The core answer
A retention-of-title clause in a credit sale says that the seller delivers the goods and the buyer may hold and use them, but ownership stays with the seller until the buyer has paid what was agreed. Under the general rule, ownership of the thing sold passes to the buyer from the moment the sale contract is made (section 458). If the contract contains a condition or a time limit, ownership does not pass until the condition is met or the time arrives (section 459). A retention clause is therefore usually analysed as a condition or time term on the transfer of ownership. The outcome depends on the wording of the contract and how the parties behaved.
The clause is not a shield that works in every case. It weakens sharply when the buyer resells to a good-faith purchaser, when the goods are mixed, processed or installed so they can no longer be separated, when the seller cannot identify which goods are theirs, and when the buyer becomes insolvent or enters rehabilitation. Even where the seller is still the owner, getting the goods back needs the buyer's cooperation or a court and enforcement route. The seller should not walk in and remove the goods just because the contract says ownership is retained.
Our practical view: treat the clause as one layer of protection, alongside a credit limit, a deposit or first instalment, other security and quick follow-up on late payment. This guide covers credit sales of identifiable goods such as machinery and of consumable goods such as raw materials, which have different limits. Information as at 21 November 2026.
This guide is only about retention of title. For credit limits and collection policy, see customer credit terms and credit limit policy. If the buyer is withholding payment because machinery does not meet specification, see machinery not meeting specification.
Who should read which section
| Your situation | Sections to read |
|---|---|
| Not signed yet | Sections 1 to 3 on the transfer point and identifying the goods, section 4 on hire-purchase, and the checklist at the end |
| Signed and in use | Section 3 on stock records and marking, and sections 5 and 6 on resale and processing |
| Already in dispute | Section 7 on buyer financial trouble and section 8 on recovering goods without infringing anyone's rights |
1. What does a retention-of-title clause do in law?
Start with the default. Section 458 says ownership of the thing sold passes to the buyer from the time the sale contract is made. If the contract is silent, ownership may pass on agreement even though the buyer has not paid, leaving the seller with a claim for the price.
Section 459 lets the parties change that. If the sale contract is subject to a condition or a time, ownership does not pass until the condition is fulfilled or the time arrives. A retention clause is typically written so that ownership passes when the buyer pays in full.
| Aspect | Without a clause | With a clear, enforceable clause |
|---|---|---|
| Ownership | Passes on making the contract (section 458) | Does not pass until the condition is met, such as full payment (section 459) |
| Seller if the buyer does not pay | Ordinary claim for the price | May assert ownership of goods still held, but must prove it |
| Buyer | Owner, free to resell or mortgage | Holds and uses the goods as agreed, but should not deal with them as full owner |
Whether particular wording counts as a condition or time term under section 459 depends on the words and the parties' intention. A clause that says the seller "remains the owner" while also saying the buyer may use the goods as owner may need to be interpreted in layers, so clear wording matters.
2. How should the clause be written?
A clause that works in practice answers these points in a contract or purchase order that the buyer has signed.
| Point | What to state |
|---|---|
| Transfer point | Ownership passes on payment in full of that invoice, or on payment of everything owed to the seller. These are different choices, so say which one |
| Goods covered | Model, serial number, batch number, quantity and the delivery notes concerned |
| Possession while unpaid | Buyer holds as custodian, keeps the goods safe, insures them as agreed, does not mortgage or pledge them, and tells the seller if anyone claims them |
| Resale | No resale before payment, or only resale in the ordinary course of business with conditions on the money received, drafted with care |
| Processing, mixing, installation | Whether the buyer must give notice first, and what happens to ownership |
| Inspection | Seller may inspect stock and records at agreed times |
| On default | Buyer must return the goods within a set time and allow the seller to collect them by an agreed method |
Two points deserve emphasis. First, the clause must be in a document the buyer has accepted before or at delivery. Text printed on the back of a delivery note the buyer never signed is hard to prove as agreed. Second, the payment and ownership terms must match the other documents, such as the quotation, purchase order and invoice. If they conflict, what was actually agreed often has to be decided in a dispute.
