Skip to main content
SUWANVARA LAWFIRM
Suwanvara Law Firm Co., Ltd.
SUWANVARA LAWFIRM
SUWANVARA LAWFIRM
Suwanvara Law Firm Co., Ltd.
Business Law

Before Signing a Long Lease or Buying Machinery: How to Test Three Scenarios (Base, Downside and Delayed)

How to test cash and loan covenants in three scenarios (base, below-plan sales, delayed start) before signing a long lease or buying machinery, with a hypothetical worked example, test tables and the contract terms that change the outcome: break clauses, subletting, buy-back and step rents.

Suwanvara Law Firm— Business Law TeamNovember 21, 202615 min read
Before Signing a Long Lease or Buying Machinery: How to Test Three Scenarios (Base, Downside and Delayed)

The core answer

Before signing a long lease or buying machinery, do not test the business plan with a single set of numbers. Test three scenarios: base (the plan), downside (sales or volume clearly below plan) and delayed (revenue starts late and sales are low at the same time). Ask the same three questions of each: how low does cash go in the worst month, are the loan covenants or minimum-cash tests still met, and what would it cost under the contract to get out?

Two points are often missed. First, a loan covenant can be breached before cash runs out. Second, the same contract term, such as an early termination right or a right to sublet, can turn a downside loss of millions into a loss of hundreds of thousands. The figures in this guide are hypothetical and only illustrate the method. They are not benchmarks for any business.

Our practical view: build the three-scenario table before you negotiate the contract, not after you sign. The result tells you which terms to ask for and sometimes that the project should start smaller.

This guide covers cash, covenants and the contract terms that change the result. For comparing investment options by payback, NPV and IRR, see Machinery, hiring or a new branch first when capital is limited, which already includes a return sensitivity test. For what to check in a ready-built factory lease specifically, see Ready-built factory lease.

Who should read which part

Your stageSections to read
Before decidingSections 1 to 5 to set assumptions and build the test table; sections 6 to 7 for the terms to negotiate before signing
In progressSection 8 to set warning signals and compare actual figures with the tested scenarios
Figures are off planSections 8 to 9 to see which exits in the contract still work and who should check what

1. Why test three scenarios instead of one plan?

A single-figure plan is usually the best case the owner believes in. But rent under a long lease and machine instalments are fixed commitments that do not fall with sales. When revenue misses the plan, the shortfall comes straight out of contribution, and falls faster than sales do.

Three scenarios show what one set of numbers cannot:

  • When cash is lowest and by how much, not just year-end profit.
  • When a covenant with the bank or supplier is breached, which can happen before cash is gone.
  • What the exit costs if you have to stop, scale down or move out.

The aim is not to predict the future precisely. It is to know in advance how far the plan can miss before the company cannot cope, and which terms to secure before signing.

2. Which assumptions should I vary?

Choose assumptions that move the result a lot and that you control least. Change them one at a time to see which hurts most, then combine them in the severe case.

AssumptionHow to vary itEvidence to hold
Sales or volumeReduce by a stated share, for example one quarter and two fifthsQuotations, order backlog, customer contracts, actual sales history
Date revenue really startsPush out 3 to 6 monthsInstallation schedule, permits, power supply, machine commissioning, staff training
Customer collection timeStretch from 30 days to 60 or 90Payment history of the largest customers
Variable costsRaise energy, materials and labour by the tested amountSupplier quotations, price history
Machine utilisationDowntime for repairs, or output below specificationManufacturer data, experience of users of the same model
Interest and exchange ratesRaise them if floating, or if the machine is importedTerms of the loan or import contract
Step rentApply the written increase every year, regardless of salesThe rent schedule in the lease

Rule of thumb: each adjustment needs a reason, for example one large customer is lost, not a round number guessed from nowhere. Link the result to a weekly cash plan as in the 13-week cash flow forecast.

3. How should the three scenarios be defined?

ScenarioMeaningQuestion it answers
BaseThe plan, backed by evidence rather than the most hopeful versionDoes the project work when things go well?
DownsideSales or volume clearly below plan; fixed costs unchangedDo covenants and contribution still hold?
Delayed (severe)Revenue starts late, sales are very low and fixed costs are already runningIs there enough cash to survive, and is there an exit in the contract?

