines the buyer adds later
  • Whether revenue or profit from combining the business with the buyer's own operations counts for the seller
  • A minimum threshold below which nothing is paid, and a cap on the total earn-out
  • All-or-nothing payment or proportional payment (getting close to target and receiving nothing often leads to disputes)
  • The test for revenue the buyer has discretion to recognise, such as work not yet delivered

3. What accounting rules apply to the measurement?

The core point is to choose one set of accounting rules and write it into the contract, rather than leaving "generally accepted accounting principles" without saying which standards apply as of which year, or what happens if the buyer changes its accounting policies.

IssueWhat to write
Standards and policiesUse the same policies as the business's financial statements before closing. If the buyer changes policy, calculate both ways and use the one closest to the former policy
Revenue recognitionState whether revenue is recognised on delivery, on invoicing or on receipt of payment, and how work that spans periods is handled
Unusual itemsSay whether one-off items (asset sales, compensation received) are excluded
Buyer's group overheadsList deductible items, the allocation method and a cap; unrelated costs cannot be deducted
Intra-group transactionsMust be at arm's length prices and disclosed to the seller
Who prepares the figuresThe buyer prepares the earn-out calculation and sends it to the seller within a set number of days after the accounts close, with supporting documents
Audited or management accountsState which are used and which prevails if the two differ

Tax treatment of the arrangement should be checked by each side's accountant or auditor. We do not give tax figures.

4. Who controls the business during the earn-out period?

A buyer normally wants full control after closing, while a seller whose payment depends on results wants some power to protect the figures. The parties must find a middle ground. Three common models:

  1. Buyer in full control, with specific prohibitions. The buyer manages at its business discretion but must not do certain things that directly affect the earn-out (see Section 5). This is the easiest to operate.
  2. Seller keeps a role. The seller stays on as director or manager with decision power over listed matters such as budget, hiring or dismissing key staff, and pricing. The risk is daily management conflict, so the contract must say whether the seller must keep working and what happens when the seller leaves.
  3. A committee or consent process for major matters. The buyer needs the seller's consent for listed decisions. This protects the seller but slows decisions.

Points to settle before choosing a model:

  • Whether the seller continues to work in the business, in what position, and under what employment or consulting agreement
  • Which matters need the seller's prior consent and which only need notice afterwards
  • Whether the seller keeps the remaining earn-out if dismissed or if the seller resigns during the measurement period, and which dismissals count as being for good cause
  • How long and how widely the seller is bound not to compete (for the underlying idea of reasonable limits see non-compete clauses after resignation; that guide is about employment, but the reasonableness principle is comparable)

5. What can the buyer do, and not do, when the price depends on results?

The central problem of an earn-out is that the buyer controls what determines the seller's figures. The contract should therefore contain specific prohibitions or undertakings instead of relying on a general line that "the buyer must act in good faith". Even so, the good faith principle in section 368 remains something the seller can invoke in an interpretation dispute.

Buyer conductTypical clause
Moving customers or orders to another company of the buyerProhibited, or the moved sales are counted back into the business
Cutting prices or taking low-margin work to change the figuresBuyer must run the business consistently with past practice, or a minimum price level must be kept
Adding group overheads or consultant feesLimit the deductible items and amount, as in Section 3
Cutting marketing budget or key sales staff, or stopping a product lineNot without the seller's consent, or a minimum investment level is fixed
Selling, transferring or merging the business during the periodThe transferee must be bound by the earn-out, or the earn-out falls due immediately
Changing financial year or accounting policyNeeds consent, or calculate on the old policy
Terminating or not renewing an important customer contract without business reasonCount that customer as if retained

The buyer's side has a point too: a contract that ties the buyer's hands too far makes real management impossible. Buyers usually ask for clear exceptions, for example where action is required by law, safety or licence conditions.

If the buyer breaches these undertakings, the consequence should be written in advance, for example recalculating the earn-out with the figures adjusted back, or making the whole capped amount payable. Relying on a later damages claim is hard because it is difficult to prove how much was lost.

