Skip to main content
SUWANVARA LAWFIRM
Suwanvara Law Firm Co., Ltd.
SUWANVARA LAWFIRM
SUWANVARA LAWFIRM
Suwanvara Law Firm Co., Ltd.
Business Law

Sales Promised the Customer but Production Cannot Deliver: Using One Set of Data with S&OP

How a Thai SME can run a monthly S&OP meeting so sales, production, purchasing and finance work from the same orders, capacity, materials and cash data, with a rush-job approval path and order-acceptance terms that reduce promises operations has not confirmed.

Suwanvara Law Firm— Business Law TeamNovember 21, 202613 min read
Sales Promised the Customer but Production Cannot Deliver: Using One Set of Data with S&OP

The core answer

When sales promises a customer something production cannot deliver, it is rarely because anyone acted in bad faith. Each function looks at a different set of numbers. Sales sees orders and customers, production sees machines and people, purchasing sees the materials on order, finance sees cash in the bank. Nobody sees the whole picture until the customer asks where the goods are.

The fix that works for an SME is a monthly S&OP (Sales and Operations Planning) meeting where every function puts the same figures on the table: confirmed orders, expected orders, usable capacity, materials on hand and on order, and the cash available. It ends with one plan and a named owner for each action. Two rules support it: rush jobs need an approval path, and any delivery date given to a customer must come from a schedule production has confirmed.

The legal side arises where sales writes a delivery date and terms into a quotation or order acknowledgement. Those documents may bind the company, so operations should confirm before they go out.

Who should read which section

Your stageSections to read
Before deciding (no such meeting yet, or considering a large order)Sections 1, 2, 3 and 7
In progress (a rush order has arrived, or you are setting up the cycle)Sections 4, 5, 6 and the checklist
When the numbers are off plan (late delivery, customer claims, tight cash)Sections 5, 6, 8 and the hypothetical example

1. Why do sales and production see things differently?

Four causes are common, and each is fixed by organising information, not by replacing people.

  • Sales is rewarded for revenue. Taking another order always looks good from its side, while the cost of rushing or late delivery lands on other functions.
  • The numbers live in different places. Orders sit in sales documents or chat apps, capacity sits in the plant manager's head, materials sit in purchasing's file.
  • There is no shared decision point. When a new order collides with an old one, who decides which to delay? Without a rule, the loudest voice wins.
  • The customer hears the answer before production hears the question. The delivery date is spoken in the negotiating room and reaches the plant afterwards.

Sales forecasting and deal status are covered in Sales pipeline, quotations and sales forecast, and monthly forecast updates in Rolling forecast. This page does not repeat them. It starts where sales already has numbers and asks whether operations can carry them.

2. What are the steps of a monthly S&OP, and who must be in the room?

Use four steps a month, finished within 4 to 6 working days.

StepWhoOutput
1. Demand reviewSalesConfirmed orders and expected orders, split into key customers and others
2. Supply reviewProduction, purchasingUsable capacity (machine hours, people, shifts), materials on hand and on order, supplier lead times
3. Match and cash checkFinanceThe gap between demand and supply, and the cash needed for materials or overtime
4. Decision meetingManagement and function headsOne plan, owners, and what sales must not promise this month

The people in the room must be able to decide on money and timing. If delegates cannot decide, the meeting turns into a status report.

If you already hold a monthly management meeting, add S&OP as one agenda item instead of scheduling another. See Monthly management meeting agenda.

3. What does "one set of data" need to contain?

Use a single file all functions can open, with an owner for every column.

DataOwnerWhat it needs
OrdersSalesOrder number, customer, quantity, date the customer wants, date the company confirmed, status (confirmed / awaiting customer / unconfirmed)
CapacityProductionWeekly output, split into normal shift and overtime, maintenance windows, known bottlenecks
Materials and componentsPurchasingStock on hand, on order with arrival dates, supplier lead times, items often short
CashFinanceInflows, outflows, and headroom for off-plan purchases. See 13-week cash flow forecast
Finished goods stockProduction or warehouseQuantity available to sell now and quantity already reserved

The single most useful rule is to keep confirmed orders separate from expected orders. This month's production plan uses confirmed orders. Expected orders are used only to prepare materials and staffing.

4. Where must the delivery date given to a customer come from?

The big problem arises when sales writes a date in a document before production has answered. Three practical rules:

  • One source for delivery dates. Sales quotes dates from the capacity schedule production has confirmed, not from instinct or from what the customer asked for.
  • Answer with a range or a condition when unsure. "We will confirm the delivery date in writing within 2 working days" is better than a date nobody has checked.
  • Add a "date production confirmed" field to the order form. If it is empty, sales should not send the acknowledgement yet.

The same order works for normal orders and rush jobs, and it connects to the order-acceptance terms in section 6.