The severe case must be something that can really happen, not an extreme disaster. If it is too harsh, no project passes and the owner stops using the method. If it is too mild, it tells you nothing. Ask: "What happens in roughly one in four businesses like this?" and use that as the base for the severe case.

4. Hypothetical example: a five-year factory lease and machinery bought on instalments

This is a hypothetical scenario to explain the method. It is not a real case, and all figures are illustrative, not industry benchmarks.

A hypothetical company will lease a small factory for 5 years and buy machinery on a 60-instalment plan to take on more work.

Starting data (baht per month)

ItemAmount
Rent60,000
Machine instalment48,000
2 additional staff40,000
Utilities, insurance and maintenance12,000
Total fixed costs160,000
Opening cash after down payment and deposit900,000
Contribution margin on sales (after variable costs)45%

Scenario assumptions

ScenarioExtra sales per monthRevenue starts
Base500,000Month 1
Downside (25% lower)375,000Month 1
Delayed (40% lower and 3 months late)300,000Month 4

Simple results

ResultBaseDownsideDelayed
Contribution per month225,000168,750135,000
Remainder after fixed costs of 160,000 per month+65,000+8,750-25,000 (and -160,000 a month for the first 3 months)
Cash at end of month 12 (from 900,000)1,680,0001,005,000195,000
Month cash falls below 300,000NeverNeverMonth 8

Observations from the example:

  • Monthly break-even sales for cash are about 355,600 baht (fixed costs of 160,000 divided by 45%), roughly 71% of plan.
  • The downside case looks safe because year-end cash is above 1 million baht, but section 5 shows a loan covenant has already been breached.
  • In the delayed case year-end cash is 195,000, but the minimum-cash test fails from month 8, and the remaining four years of commitments are the larger issue (sections 6 and 7).

5. How do I test cash and loan covenants in each scenario?

Test in two layers: cash first, then the conditions agreed with the lender or supplier (covenants), which usually fail first.

Tests to run

TestHow to read itWhat to record
Lowest cashRoll cash forward monthly through the heaviest-commitment periodThe month and the amount of the low point
Minimum cash under the loan or company policyCompare the low point with the thresholdThe month it goes below
Debt service coverage ratio (DSCR)(contribution after fixed costs other than instalments) divided by the instalmentThe ratio against the threshold in the contract
Months of runwayLowest cash divided by the monthly shortfallTime available to fix the problem
Knock-on effectDoes breaching one term trigger another contract (cross-default)?A list of linked contracts

The hypothetical example continued. Suppose the loan requires DSCR of at least 1.2 and cash of at least 300,000 baht. Both are illustrative, and a real contract may define them differently, so read the actual wording of the document you will sign.

ScenarioDSCR (112,000 is fixed costs other than the instalment)Meets 1.2?Lowest cashMeets the 300,000 floor?
Base(225,000 - 112,000) / 48,000 = 2.35YesNot below 900,000Yes
Downside(168,750 - 112,000) / 48,000 = 1.18NoAbout 900,000Yes
Delayed(135,000 - 112,000) / 48,000 = 0.48No195,000 at month 12No, from month 8

The downside case has enough cash but breaches the DSCR covenant. Depending on the contract, that could let the lender demand early repayment, ask for more security or reset terms. Sales that give a DSCR of exactly 1.2 are about 376,900 baht a month, and the downside case sits just below that.

Before signing a loan or hire-purchase agreement

  • Ask the bank or seller to state the covenant formula in writing, and the period tested (monthly, quarterly or annual).
  • Ask whether there is a cure period after a breach, and how many days it lasts.
  • Ask what follows a breach: a rate change, extra security or immediate repayment.
  • Check whether a term in one contract is tied to another (cross-default).

6. Which contract terms change the damage in a downside case?

The scenario table tells you how much it hurts. The contract tells you whether you can get out and what it costs. Read these terms with particular care before signing.