6. How can the seller inspect the books?

Where the buyer holds the accounts, the seller needs a right to inspect, otherwise there is no way to know whether the figures are right. The contract should set out:

  • When the buyer must deliver the earn-out report after each period and what supporting documents come with it
  • How many days the seller has to object, and that objections must be in writing with reasons
  • The right for an accountant or inspector appointed by the seller to see the books, supporting records, key customer contracts and necessary data during business hours
  • Confidentiality obligations of the inspector; if the seller has a competing business, access may be limited to an independent accountant rather than the seller
  • Who pays the cost: usually the seller first, with the buyer bearing it if the inspection finds an error above an agreed level
  • That the buyer must keep records throughout the measurement period and any continuing dispute

Financial statements filed by a juristic person with the Department of Business Development can be checked through the department's channels at dbd.go.th, but they are not detailed enough to replace an inspection right written into the contract.

7. If the numbers do not match, who decides?

First split disputes into two types, then choose a mechanism for each.

TypeExampleMechanism often used
Numbers or accounting disputesHow much overhead to allocate, which period revenue belongs to, what the final figure isIndependent expert, such as an accounting firm that has never worked for either side
Contract and conduct disputesWhether the buyer breached a prohibition in Section 5, how a definition is interpretedArbitration or the courts

An independent expert suits accounting questions because it is faster and cheaper than litigation, but the contract must be clear about:

  • How the expert is chosen, and who appoints if the parties cannot agree
  • That the expert decides only the points referred and how far the expert may interpret the contract
  • A time limit, for example a decision within a set number of days of referral
  • Whether the decision binds both sides and can be challenged only for manifest error or fraud
  • How the expert's costs are shared
  • Whether the expert acts as an expert or as an arbitrator, because enforcement of the decision differs

If arbitration is chosen, name the institution, seat, language and number of arbitrators in the contract. The Arbitration Act B.E. 2545 (2002) is the main law on the subject, and international aspects are discussed in foreign governing law and arbitration clauses before signing. If no mechanism is written in, disputes go to the ordinary courts, which takes longer and exposes business information.

8. When is payment due, and what secures it?

The deferred part of the price is money the buyer still owes, so the seller must look at both timing and ability to pay.

IssueWhat to set
Payment dateWithin a set number of days after the final figures are agreed or the expert decides, not tied to "when the buyer is ready"
InstalmentsAnnual instalments or one payment at the end; whether advance payments are made
Undisputed partPay the part the buyer accepts first and argue about the difference
Interest on late paymentState the rate or method in the contract and check with a lawyer that it is within what the law accepts
Set-offWhether the buyer may deduct from the earn-out to cover warranty claims under the agreement, and on what conditions
SecurityFunds held by a third party, bank guarantee, guarantee from the buyer's parent or shareholders, or a pledge over the transferred shares
Events that accelerate paymentBuyer sells the business on, becomes insolvent, stops operating, or commits a serious breach

The right security depends on the buyer's standing. If the buyer is a newly formed company with no other assets, security matters far more than where the buyer is a stable group.

9. Checklist before signing a contract with an earn-out

  • Metric, formula, period and scope of the business are written into the contract, with a worked example attached
  • Accounting policies to be used and what happens if the buyer changes them
  • Deductible and non-deductible costs, with a cap
  • The buyer's prohibitions and undertakings during the period, and the consequence of breach
  • The seller's role after closing and the effect of the seller leaving
  • Inspection rights and the deadline for objections
  • An independent expert for number disputes, and arbitration or courts for other disputes
  • Payment date, late-payment interest and security
  • Events that make the earn-out fall due immediately, such as a resale or closure by the buyer
  • Tax treatment of deferred, performance-based payments checked by an accountant or auditor before signing
  • Company status and business information checked; see Thai legal due diligence in cross-border deals

Hypothetical example: the buyer loads group overheads and the earn-out nearly halves

This example is invented to illustrate the points. It is not a real case, and all figures are illustrative.

Mr. Mana sells his office-equipment distribution company. The total price is 26,000,000 baht: 20,000,000 baht at closing and an earn-out of up to 6,000,000 baht tied to operating profit in the first year after closing. The contract says:

  • Operating profit below 4,000,000 baht: no earn-out
  • Operating profit of 5,000,000 baht or more: the full 6,000,000 baht
  • Between 4,000,000 and 5,000,000 baht: paid proportionally

At year end the buyer reports operating profit of 4,200,000 baht and pays an earn-out of 1,200,000 baht (20% of the cap). Mr. Mana exercises his inspection right and finds that the buyer booked 700,000 baht of "group management fees" into the business's accounts.