5. How should a rush job be approved without wrecking the plan?

A rush job is an order that arrives outside the plan and needs goods faster than the normal schedule allows. The costs often hide in overtime, materials bought at rush prices, line changeovers, and other orders pushed back. Write the rules before the event.

Rush-job approval steps

  1. Sales completes a rush request: customer, quantity, date required, order value, estimated gross margin, and why the customer needs it fast.
  2. Production answers whether it is possible and how (overtime, extra shift, subcontracting), and which orders would move.
  3. Purchasing answers whether materials are sufficient and, if not, when extra stock would arrive and at what price.
  4. Finance answers whether cash can cover it and how it affects this customer's credit terms.
  5. The approver at the right level decides and records the reason on the form.

Example approval levels (adapt to your company)

CaseApprover
Doable on a normal shift, no effect on other ordersProduction manager
Needs overtime or off-plan materials within a preset limitProduction manager with finance
Above the limit, or a key customer's order must be delayedManagement
Payment or deposit terms must changeManagement with the person authorised to sign for the company

Record the rush cost against that order, so sales sees the margin after rush costs and can use it when a customer asks for rush jobs repeatedly. If material costs have shifted enough to affect price, see Raw material price adjustment clauses.

6. How do order-acceptance terms reduce promises operations has not confirmed?

When sales writes a delivery date and terms into a document, that document is more than a sales tool. Under Civil and Commercial Code section 359, an acceptance that adds to, limits or modifies the offer is treated as a rejection and at the same time a new offer. So if the company acknowledges a customer's purchase order and changes the delivery date, the acknowledgement may be a new offer that the customer has not yet accepted. If the customer then takes the goods or carries on, the wording of the last document may carry a lot of weight. The result depends on the full set of documents and conduct. For conflicting documents, see Quotation and purchase order with conflicting terms.

Terms to align with the S&OP plan:

TermHow to write itLinked data
Delivery dateState whether it is an estimate or confirmed, and when the clock starts (for example, from receipt of the deposit and customer-approved drawings)Capacity schedule
Minimum and maximum quantitySet a range per order or per month; anything beyond needs a new agreementCapacity, materials
Price validityState how many days the quotation holds and what can change the price before confirmationMaterial prices and lead times
Changes and cancellationState the notice period within which changes are allowed, the effect of changes after production starts, and costs the customer bearsProduction plan, materials stock
Rush jobsState that a rush needs written confirmation and whether it carries an extra chargeOutput of the rush approval
Deposit and paymentTie the production start date to receipt of the depositCash
Delay caused by the customerState that late approval of drawings or data moves the delivery date accordinglyCapacity schedule

Do not write terms the company cannot actually perform, for example "delivery within 7 days in all cases" when the schedule cannot support it. Terms that overreach come back as the company's own burden.

If a contract or document includes late-delivery penalties or damages, whoever reviews contracts should see it before signing. See Contract review before signing without a legal department.

7. What should you ask before accepting a large order?

Ask four questions before accepting a large or fast order.

  • Is there enough spare capacity? If not, whose order is delayed, or should a shift be added?
  • Are materials sufficient, and can suppliers deliver in time?
  • Can cash carry it? When does the customer pay, and how much must the company lay out first?
  • If delivery is late, what can the customer claim under the contract, and what would it cost the company?

If you cannot answer any of them, reply with a condition such as "we will confirm capacity and materials by [date] and respond in writing" instead of promising at once.

8. What should you do first when the numbers go off plan?

  • If you know delivery will be late, tell the customer before the due date, with a new date production has confirmed. Silence until delivery day harms the relationship more than early notice.
  • Check what the contract or acknowledgement says on delivery date, effect of delay, and cancellation rights. If there is a dispute or a threat of suit, consult a lawyer before replying.
  • If the cause is cost or an outside event, see Force majeure versus cost increases to see whether such an event counts as force majeure under the contract, which it often does not automatically.
  • Trace where the failure happened: a promise before confirmation, stale capacity data, or materials that did not arrive. Fix the rule in the next S&OP cycle.

9. Checklist: set up S&OP within a month

  • Pick a monthly meeting date and attendees who can decide on money and timing
  • Build one data file, separating confirmed orders from expected orders
  • Name an owner for every column and set an update deadline before the meeting
  • Define how usable capacity is measured, including bottlenecks and maintenance
  • Add a "date production confirmed" field to the order form and acknowledgement
  • Write the rush request form and the approval table by cost threshold
  • Review order-acceptance terms and quotations so they match what the plant can do
  • Have finance record the cash effect of every rush job
  • Keep a record of decisions and owners each time
  • After the first cycle, review how far plan and actual differed and why

10. Hypothetical example: a customer asks for 400 extra pieces in three weeks

This is a hypothetical, not a real case or company. All figures are illustrative.