3. How do you identify the goods, mark them and keep stock records?
Section 460 says that where goods sold are not yet ascertained, ownership does not pass until they have been marked, counted, weighed, measured, selected or otherwise identified. Where specific goods are sold and the seller still has to count, weigh, measure or do something else to fix the price, ownership does not pass until that has been done.
Two consequences follow. A bulk sale of raw materials that has not been separated into the buyer's share may leave ownership with the seller because of section 460, not because of the clause. And when the seller needs to prove that goods in the buyer's factory are the goods it sold, it must be able to identify them.
Practical steps:
- Machinery and high-value goods: record the model, serial number and manufacturer, and fix a plate or sticker saying the goods are not yet paid for, if the buyer agrees.
- Raw materials and batch goods: record the batch number, delivery date and weight or quantity on a delivery note the buyer signs.
- Ask the buyer to keep each batch apart from stock bought from other suppliers, or at least tagged so it can be checked.
- Ask the buyer to prepare and send stock reports on a schedule, for example monthly.
- Keep dated photographs of the goods at delivery and at each stock check.
Consumable goods bought from several suppliers are where the clause tends to work least well, because after a few months nobody can say whose raw material is left.
4. How is retention of title different from hire-purchase?
Many people call a credit sale in which the seller keeps title "hire-purchase". It should not be described that way, because it is a different contract.
Section 572 provides that hire-purchase is a contract under which an owner lets property on hire and promises to sell it, or to let it become the hirer's property, on condition that the hirer pays a set sum in set instalments. A hire-purchase contract that is not in writing is void.
| Point | Credit sale with retention of title | Hire-purchase (section 572) |
|---|---|---|
| Type of contract | Sale (buyer owes the price) | Letting on hire with a promise to sell or let property pass |
| Writing | Should be in writing to prove the clause | Must be in writing, otherwise void |
| Position of the person in possession | Buyer waiting for ownership to pass | Hirer who is not yet the owner |
| Vocabulary in the document | Price, instalments, transfer conditions | Rent, promise, hire-purchase payments |
This matters in practice. If a document is called a sale but reads like a letting with a promise to transfer, it may be interpreted according to what it actually says. A seller who wants hire-purchase should paper it as a written hire-purchase contract with all its elements. A seller who wants a credit sale should write the sale contract so that price, payment and transfer point are clear, and should not borrow hire-purchase wording without need.
If your concern is a debtor's asset that is subject to a finance company's hire-purchase, see debtor's car on hire-purchase, which is written from a creditor's enforcement point of view.
5. What if the buyer resells to a third party?
This is where retention of title is weakest when the buyer is a trader. Section 1332 provides that a person who buys property in good faith at an auction, in the open market or from a merchant who sells goods of that kind need not return it to the true owner unless the owner reimburses the price paid.
If your buyer is a merchant who normally sells that kind of goods and its customer bought in good faith, the original seller may well be unable to recover the goods from that customer without repaying the price. How the section applies in detail, for example whether the sub-buyer acted in good faith and whether the sale was from a merchant of that kind, depends on the facts and must be checked case by case.
In practice, the contract terms that help operate against the buyer, not the third party:
- No resale before payment, or only ordinary-course resale with an obligation to disclose the sub-buyer's name.
- An assignment of the buyer's claim for the resale price, or at least a duty to pay the seller first from the proceeds. This is hard to draft and its legal effect must be checked before use.
- A duty to report each resale.
- For a large lot about to be resold, agreement in advance that the seller is paid before delivery to the end customer.
These terms do not guarantee that the seller can follow the goods, but they give the seller contractual claims against the buyer and evidence that the buyer broke the agreement.
6. What if the goods are processed, mixed or installed in the buyer's property?
Three situations are common.