TermHow it changes the downsideWhat to check or ask for
Early termination right (break clause)Cuts years of remaining commitment to the notice period and the agreed costWho holds it, from when, how many months' notice, what deposit or fee is forfeited
Sublease and assignmentIf allowed, another tenant can take over and reduce the burdenIs consent needed, on what grounds can the landlord refuse, does the original tenant stay liable
Buy-back of the machineryLimits the loss on a machine that is unusable or not worthwhileA fixed buy-back price, the period, the condition required, who pays transport
Step rentFixed costs rise every year even if sales do notThe rent for each year, fixed amount or index-linked, any cap
Grace period on rent or instalments in the early monthsEases cash pressure while waiting for revenueUntil when, and counted from signing or from handover of the premises
Minimum commitments or take-or-payYou pay even if you do not useThe minimum, the period measured, any right to make up shortfalls later
Penalties and accelerationOne missed instalment may bring the whole balance dueDefault triggers, cure period, whether the penalty is excessive
GuaranteesThe burden may fall personally on directors or ownersWho guarantees, whether the amount or period can be capped
Force majeure and late deliveryHelps if the landlord or seller delivers late and revenue starts lateWhen rent starts, whether the seller compensates delay

Legal points (Civil and Commercial Code, information as at 21 November 2026)

  • Section 544: a tenant may not sublet or transfer its rights to a third party unless the lease provides otherwise, and if the tenant breaches this the landlord may terminate the lease. If subletting is your exit, write the right into the lease.
  • Section 538: a lease of immovable property needs written evidence signed by the party to be bound, otherwise it cannot be enforced in court. If the lease runs for more than three years and is not in writing and registered with the competent official, it can be enforced for only three years. A long-term investor must check registration.
  • Section 383: if a penalty is excessive, the court may reduce it to a reasonable amount. Do not build a cash plan on this, because it depends on court proceedings and the facts of each case.

Hire-purchase contracts, machinery sale contracts and service contracts may carry other specific rules. Check each contract individually.

7. How do the terms change the numbers in the example?

The hypothetical example continued. Suppose the company in section 4 decides to leave at the end of month 12 because it is in the severe case, and compare two situations. The figures are illustrative and exclude transport, restoration costs and legal costs.

ItemWithout helpful termsWith helpful terms (hypothetical)
Rent remaining48 months x 60,000 = 2,880,0003 months' notice, 3 more months of rent = 180,000, plus forfeited deposit of 120,000, total 300,000
MachineryRemaining instalments 48 x 48,000 = 2,304,000Seller buys back at an agreed 1,500,000, gap to pay 804,000
Approximate total exposure5,184,0001,104,000

The outside circumstances are identical. Two contract terms reduce the exposure from over 5 million baht to about 1.1 million. That may still exceed the cash left (195,000), but it is a figure that can be renegotiated or financed far more easily.

Step rent quietly makes things worse. If rent rises 5% a year, year-5 rent is about 72,900 baht a month (from 60,000). Fixed costs grow without sales growing. Put the step into the test table for every year instead of using year-1 rent throughout.

8. After signing, what warning signals should I set, and what should I do when figures drift toward the downside?

After signing, compare actual monthly figures with the three scenarios you tested, and write decision points in advance, while things are not yet tight.

SignalDecision point to set beforehand
Actual sales below plan for 2 months in a rowRevisit the forecast and talk to the lender before a covenant is breached
DSCR approaching the contract thresholdAsk for a waiver or reset in advance rather than after the breach
Cash below the set levelStop deferrable spending, ask suppliers for terms, speed up collection
Approaching the date to exercise a break right or give noticeRecord the date in the contract register and decide before the last day
Machine performing below specificationNotify the seller in writing within the period in the contract and keep evidence

When the figures are already off plan, first check whether the exits in the contract are still available: when a break right can be used, when notice must be given, whose consent a sublease needs, and approach the lender before default rather than after. For notice-date discipline see auto-renewing contracts and the notice date register, and for cost shocks see force majeure vs cost increase.