The contract says group overheads are deductible only if genuinely related to the business and capped at 200,000 baht a year. The independent expert decides that 200,000 baht is deductible, so profit is adjusted upward by 500,000 baht to 4,700,000 baht. The correct earn-out is therefore 70% of the cap, which is 4,200,000 baht. The buyer owes a further 3,000,000 baht, plus late-payment interest as the contract provides.

If the contract had not listed deductible overheads and a cap, and had given no inspection right, Mr. Mana would have had to prove on his own that the group management fee was unreasonable, which is much harder.

Common misunderstandings

MisunderstandingCorrection
"An earn-out guarantees the seller the full amount"No. The amount depends on actual results and the contract's calculation method. The seller may receive less than the cap or nothing
"Writing that the buyer must manage in good faith is enough"Good faith helps with interpretation but is hard to prove and the result is unpredictable. Write specific prohibitions and the consequence of breach
"Profit is the fairest target"Profit invites the most argument over costs. Without a detailed definition it can be the metric that causes the most disputes
"Once the expert decides, there are no more disputes"It depends on what the contract sends to the expert and how binding the decision is. Disputes over interpreting the contract can still go to arbitration or the courts
"No security is needed because the buyer is a large company"A buyer that acquires through a newly formed company has no other assets, so security or a parent guarantee should be considered
"Agree the target figure now and write the details later"A target figure means nothing until it is clear how it is counted. Write the formula and the example at the same time

Further reading

A good earn-out is not about whether the target is high or low; it is a contract that answers what is counted, how, who controls, who inspects and who decides, before anyone starts to argue.

We draft and review earn-out terms in business sale agreements: metric definitions, buyer prohibitions and undertakings, inspection rights, dispute mechanisms, and payment terms with security. We are not accountants or tax advisers, we do not value businesses, and we cannot promise the result of a negotiation or the amount you will receive. Fees depend on the stage of the matter and the work required. Send us the documents first and we will give you the scope of work and fees in writing before we start. Call +66 92 254 2045 or send us the details. See also business sale and contracts and documents.


This guide is published by Suwanvara Law Firm — a Khon Kaen law firm established in 1986. General information only, not legal advice on a specific matter.

Frequently asked questions

What is an earn-out?+

An earn-out is an arrangement under which part of the purchase price is paid later, and how much is paid depends on how the business performs over an agreed period, for example on revenue, profit or the number of customers retained. The seller receives the first part at closing and the rest depends on actual results. It is used when buyer and seller disagree about the future value of the business.

Should the target be based on revenue or profit?+

Revenue is easier to measure and harder for the buyer to manipulate, but a buyer can cut prices or take low-margin work to push sales up. Profit reflects the quality of revenue but invites argument over costs the buyer loads onto the business. Many deals use both, or a single metric defined in great detail. Whatever is chosen, attach the formula and a worked calculation to the contract.

What can the seller do if the buyer charges group overheads to the business?+

If the contract lists which overheads count and how they are allocated, that list applies. If it does not, the seller must rely on the principle that contracts are interpreted in good faith and prove that the cost has nothing to do with the business. It is better to set out deductible and non-deductible items in advance, together with a right to inspect the books and supporting documents.

Who should decide a dispute over earn-out figures?+

Disputes about numbers or accounting are often sent to an independent expert, such as an accounting firm both sides accept, who decides within a short time. Disputes about interpreting the contract or about a buyer's breach usually go to arbitration or the courts. The contract should separate the two and say whether the expert acts as an expert or as an arbitrator, because the legal consequences differ.

Should the seller ask for security for the earn-out payment?+

It should be considered, because the money falls due in the future. Options include holding part of the price with a third party, a bank guarantee, a guarantee from the buyer's parent or owners, or a pledge over the transferred shares. The right choice depends on the buyer's financial standing and the deal structure, so take legal advice before agreeing.

Lawyer-client handshake symbolizing trust at Suwanvara Law Firm

Ready to hear your story

Get an initial consultation with one of our experienced attorneys.