The core answer
If the contract says the buyer must "buy or pay" a minimum quantity, the buyer will usually have to pay for the part it did not take, even if it could not resell the goods. This kind of clause moves the risk of falling sales onto the buyer from the moment the seller reserves capacity or raw materials. But not every figure in a contract binds equally. A forecast given so the seller can plan is different from a minimum the buyer is committed to, and features such as deferral, carry-forward and relief when end customers cut orders apply only if they are written in.
The legal rule (Civil and Commercial Code). If the amount payable for buying too little is treated as a contractual penalty, a court may reduce it to a reasonable amount when it is disproportionately high, considering all the creditor's lawful interests and not only financial ones (section 383). Once the penalty has been paid, the right to ask for a reduction lapses. And some arrangements may be treated as the price of the main obligation rather than a penalty, which leads to a different result.
Our practical view. Do not assume every take-or-pay clause works the same way. Before signing, work out which figures are forecasts and which are commitments, whether the count is per period or per year, whether volume can be carried forward, and who bears the risk when downstream sales fall. If you are already bound, read the wording before you agree to pay or refuse.
This guide is about minimum purchase commitments and shortfalls. If raw material costs change and you want to adjust prices, see raw material cost increases during a contract. For quotations and purchase orders that conflict, see quotation and purchase order with conflicting terms.
Who should read which part
| Your stage | Read |
|---|---|
| Not yet signed | Sections 1 to 4 on forecasts versus commitments, section 6 on negotiation points, and the pre-signing checklist in section 7 |
| Signed and running | Section 3 on deferral and carry-forward, section 4 on falling end-customer orders, and the monitoring checklist in section 7 |
| Dispute already started | Section 5 on price versus penalty, section 4 on the effect of reduced orders, then collect documents under section 7 |
1. What is the difference between a purchase forecast and a real purchase commitment?
Long-term supply contracts often contain several quantity figures in different places: the body of the contract, the schedules and messages exchanged along the way. What you must separate is which figure the buyer is bound to buy or pay for, and which is simply the buyer's expectation shared so the seller can plan.
| Type of figure | Nature | Typical wording | Usual effect |
|---|---|---|---|
| Forecast | The buyer informs the seller so it can arrange materials and capacity | "forecast", "expected", "for planning purposes" | Usually does not oblige the buyer to buy, though some contracts let the seller recover the cost of materials ordered in line with the forecast |
| Minimum quantity to buy | The buyer agrees to buy no less than this in each period | "must purchase not less than", "minimum quantity" | The buyer has a duty to buy; buying less is a breach or triggers the shortfall payment the contract sets |
| Take-or-pay | The buyer pays for the minimum even if it does not take the goods | "must pay even if not taken", "shortfall payment" | The buyer pays the shortfall without taking delivery, by the formula in the contract |
| Maximum the seller must reserve | The ceiling the seller commits to supply | "maximum quantity", "reserved capacity" | A burden on the seller, not a purchase obligation of the buyer |
When documents give different figures, first identify which is the main contract and which is a schedule or purchase order, and whether the contract has a clause ranking its documents. If it does not, agree the position in writing before purchasing starts.
Points to check: what the figure is called, which document it is in, who gave it, when, and whether the contract states the consequence of buying less.
2. How does a take-or-pay clause work?
The clause usually has the following elements. A buyer should find each of them in its own contract.
- Minimum quantity and measurement period, for example per month, quarter or year. An annual count gives more flexibility than a monthly one.
- What counts as a purchase: when the goods are ordered, when the seller is ready to ship, when delivered or when taken. This matters a great deal once pickup is deferred.
- The shortfall formula. The shortfall is the minimum less the quantity actually bought, multiplied by the price or a share of the price. Some contracts charge the full price, others only part, because the seller saves the cost of what it did not produce.
- How and when the shortfall is invoiced: within how many days after the period ends, and how long the buyer has to dispute the figure.
- The buyer's rights after paying the shortfall, for example whether it can take that quantity later (see section 3).
- Exceptions and exits, such as events preventing the seller from supplying, force majeure, or a right to reduce volume on advance notice.
Such a clause is not unlawful in itself. A seller has real business reasons to ask for it, such as investment in machinery or advance purchase of materials. What the buyer should do is know how much risk it takes on before signing, and negotiate so that the burden matches what the seller has genuinely reserved.
3. When can pickup be deferred, volume carried forward, or a shortfall made up later?
A buyer close to missing its minimum often asks whether it can defer pickup or make it up next period. The answer depends on whether the contract grants the right. If it is silent, the buyer has no right to do this on its own and needs the seller's agreement.
| Mechanism | Meaning | What to look for in the contract |
|---|---|---|
| Deferral | The buyer asks the seller to hold the goods and take them later | How many times and for how long, who pays storage and bears the risk of the goods, whether the price changes |
| Carry-forward | Quantity bought above the minimum this period counts toward the next | For how many periods, and whether there is a cap |
| Make-up | A buyer who paid a shortfall takes that quantity in a later period | Within how many months, whether the old or current price applies, and whether it is paid for twice |
| Shortfall credit | The amount paid is deducted from later purchases | What it can be set against, and when it expires |
Points to watch when asking for relief:
- Ask in writing and get a reply. If the seller says "fine" in a chat message, confirm by email what was agreed, for how long and which period it affects.