A hypothetical company makes plastic parts. Normal-shift capacity is about 1,000 pieces a month, with 900 pieces already confirmed. A large customer calls sales asking for 400 more in 3 weeks. Sales wants the job because it is worth about 200,000 baht.

Item (illustrative figures)Result from one set of data
Spare capacity on the normal shift100 pieces
Pieces that need rushing300, through overtime or an extra shift
Estimated overtime and changeover cost30,000 baht
Extra materials to buyAbout 60,000 baht, arriving in 10 days
Cash laid out before the customer pays90,000 baht, with 45-day customer credit
Estimated gross margin on the rush jobLower than sales assumed; calculate after rush costs

Sales does not accept at once. It tells the customer "we will confirm capacity and materials within 2 working days" and completes a rush request. The production manager says the first 300 pieces can be done by week 3, but the other 100 must ship in week 4. Purchasing confirms materials. Finance confirms cash. Management approves because the amount exceeds the production manager's limit.

The acknowledgement states: 300 pieces by the set date and the other 100 the following week, counted from receipt of the deposit and approved drawings. The rush charge is stated clearly. If the customer returns the acknowledgement with changed terms, the company treats no agreement as formed until both sides agree again in writing.

In this example the company avoids promising all 400 pieces in 3 weeks and then scrambling. In a real case the result can differ, depending on the contract, suppliers and each company's figures.

Common misunderstandings

  • "S&OP is one more meeting." Not necessarily. If you already hold a monthly management meeting, make it one agenda item. What changes is that every function brings the same numbers.
  • "We need ERP software first." Not necessarily. A spreadsheet with clear data owners and update dates works. Most problems are about data discipline, not tools.
  • "Put the delivery date in the quotation now and fix it later." It may not be easy to fix. A document that has gone out can be a binding offer. Have production confirm first.
  • "If our acknowledgement states our terms, the customer must accept them." Not always. If the text differs from the customer's purchase order, it may be a new offer the customer has not accepted. The result depends on the documents and conduct in each case.
  • "A rush job is a chance to earn more." Not always. After overtime, rush-priced materials and delayed orders, the margin may be lower than expected. Calculate before approving.
  • "Follow this page and we will never deliver late." No. This page reduces unconfirmed promises, but breakdowns, late suppliers and changed orders still happen.

Limits of this guide. This page is not advice on production engineering, line design, accounting or tax. It gives no tax formulas or figures that would replace an accountant, and it does not say how any particular contract binds the parties, which requires the actual documents. Information as of 21 November 2026. If the law or practice changes, check with the relevant agency, such as the Department of Business Development and the Revenue Department.

Further reading

Have sales quote delivery dates only from the schedule production has confirmed, and have every function meet on the same figures each month; that does the most to cut promises the plant cannot keep.

We help companies set up order-acceptance terms, adjust quotation and acknowledgement wording to what operations can confirm, set rush-job approval authority, and review contracts with key customers. We are not production engineers, accountants or ERP consultants, and we cannot promise the outcome of negotiations with customers. Our fees depend on the stage of the matter and the work involved. Send us the documents first, and we will tell you the scope of work and fees in writing before we start. Call +66 92 254 2045 or send us the details. See also business plan and management systems.


This guide is published by Suwanvara Law Firm — a Khon Kaen law firm established in 1986. General information only, not legal advice on a specific matter.

Frequently asked questions

What is S&OP, and does an SME without a planning team need it?+

S&OP (Sales and Operations Planning) is a monthly meeting where sales, production, purchasing and finance look at the same figures on orders, capacity, materials and cash, then agree on one plan every function carries out. No law requires it. An SME does not need a planning team, but each data set needs a named owner and the meeting needs a fixed date.

What should sales tell a customer about the delivery date if it is unsure production can make it?+

Give a range or a condition, for example 'we will confirm the delivery date in writing within 2 working days', rather than an exact date straight away. Set a rule that any delivery date written in a quotation or order acknowledgement must come from a capacity schedule that production has confirmed.

Who should approve a rush job?+

Name approvers by position and set the thresholds in advance. For example, the production manager approves a rush job that needs no extra overtime or off-plan materials, finance co-approves anything above a set cash or cost limit, and management decides when another customer's order must be delayed.

Is a delivery date that sales gives a customer legally binding on the company?+

It may be, depending on whether the document is an offer or an acceptance and on what it says. A quotation or order acknowledgement stating a delivery date may be read as an agreement on timing if the customer accepts on those terms. A reply that adds changes is treated as a new offer under Civil and Commercial Code section 359. The result in each case depends on the actual documents and conduct.

Do we need ERP software before we can run S&OP?+

No. One shared spreadsheet is enough if each figure has a clear source, an owner, and is updated before every monthly meeting. Software can follow once volumes or SKU counts outgrow the spreadsheet.

Lawyer-client handshake symbolizing trust at Suwanvara Law Firm

Ready to hear your story

Get an initial consultation with one of our experienced attorneys.