- Raw material turned into other products. The buyer uses metal, plastic pellets or ingredients to make finished goods. The original material may no longer exist in its original form and is hard to identify.
- Mixed with someone else's material. Material is poured into the same tank or silo as another supplier's, and nobody can tell whose is whose.
- Installed in the buyer's property. Machinery is bolted to the factory floor, connected to a production line or fixed to a building. Removal may cause damage or affect property belonging to someone else, such as the landlord of the building the buyer rents.
In these cases the effect of retention of title on goods that have changed form or merged with other property should not be treated as certain. The answer depends on whether the goods can still be separated, who owns the other property involved, and what the contract says. A clause giving the seller rights in finished products or in sale proceeds must be drafted precisely, and its effect against third parties must be checked. Do not assume that writing it down gives full effect.
A practical response is to separate goods that will be processed or installed from goods that will not, and to apply different measures. For consumable raw materials, for example, use shorter credit, faster collection or other security, instead of relying on the clause alone.
If machinery is seized in another creditor's case, a seller that is still the owner may need to file an objection to the seizure. See a third party claims seized property is theirs, which explains this from the viewpoint of the seizing creditor and the claimant.
7. What if the buyer is in financial trouble, bankrupt or in rehabilitation?
When the buyer has many creditors, the seller hopes the clause lets it avoid queuing with them. Whether it does depends on several things.
- Whether the goods are still there and can be identified (section 3).
- Whether the clause was clearly agreed and can be proved.
- Whether the buyer has already resold, processed or installed the goods (sections 5 and 6).
- The bankruptcy or rehabilitation procedure itself, which involves an officer who takes control of assets, deadlines for filing claims and, during rehabilitation, stays on some enforcement. A seller with retention of title should not assume it can simply go in and take the goods.
- Whether secured creditors such as a bank also claim rights over the stock or machinery.
In practice, once you learn the buyer is in trouble, stop delivering further goods without payment, gather the delivery notes, contract and stock records immediately, photograph the goods, and take advice before filing or accepting any document. The procedures are explained in the creditor's guide to bankruptcy and rehabilitation.
8. The buyer has defaulted. How do you get the goods back?
A sensible order is as follows.
- Check that the clause is in a contract the buyer accepted and see what it says about collecting goods on default.
- Send a notice requiring payment or return of the goods, with a deadline and a list of the goods, by a method that proves delivery.
- Agree a date and time for collection, have the buyer sign a record of what is returned, and photograph the goods before and after.
- If the buyer refuses, hides the goods or has sold them, take advice on a claim for return of the goods or for the price, including interim measures before judgment. See interim protection before judgment if there is reason to fear that assets will be moved.
- After judgment, recovery goes through enforcement, not self-help.
The most important warning: do not enter the buyer's factory or warehouse to remove goods without consent, cut chains, break locks or dismantle machinery yourself, even if you believe the goods are yours. That may create civil or criminal liability for the seller, and it can turn the buyer into the one with a complaint.
Documents and steps to prepare before delivering on credit
- A sale contract or purchase order containing the retention clause, signed by the buyer's authorised person
- A clear statement of the transfer point, saying what must be paid in full
- Quotation, purchase order, delivery note and invoice that say the same thing
- A delivery note signed by the buyer, showing model, serial or batch number, quantity and where the goods are installed or kept
- Dated photographs of the goods and of any plate or marking on them
- An agreement to keep the goods separate and to provide stock reports on a schedule
- Agreed terms on insurance and care of the goods
- Terms on resale, processing and installation
- A right to inspect stock, and a procedure for recovering goods on default
- A duty on the buyer to notify at once if anyone claims the goods or they are seized
- Other security used alongside, such as a deposit, a credit limit or a guarantor
- A named person on the seller's side who checks stock and follows up payment on a schedule
Hypothetical example: a manufacturer sells a packing machine and plastic pellets to the same factory
This is not a real case. All figures are illustrative and only explain the principle.