- One waiver is not a permanent arrangement. If the seller relaxes the rule once, state clearly whether it is for this occasion only or a continuing practice.
- Do not assume a right has been lost because nothing has been demanded yet. Under section 381, if a creditor has accepted performance, it can claim the penalty only if it reserved its rights when accepting. A seller may therefore send reservation-of-rights wording when it takes payment or ships goods. Buyers should read those messages.
4. If my customers order less, do I still have to pay?
This is a common situation for raw material buyers and factories. The buyer has a supply contract with a seller and resells to its own customers. When those customers cut orders, the buyer buys less raw material. The question is whether the supply contract ties the minimum to downstream orders.
- The contract does not link them. The supply contract and the resale contracts are separate. The raw material seller is not a party to the latter. The risk of falling orders usually stays with the buyer unless the contract has an exception.
- The contract has a relief mechanism, for example reduced volume on advance notice with proof of lower orders, renegotiation of the minimum if orders fall beyond a stated percentage, or conversion to an annual quantity. Apply it as written and follow the stated steps, such as giving notice within a set number of days.
- Is it force majeure? Orders falling with the market or because a customer changes its plans is generally not force majeure in itself. See force majeure versus cost increases for how force majeure differs from ordinary business risk.
If the buyer already knows its volume will fall, it should tell the seller early. The seller may still be able to adjust its plans, and early notice makes it easier to negotiate options such as deferral or switching to another product, rather than waiting for the period to end and being invoiced for the shortfall.
5. Is a shortfall payment a price, or a penalty a court can reduce?
When a buyer misses the minimum and is invoiced a shortfall, the legal question is what that payment is, because it affects how it can be challenged.
Type 1: the price of the main obligation. The contract may make the buyer owe payment for the minimum quantity from the start. Paying the shortfall is then simply performing that obligation, not a sanction for breach. If the wording is like this, asking a court to reduce it is usually harder, because it is not a penalty.
Type 2: a penalty. The contract may say that if the buyer buys less, it is in breach and must pay a sum as compensation. That resembles a contractual penalty under section 379, under which the penalty is forfeited when the debtor defaults. The consequences are:
- The seller may claim the penalty instead of performance, but once it tells the buyer it will claim the penalty, it loses the right to demand performance (section 380, first paragraph).
- If the seller is entitled to damages, it may claim the penalty as the minimum amount of damages and may prove greater loss (section 380, second paragraph). On the scope of damages in general, section 222 refers to loss that normally arises from non-performance, and to loss from special circumstances that the parties foresaw or should have foreseen.
- If the penalty is for improper performance, the seller may claim it in addition to performance (section 381), but if it has accepted performance it can claim the penalty only if it reserved its rights when accepting.
- If the penalty forfeited is disproportionately high, the court may reduce it to a reasonable amount, considering all of the creditor's lawful interests and not only financial ones (section 383, first paragraph).
- Once the penalty has been paid, the right to seek a reduction lapses (section 383, second paragraph). A buyer should therefore dispute the figure before paying.
Which category a shortfall payment falls into depends on the wording, the structure of the contract and the facts, for example what the contract calls it, what costs the seller saved by not producing, and how the amount relates to real loss. Anyone facing a demand should have the whole contract reviewed before reaching a conclusion.
On a customer deducting penalties or damages from its own payment, see when a customer deducts penalties or damages from its payment. On penalties in purchase orders, see quotation and purchase order with conflicting terms.
6. Before signing or negotiating, what should you push for?
The table lists points buyers often negotiate. They are not fixed rules, and the outcome depends on bargaining power and the nature of each business.
| Issue | Question to ask | Options often seen |
|---|---|---|
| Measurement period | Monthly, quarterly or annual? | Annual or quarterly so highs and lows average out |
| Minimum level | Is it set above what you can realistically sell? | A percentage of forecast, or start low and rise as sales are proven |
| Tolerance band | Can you buy below it without a shortfall? | A permitted variance, such as plus or minus an agreed percentage |
| Shortfall formula | Full price, or only the seller's real loss? | A share of price after deducting costs the seller saves |
| Carry-forward and make-up | Can excess carry over? Can paid shortfall be taken later? | State the number of periods, the price used and an expiry date |
| Deferral | How many times, and who pays storage? | A limited right to defer on advance notice |
| End-customer orders fall | Is there a reduction or renegotiation mechanism? | State the threshold, notice steps and evidence required |
| Seller cannot supply | Does the minimum fall if the seller short-delivers? | Provide that quantities the seller fails to supply do not count as buyer shortfall |
| Term and renewal | How many years, automatic renewal? | See auto-renewal and notice dates |
| Price adjustment | Fixed price, or an adjustment formula? | See raw material cost increases during a contract |
| Liability cap | Is there a cap on shortfall plus damages? | See limitation of liability and indemnity |
7. Checklist before signing and during the contract
Before signing
- Mark every quantity figure in the contract and schedules as a forecast or a commitment
- Check that "must buy", "must pay" and "forecast" are not mixed up
- Check the measurement period, and whether purchase is counted at order, shipment or pickup
- Check the shortfall formula against your own lowest realistic sales forecast
- Check whether deferral, carry-forward, make-up and shortfall credit exist, and on what terms
- Check for exceptions when the seller cannot supply, on force majeure, or when end-customer orders fall
- Check the term, renewal and exit mechanisms
- Note the points you intend to negotiate and the ones you can accept if the other side will not move
During the contract
- Keep a monthly tracker of actual purchases against the minimum
- Warn the seller early when you see a shortfall coming, within any notice period the contract gives
- Keep every deferral, carry-forward and waiver in writing
- Keep evidence of falling end-customer orders if the contract refers to it
- Check every shortfall invoice, including formula, figures and period, before paying
If there is a dispute
- Gather the contract, schedules, purchase orders, emails and messages about quantities
- Prepare a table of ordered, taken and minimum quantities by period
- Check how far the seller actually prepared materials or capacity, if there is evidence
- Do not pay the shortfall before knowing whether it is a price or a penalty, because payment affects the right to a reduction under section 383
8. Hypothetical example: a plastics buyer misses the minimum after its own customer cuts orders
This example is not a real case. Names, figures and terms are illustrative only.