9. Who should check what?

MatterSuitable reviewer
Contract terms, break rights, sublease, buy-back, lease registration, guaranteesA lawyer
Tax and accounting treatment of leases, hire purchase and depreciationAn accountant or auditor (a law firm does not give tax rates or tax figures)
Sales and cost assumptionsThe owner, sales and production teams
Covenant formulasThe bank or lender, together with whoever prepares the company's accounts

Checklist before signing

  • Write down the main assumptions and the evidence for each (sales, revenue start, collection time, costs)
  • Build the three-scenario table and find the lowest-cash month in each
  • Find monthly cash break-even sales and compare with plan
  • Test every loan covenant (DSCR, minimum cash, others) in every scenario
  • Put the annual step rent into the table for each year
  • Check that a lease of more than three years is in writing and registered, or will be
  • Ask for an early termination right, a right to sublet or assign, and a buy-back, each with clear figures
  • Check penalties, acceleration, guarantees and cross-default
  • Set warning signals and record key dates in the contract register
  • Have an accountant check the tax effects and a lawyer check the draft before signing

Common misunderstandings

  • "If year-end cash is still positive, we are safe." Not necessarily. A covenant may be breached first, and cash can hit its lowest point mid-year before recovering. Look month by month.
  • "A five-year lease means we can leave whenever we cannot cope." Not so. Without a termination right in the contract, leaving on your own may be a breach, and the remaining commitment depends on each contract.
  • "Subletting is always the way out." Under section 544 the general rule is that it is not allowed unless the lease says so, and breaching it lets the landlord terminate.
  • "The court will reduce a high penalty anyway, so I need not worry." Section 383 lets the court reduce it, but that is discretionary, requires proceedings and should not be the basis of cash planning.
  • "The seller said they would buy it back." A salesperson's words are not a contract term. The price, the required condition and the period need to be written down.
  • "The example figures apply to my business." All figures here are hypothetical. Use your own numbers and your own contracts.

Further reading

Before signing a long lease or buying machinery, test three scenarios with monthly cash and loan covenants, then negotiate the terms that let you exit, because contract terms change the damage far more than the sales figures you cannot control.

We review and draft leases, hire-purchase and machinery sale contracts, help rank the terms worth negotiating from your test results, and prepare the commitments section that supports a business plan. We are not accountants or tax advisers, we do not decide whether your business should invest, and we cannot promise the outcome of negotiations with a landlord, seller or bank. Our fees depend on the stage of the matter and the work involved. Send us your documents first, and we will set out the scope of work and our fees in writing before we start. Call +66 92 254 2045 or send us the details. See also business plan and contracts and documents.


This guide is published by Suwanvara Law Firm — a Khon Kaen law firm established in 1986. General information only, not legal advice on a specific matter.

Frequently asked questions

How many scenarios should I test before signing a long lease or buying machinery?+

At least three: a base case that follows the plan, a downside case where sales or volume come in clearly below plan, and a severe or delayed case where revenue starts late and sales are low at the same time. For each, answer three questions: how low does cash go, are the loan covenants still met, and what would it cost under the contract to get out.

Which assumptions should I vary?+

Vary the ones that move the result a lot and that you control least: sales or volume, the date revenue really starts, customer collection time, energy and labour costs, machine utilisation, and the interest rate if it floats. Change them one at a time first, then together in the severe case.

Which contract terms change the outcome most when sales fall short?+

The terms that decide when you can leave and what it costs: an early termination right and its notice period, the right to sublet or assign, a buy-back of the machinery and its price, annual step rents, minimum commitments, penalty clauses and director guarantees. Negotiate them before signing, because your leverage drops sharply afterwards.

Can a tenant sublet or assign the lease without the landlord's agreement?+

Under Civil and Commercial Code section 544, the tenant generally may not sublet or transfer its rights to a third party unless the lease provides otherwise, and if the tenant breaches this the landlord may terminate the lease. If subletting is meant to be your exit, the lease must say so from the start.

What applies to a lease of immovable property for more than three years?+

Under section 538, if a lease of immovable property runs for more than three years and is not made in writing and registered with the competent official, it can be enforced in court for only three years. A tenant who invests in machinery or fit-out for the long term should check this before signing.

Lawyer-client handshake symbolizing trust at Suwanvara Law Firm

Ready to hear your story

Get an initial consultation with one of our experienced attorneys.