Company A sells Factory B one automatic packing machine for 2,400,000 baht and 20 tonnes of plastic pellets for 800,000 baht, on 60 days' credit. The contract and purchase order signed by B say ownership passes when B has paid the price of each item in full. The machine's serial number appears on the delivery note and a plate is fixed to it. The pellets have a batch number on the delivery note, but B tips them into the same silo as pellets bought from other suppliers.
After 60 days B has not paid and there are rumours of cash-flow trouble.
| Item | Status | How certain the clause is |
|---|---|---|
| Packing machine | Still at the factory, fixed to the floor, plate bearing the serial number | Reasonably identifiable, but removal must consider the floor and the production line, and must not infringe anyone's rights |
| Unused pellets | Mixed with other suppliers' pellets in the silo | Hard to show which part is A's |
| Pellets made into products | Partly resold to B's customers | Very weak, especially if B's customers bought in good faith from a trader of that kind |
What A should do: ask B for a joint stock check and a signed record, send a notice requiring payment by a deadline, and if B will not return the machine, take advice on a claim or interim measures. A should not send people to take the machine without consent. If B is sued for bankruptcy or applies for rehabilitation, A must follow the statutory procedure and keep all evidence about the tagged machine.
The lesson: an identifiable machine has a better chance of being protected by the clause than raw material that was mixed and processed, so the seller should plan separately for the two kinds of goods.
Common misunderstandings
| Misunderstanding | Correction |
|---|---|
| Once retention of title is written in, the seller can take the goods back in every case | The clause lets the seller argue that ownership has not passed, but the real outcome depends on the wording, the evidence and the state of the goods. Recovery in every case cannot be promised |
| The seller can go in and remove the goods because it is still the owner | Taking possession without consent may be an offence or create civil liability. It needs the buyer's cooperation or a court and enforcement route |
| A credit sale with retention of title is hire-purchase | They are different contracts. Hire-purchase under section 572 is a letting with a promise to sell or let property pass, and must be in writing |
| The clause follows the goods to a sub-buyer | A good-faith buyer from a merchant who sells goods of that kind may not have to return them under section 1332 unless the owner reimburses the price |
| Goods that have been processed still belong to the original seller | The position weakens sharply when goods are processed, mixed or installed so that they cannot be separated, and the effect must be checked case by case |
| On buyer bankruptcy the clause always lets the seller take the goods ahead of other creditors | The statutory procedure applies and the seller must prove the goods are still there and are theirs. The result is uncertain |
| Printing the clause on the back of the delivery note is enough | If the buyer never saw or agreed to it, it is hard to prove. Have the buyer sign the contract or purchase order |
Limits of this guide. This guide explains the Civil and Commercial Code rules on sale and hire-purchase and their effect on good-faith buyers. It does not cover registration of security under other laws, international sales that may be governed by foreign law, tax terms, or the detailed steps of bankruptcy and rehabilitation. Have a lawyer review the actual contract and documents before relying on them.
Further reading
- Customer credit terms and credit limit policy
- Unpaid invoices from business customers
- Machinery not meeting specification
- A third party claims seized property is theirs
- Creditor's guide to bankruptcy and rehabilitation
A retention-of-title clause lets a seller keep claiming ownership while waiting for payment, but it works best when it is clearly written, signed by the buyer, tied to identifiable goods that have not been resold, mixed or processed, and getting the goods back still requires cooperation or a court process.
We help sellers draft sale and retention-of-title terms, review delivery and stock documents, structure security, and advise when a buyer defaults or runs into financial trouble, including preparing notices and taking court action. We are not tax advisers or accountants, and we cannot promise that goods will be returned or a debt paid. Fees depend on the stage of the matter and the work required. Send us the documents first, and we will give you the scope of work and fees in writing before we start. Call +66 92 254 2045 or send us the details. See also contracts and documents and business services.
This guide is published by Suwanvara Law Firm — a Khon Kaen law firm established in 1986. General information only, not legal advice on a specific matter.