Company A makes plastic parts for an appliance maker. It signs a two-year contract to buy plastic resin from Company B. The contract sets an annual minimum of 600 tonnes, counted per year. A shortfall is payable at 40 percent of the per-tonne price (assumed), and the contract has no exception for falling end-customer orders and no carry-forward right.
At the end of year one, Company A has bought 450 tonnes because its customer cut orders. The shortfall is 150 tonnes. Company B invoices the shortfall at 40 percent of the price.
What Company A should check:
- The commitment. The 600 tonnes is written as "must purchase not less than", so it is a commitment, not a forecast.
- Why end-customer orders fell. The contract has no exception, so this is likely Company A's risk.
- The shortfall formula. Does 40 percent reflect the cost Company B did not incur by not producing, and are there figures to support it?
- What the payment is. If the contract describes it as an amount due under the purchase obligation, it may be a price. If it calls it a charge for breach, it may be a penalty a court can reduce under section 383 if disproportionately high.
- Disputing before payment. Any challenge must come before paying, because after paying a penalty the right to ask for a reduction lapses.
Company A could ask Company B to carry the shortfall into next year, or to treat it as credit toward other products, with the agreement in writing. The result depends on the contract and on Company B's willingness. There is no guarantee of a reduction or waiver.
Common misunderstandings
- "A forecast in the contract is the quantity I must buy." Not necessarily. A forecast for the seller's planning differs from a minimum the buyer is committed to. Look at the wording and the document it appears in.
- "If I cannot resell, I do not have to pay." Not necessarily. If the contract does not tie the minimum to end-customer orders, the risk usually stays with the buyer. Check whether there is an exception.
- "All take-or-pay clauses are the same." They are not. The measurement period, shortfall formula, carry-forward and exceptions differ, so the outcome differs. The same label can cover very different arrangements.
- "A court will always reduce a penalty." No. A court may reduce it when it is disproportionately high and the arrangement is a penalty, but some arrangements may be treated as a price, and once paid the right to seek a reduction lapses (section 383).
- "If the seller waived once, it will always waive." Not necessarily. Confirm in writing each time whether it is for this occasion only or ongoing.
- "The buyer can defer or carry forward on its own." Only if the contract grants the right. If it is silent, the seller's agreement is needed.
- "This guide tells you how your own clause works." It does not. It is general guidance, and each contract's wording can lead to a different result.
Limits of this guide. This guide covers minimum purchase commitments and shortfalls between businesses. It does not cover energy contracts or contracts governed by specific rules, the tax treatment of shortfall payments, or dispute details that turn on evidence in a particular matter. The real outcome can change with the contract wording and the facts. Information as of 21 November 2026. Have tax questions checked by an accountant or auditor.
Further reading
- Raw material cost increases during a contract: when can a company ask to adjust the price
- Quotation and purchase order with conflicting terms: which terms govern
- Force majeure versus cost increases
- When a customer deducts penalties or damages from its payment
- Auto-renewal and notice dates
- Limitation of liability and indemnity in contracts
Separate forecasts from real minimum commitments before you sign, and if you are invoiced a shortfall, check before paying whether it is a price or a penalty, because once it is paid the right to ask for a reduction under section 383 lapses.
We review minimum purchase commitments in a contract before signing, prepare a table separating forecasts from commitments, and plan the negotiation of purchase volumes. We also check shortfall invoices and demand letters you have received. We are not tax advisers or accountants, and we cannot guarantee that the other party will agree to a reduction or waiver. Our fees depend on the stage of the matter and the work required. Send us the documents first, and we will give you the scope of work and our fees in writing before we start. Call +66 92 254 2045 or send us the details. See also contracts and documents and business law services.
This guide is published by Suwanvara Law Firm — a Khon Kaen law firm established in 1986. General information only, not legal advice on a specific matter.

